user-1: This post has been altered and more text added. I think it is more stream lined now.
Although now a new issue is that the question is too broad. It has multiple questions and some of them seem heavy to answer.
Should this post be reopened or remain closed?


user157: I think I'm on the permissive side when it comes to questions but I would personally vote to reopen this question. I'm a supporter of comparative-religion questions and I've argued for them here. I think there are valid questions to be asked and the contradictions between Christianity and Buddhism is a fair topic that will have definite answers. I have to say that the number of comments on the only answer is concerning but there have been many questions where people get a bit chatty on the comments (then are moved over to chat itself).
That said I'm not going to really argue for this one. I respect Chris's answer and it is typically well argued. Unfortunately as a mod my vote is binding so I'm unable to vote to reopen without it being very undemocratic. If I wasn't a moderator and had a normal vote I would vote to reopen this one.

-1: <p><a href="https://buddhism.stackexchange.com/review/reopen/2897">This post</a> has been altered and more text added. I think it is more stream lined now.</p>

<p>Although now a new issue is that the question is too broad. It has multiple questions and some of them seem <em>heavy</em> to answer.</p>

<p>Should this post be reopened or remain closed?</p>

<p><img src="https://i.stack.imgur.com/vsnrf.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p>
 157: <p>I think I'm on the permissive side when it comes to questions but I would personally vote to reopen this question. I'm a supporter of <a href="https://buddhism.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/comparative-religion" class="post-tag" title="show questions tagged &#39;comparative-religion&#39;" rel="tag">comparative-religion</a> questions and I've argued for them <a href="https://buddhism.meta.stackexchange.com/a/355/157">here</a>. I think there are valid questions to be asked and the contradictions between Christianity and Buddhism is a fair topic that will have definite answers. I have to say that the number of comments on the only answer is concerning but there have been many questions where people get a bit chatty on the comments (then are moved over to chat itself).</p>

<p>That said I'm not going to really argue for this one. I respect Chris's answer and it is typically well argued. Unfortunately as a mod my vote is binding so I'm unable to vote to reopen without it being very undemocratic. If I wasn't a moderator and had a normal vote I would vote to reopen this one.</p>
