Having ADHD along with a coexisting disruptive behavior disorder (ODD/CD) can complicate diagnosis and treatment and also worsen the prognosis. Even though many children with ADHD ultimately adjust, some (especially those with an associated conduct or oppositional defiant disorder) are more likely to drop out of school, have fewer years of overall education, have less job satisfaction and fare less well as adults. Early diagnosis and treatment of these conditions is by far the best defense against these poorer outcomes.
What are the types of disruptive behavior disorders?
Disruptive behavior disorders include two similar disorders: oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) and conduct disorder (CD). Common symptoms occurring in children with these disorders include: defiance of authority figures, angry outbursts, and other antisocial behaviors such as lying and stealing. It is felt that the difference between oppositional defiant disorder and conduct disorder is in the severity of symptoms and that they may lie on a continuum often with a developmental progression from ODD to CD with increasing age.
These behaviors must be exhibited more frequently than in other children of the same age and must cause significant impairment in social, academic or occupational functioning to warrant the diagnosis.
Conduct disorder (CD) involves more serious behaviors including aggression toward people or animals, destruction of property, lying, stealing and skipping school. The behaviors associated with CD are often described as delinquency. Children exhibiting these behaviors should receive a comprehensive evaluation.
Children and adolescents with ADHD and CD often have more difficult lives and poorer outcomes than children with ADHD alone.
Approximately one-third to one-half of all children with ADHD may have coexisting oppositional defiant disorder (ODD). These children are often disobedient and have outbursts of temper. The rate of children meeting full diagnostic criteria for ODD is similar across all ages. Males have a greater incidence of ADHD and ODD, as do children of divorced parents and mothers with low socioeconomic status. Children with the ADHD combined subtype seem to be more likely to have ODD.
In some cases, children with ADHD may eventually develop conduct disorder (CD), a more serious pattern of antisocial behaviors. Conduct disorder may occur in 25 percent of children and 45 percent of adolescents with ADHD. CD is more commonly seen in boys than girls, and increases in prevalence with age. Children with ADHD who also meet diagnostic criteria for CD are twice as likely to have difficulty reading, and are at greater risk for social and emotional problems. Non-aggressive conduct problems increase with age, while aggressive symptoms become less common.
Given the high co-occurrence of ADHD with disruptive behavior disorders, all children with ADHD symptoms and disruptive behaviors need to be assessed for the possibility that ODD or CD may be present in addition to ADHD.
Children with ADHD and CD are often at higher risk for contact with the police and the court system than children with ADHD alone. These children frequently lie or steal and tend to disregard the welfare of others. In addition, they risk getting into serious trouble at school or with the police. The risk for legal troubles may be mostly attributable to the symptoms of CD rather than ADHD.
Disruptive behavior disorders and untreated ADHD have been found to lead to an increased risk of substance use disorders. In addition, adolescents with disruptive behaviors disorders and ADHD are more likely to be aggressive and hostile in their interactions with others, and to be arrested. It has also been suggested that the greater impulsivity associated with the ADHD may cause greater antisocial behavior and its consequences. Thus, early recognition and treatment of both the ADHD and disruptive behaviors in children is essential.
All children with symptoms of ADHD and ODD/CD need to be assessed so that both types of problem behaviors can be treated. These children are difficult to live with and parents need to understand that they do not need to deal with their ADHD and ODD/CD child alone. Interventions such as parent training at home and behavioral support in the school can make a difference and parents should not hesitate to ask for assistance.
Parent Training (PT): Parent training has been shown to be effective for treating oppositional and defiant behaviors. Standardized parent training programs are short-term interventions that teach parents specialized strategies including positive attending, ignoring, the effective use of rewards and punishments, token economies, and time out to address clinically significant behavior problems. Such training programs may include periodic booster sessions.
Severe cases of CD may require multisystemic therapy, an intensive family- and community-based treatment that addresses the multiple causes of serious antisocial behavior in youth. This approach is very comprehensive and demanding. The therapist using such an approach must possess access to developmental and clinical expertise. These intervention services are delivered in a variety of settings, such as home, school and peer groups. Academic and school-based problems are included and some therapists work directly with an entire peer group to influence change.
Parent-child interaction therapy is a treatment that teaches parents to strengthen the relationship with their child and to learn behavior management techniques. It has been found to be effective in the long term for young children with ODD and ADHD. Three to six years after treatment, the mothers of children with these disorders reported that the changes in their children’s behavior and their own feelings of control had lasted. Mothers’ reports of disruptive behavior decreased with time after treatment.
Collaborative Problem Solving (CPS): Another technique that seems to be promising for children with ADHD and ODD is collaborative problem-solving (CPS). CPS is a treatment that teaches difficult children and adolescents how to handle frustration and learn to be more flexible and adaptable. Parents and children learn to brainstorm for possible solutions, negotiate, make decisions, and implement solutions that are acceptable to both. They learn to resolve disagreements with less conflict.
Family Therapy: Often a child’s behavior can have an effect on the whole family. Parents of children with ADHD often report marital difficulties. Mothers may be more depressed and siblings may also develop behavior problems. Family therapy is critical to helping a family address these issues and cope with the realities of having a child with ADHD and disruptive behaviors. Seeking out a counselor or family therapist in your neighborhood can help the entire family address these issues.
School-wide Positive Behavioral Supports: In addition to the environment at home, the school can have a significant impact on a child’s behavior patterns. Many school systems now have programs in place to provide school-wide positive behavioral supports. The aim of these programs is to foster both successful social behavior and academic gains for all students. These programs consist of: (1) clear, consistent consequences for inappropriate behaviors; (2) positive contingencies for appropriate behaviors; and (3) team-based services for those students with the more extreme behavioral needs.
Tutoring: Children’s ADHD symptoms, as well as oppositional symptoms, have been found to be significantly lower in one-on-one tutoring sessions than in the classroom.
Classroom Management: Providing appropriate instructional supports in the classroom can also lessen disruptive behavior. These include: creating an accepting and supportive classroom climate, promoting social and emotional skills, establishing clear rules and procedures, monitoring child behavior, utilizing rewards effectively, responding to mild problem behaviors consistently and effectively managing anger or aggressive behavior.
Overall results from several clinical studies indicate that medications used for the treatment of ADHD (stimulants as well as non-stimulants) remain an important component in the treatment of ADHD and coexisting ODD/CD. Children with these disorders treated with these medications were not only more attentive, but less antisocial and aggressive. ADHD medications are often effective treatments for aggressive or antisocial behavior in patients with ADHD and certainly play a role in any treatment program. See Managing Medication for Children with ADHD for more information.
In addition to using stimulant medications alone, medication combinations to reduce behavioral and conduct symptoms associated with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder appear to be very effective. In several studies, this treatment combination was reported to be well tolerated and unwanted effects were transient.
To increase the chance for a successful future and to discourage delinquent behaviors in children with ADHD, diagnosis and intervention is extremely important. It is essential for parents to provide structure and reinforce appropriate behavior. In addition, a positive behavior management plan to lessen anti-social behavior is important. Parents should discuss their child’s behavioral symptoms with the pediatrician or family practitioner and seek a referral to a mental health professional who can suggest effective parenting strategies.
In addition, parents should contact their child’s school counselor or school psychologist to discuss possible interventions to improve behaviors at school. Having the counselor or psychologist support the teacher in handling classroom behaviors often results in significant behavioral changes and decreases the incidence of expulsion. Consistent behavior management at home, school and elsewhere needs to be enforced.
Barkley, Russell. (1998). Your defiant child: 8 steps to better behavior . New York, NY: Guilford Press. This book is divided into two parts, “Getting to Know Your Defiant Child” and “Getting Along with Your Defiant Child.” Part two contains an eight-step parenting program built on consistency.
Clark, Lynn. (1996) SOS! Help for parents . Berkeley, CA: Parents Press. This book helps parents learn methods for helping children to improve their behavior and techniques for aiding a variety of child personalities, from the stubborn and willful child to time-out basics. It focuses on the basic skills of time-out and how parents can use these techniques to further a child’s behavior modification.
Forgatch, Marion S. and Gerald R. Patterson. (2005) Parents and adolescents living together: Family problem solving. Champaign, IL: Research Press. This book shows parents how to improve their communication and problem-solving skills, hold family meetings and get the whole family involved in solving problems. It explains how parents can teach their teenaged children to be responsible about schoolwork, sexual behavior and drugs and alcohol.
Goldstein, Sam; Robert Brooks and Sharon K. Weiss. (2004) Angry children, worried parents: Seven steps to help families manage anger . Plantation, FL: Specialty Press. This book helps parents cope with anger in their children. It presents the following seven steps to help children learn to manage anger: (1) understand why children become angry; (2) determine when your child needs help; (3) help the child become an active participant in the process; (4) use strategies to manage and express anger; (5) develop and implement a daily management plan; (6) assess and solve problems; and (7) instill a resilient mindset in the child.