There are so many different programs that format yearbooks for you like Blurb, Mixbook, Artifact Uprising, My Publisher, Picaboo, Lulu, and places like Costco or Walmart. I have tried all of these but I personally like Shutterfly the best. I find their quality and processing to be my favorite (especially with all of their deals and giveaways) but to each their own!
Year in review page. This just sums everything up right as you open it. Highlights, additions, current living situation, hobbies, things you learned? You can create anything really!
Obvious occasions. Birthday, holidays, anniversary, and BIG events/parties.
Summer fun page. Let's be real, we live in Canada so the majority of our adventurous photos exist in a span of 3-4 months! :P I generally have a good collection so summer gets it's own pages. Reunions, Magrath Days and 70% of my family's birthdays? It's just a PARTY season!
Jar of hearts page. I have a jar with a wooden heart attached to it sitting in our kitchen. Plain sight. Throughout the year Jason and I jot down memories, thoughts, or funny moments and toss them in the jar. Every New Years Eve we read them one by one. Jason laughs, I get a little teary, and then I also laugh bahaa. It's another chart-topping tradition that I love! I then type these out with their dates on a page at the end of our yearbook just for future reference. It's a bit more personal to see the day-to-day thoughts rather than just photos + Jason joins in. If he enjoys it I know it's good!
Whatever else page. My photos generally tell me what else I should include or if I missed a prime photo. It's also a good time to do a little photo clean up. If there are photos you skip, delete them!