Response - It is about how you respond to a particular piece of literature. In order to respond, you have to feel the tone and behavior of the narrator. Put in question all the actions the main character does. For instance, if the character is rude, you should investigate what led him to be rude.
Personal experience - Another characteristic of the personal response paper is to add experience similar to the one discussed in the paper but it happened to you. In other words, to relate the paper to your own world.
This is the place where you can find reliable papers. School library is a good source of papers, that are probably reviewed by teachers, and that’s why they are reliable.
Look for a book with samples, or only samples by other students, they will be really helpful.
This is a good advice, but not all teachers and tutors are willing to give you a sample paper. They will give you some advice regarding the structure, but as long as you don’t see a finished work, it will be abstract to you, unless you are good at writing and meet your teacher’s/ tutor’s expectations without reading any samples.
This is probably the least reliable source, but you can find a lot of essays there. Consider only pages of universities and schools. Talking about these sites, you can look for your online school library prior any others. You can find vast number of examples of papers on the Internet. Be picky and selective in order to avoid reading junk.
No matter the source you choose, it is important for you to start from your teacher/ tutor, then continue with your school library and leave the Internet last. You will definitely find good samples this way.