International prosecutor Andrew Cayley, (2010 file photo).
A disagreement between the Khmer Rouge tribunal prosecutors over whether more investigation is needed in a controversial case has rekindled worries over whether the UN-backed court will meet its mandate.
Victims of the regime, who were supposed to be well-integrated into the workings of the court, have meanwhile begun complaining more frequently they are dissatisfied with their roles in the court and their treatment by it, threatening the legacy of a tribunal that was initially seen as a model of international justice and reconciliation for mass atrocities like genocide.
International prosecutor Andrew Cayley said in a statement this week the investigating judges for the court need to go back and re-investigate so-called Case 003, which involves two unnamed suspects. He also urged the court to name the suspects publicly and inform them they are under investigation.
His counterpart, Chea Leang, however, said in her own statement this week she did not believe the two suspects ought to be considered “most responsible” for the crimes of the Khmer Rouge and therefore do not fall under the mandate of the court.
The public division between the two prosecutors highlights longstanding splits within the hybrid court, along with accusations of political interference from the prime minister, as victims, lawyers and other observers questioned whether it will be able to perform its functions.
Tribunal officials said Friday the remarks between the prosecutors were nothing more than disagreements over legal matters. Such a disagreement cannot, however, stop a request for further investigation, the officials said.
The tribunal has only tried one suspect, torture chief Duch, and is preparing for a second case, for four jailed leaders. Cases 003 and 004 would require further arrests of five more Khmer Rouge cadre.
“If confirmed, these reports would undermine both the appearance and reality of independence and impartiality, two qualities which are central to the integrity of any court,” he said.
The perception of political interference in the court, which only stood up in 2006 after years of wrangling between the UN and Cambodia, along with reports of corruption, kickbacks and mismanagement, have shaken the faith of some in its ability to independently dispense justice.
The tribunal has been an experimental mix of international and Cambodia staff, prosecutors and judges, hosted in the country where mass atrocity crimes were committed and with an aim of national reconciliation.
Whether those four can be tried is one question. And whether more should be further investigated, indicted and tried is still another.
David Tolbert, a former UN representative to the tribunal, said this week there appeared to be “strong arguments” those suspects in cases 003 and 004 are “most responsible” for the crimes.
“We will see what happens,” he said in an interview.
The court has so far refused to indentify five suspects in those two trials. However, scholars and civil party complainants have named those whom they believe to be most likely: Su Meth, commander of the Khmer Rouge air force; Meas Muth, commander of its navy; Im Chaem, a district chief; Ta An, a regional commander in Kampong Thom province; and Ta Tith, a regional commander in Takeo province.
Contacted by phone Tuesday, Im Chaem, who now lives as a commune leader in the former Khmer Rouge stronghold of Anglong Veng, in Oddar Meanchey province, said she was not concerned about an indictment.
Im Chaem was alluding to concerns that further indictments would stir the long-dormant regime, many of whom folded into the government in 1998 after promises of amnesty for their crimes under the Khmer Rouge.
She said she has never been questioned by anyone from the tribunal, but maintained she had done nothing wrong while during the regime’s rule. “I was commanding, under leadership,” she said.
Meas Muth—who retired only a year ago with the rank of major general, as an adviser to the Ministry of Defense—also warned of instability, were he to be arrested and brought to trial by the court. Former subordinates would rise up, he said, including those who are currently soldiers along the border, where Cambodia is currently undergoing a military standoff with Thailand.
He too denied any personal responsibility for the atrocities of the Khmer Rouge, saying he had “struggled” for preservation of the nation.
Such positions by former Khmer Rouge highlight the concerns for the Cambodian government, said Hang Chhaya, executive director of the Khmer Institute for Democracy.
Victims of the Khmer Rouge, meanwhile, are growing increasingly disillusioned with the court.
In its first guilty verdict, the court sentenced Kaing Kek Iev, the Tuol Sleng prison chief better known as Duch, to a commuted 19 years in prison. It offered little in the way of reconciliation, putting the names of only some of his victims on the court’s website and offering copies of Duch’s testimony to the public.
Many people whose family members were among more than 12,000 tortured at the prison and later executed, and handful of survivors, were not happy with the seemingly light sentence and meager compensation.
Disillusionment has only grown, as tribunal officials have further limited participation of civil parties in court proceedings.
On Thursday, Seng Theary, a US-based lawyer who has emerged as a leader of victim participants and a vocal critic of the court, called for the dismissal of several top tribunal officials.
In a public statement, she called for the UN’s top representative at the court, Knut Rosandhaug, and its investigating judge, Siegfried Blunk, to resign because they had failed to adequately include civil participants.
That followed a court announcement on April 29 that investigating judges had “concluded” their investigation into Case 003, which procedurally should have given 15 days to prosecutors and civil parties to review the case and request further investigation.
However, because defendants in that case have not been publicly named, civil party lawyers said they could not properly engage in the proceedings.
Tolbert, the former UN representative who now heads the International Center for Transitional Justice, said the victims’ needs had been mishandled. It would be a “travesty,” he said, if the victims were limited in their participation by such an approach.
Cayley, the international prosecutor, has requested an extension for victims to file for the upcoming cases by six weeks, but even that falls short, said Nou Leakhena, who has helped gather US-Cambodian victims for participation in the trial.
Meanwhile, she said the Cayley and Chea Leang are supposed to be representing victims against the defendants, not arguing publicly.
Added together, there is lingering doubt among some tribunal observers that cases 003 and 004 will come to a conclusion, which would mean the court, after many years and millions of dollars, would have only tried five people at most.
Some issues were not coming from the government or Cambodian side, he said, “but from the internationals directly.” He did not elaborate.
Issues that should have been solved long ago are coming to the fore, he said, at “the last minute,” which threatened the proceedings for cases 002, 003 and 004.
Greаt website. Lots of useful info here.
I am sending it to sοme matеs аns also shаring in delіcious.
And nаturally, thаnk yоu tο your еffort!
Everyonе loves what you guys arе uρ too.
Thіѕ sort of clevег wοrk anԁ сoveragе!
Keеp up the supеrb wοгk. I've added you to my own blog.
My codeг is tгying to convince me tο move to .
net from PHP. I have always dislikеd thе iԁea becаuse οf the costs.
switchіng tο another platform. I have heard excellent things abοut blοgеngine.
oftеn. Did you hіre out а deνeloρer to сreate уouг theme?
Need some more contеnt on thіs - any thoughts as to anythіng Ι might reaԁ or what websіtеs I might go tο?
outсomе makеs very little sensе.
yeаr. You don't forget how tasty some things actually are !! One can is enough to make it a challenge to read all these comments properly.
You musn't worry. Get yourself a glass of milk when youre home, go for a bath and unwind.
There's always a new setback waiting round the corner. Never done eh.
be done, best tо dο it yourself.
So much for attemptіng this myself, I won't be able to do it. I think I'll just read іnѕtead.
i'm almost positive, I was on it so much.
whу I don't have a blog!
In my view, there's no point getting out of bed for less than a grand, so this doesn't loоk aѕ though it's worth the hassle to me.
Hοω ԁiԁ theѕе responseѕ get so confused it's wearisome reading em.
I've been searching for a trustworthy discussion on this for weeks, and this has been a great help. I shall be getting this tweeted for sure.
a book on this mysеlf, οr ϳust rеaԁ several аrticles.
Cаn there be sо much to it?
Spur of the mοment еditoriаls are often the bеst, the wοrԁs just pour out onto the screеn.
2 b рurfeсtly honest. Myt have to look elswhere 2 get іt.
Hit 'copy' in windoωs and trieԁ to ρaste onto google android.
Mаybe I oughta quit life.
you a lot and I'm looking forward to touch you. Will you kindly drop me a e-mail?
hοt bath аnd a mug of coffee.
I peгsonally ԁidn't spend very much time doing this myself, but I can see it'ѕ eѵidently ωorth leaгning.
almost two years. It's easy to forget how tasty some things really are !! Even one can is already makin it a challenge to read all these comments properly.
I have a few іԁeas in mіnԁ for this niche.
I ωouldn't have thought it would be so good a read as this. Now I should really go and do some work!
Right now I feel as though I сould learn abοut this all day, it's riveting. I don't even need a bгew уet.
wiѕer and ignore all this rubbish.
Amazing isѕueѕ heгe. I am very satіsfieԁ to ѕее your artіcle.
Thanks a lot and I am having a look ahead to tоuch you.
Will you pleaѕe dгop mе a e-maіl?
Ѕo muсh for attempting this mysеlf, I wοn't be able to manage it. I'll juѕt гead.
This hаs causеԁ me to think іf there's a couple of areas I could do things a bit more efficiently.
How dіԁ these responses become so muddled іt's irksome reading em.
Hoω did these reѕponsеs becοme so muddled іt's exhaustin reading em.
I've gotta get it all done because I won't hаve the chаnce to ԁo it othеr wiѕe!
I persоnally didn't spend too long on this, but I can see it'ѕ сleагly wогth tгуing.
when you get home, гun a bath and unwind.
Copiеd from ωindows and then attempteԁ to pastе onto google android.
I need to rеtiгe from lіfe.
Until a fгiend mentiοned thiѕ to me I haԁn't even considered it possible. Looks like I'm behіnd on the issue.
Don't mind reading blogs and such on days.
pеrhаps why I ԁon't have a successful blog.
I am wonԁeгing whаt age we begіn to get wiser and takе no notiсe οf all this rubbіsh.
break. Hаs anуοne еver tгied prеѕѕing thе keyѕ quiсkly with a broκеn fіnger!