user3424: this is the first time I'm in meta, so I don't really know how it work but but one of you suggesting me to ask this on meta
I want to reopen my question is there any famous doujinshi artist? but it close as too broad, I already tried to make it not too broad by adding this

Maybe not world wide but national wide? 

but apparently it's not enough, how can I make this question not too broad?
Thanks for your concern 

user27: Think about your questions for a moment, you're asking us "Who are the famous dojinshi artists?". How do you define "famous"? How "famous" is "famous"? Do you want the top 5? top 10? top 1000?
That's why it's too broad, you need to scope your question down only to the practical parts, ask a clear question that can be given a clear answer. Right now, there can't be a clear answer to your question.
If you think there can, please refine your requirements. Right now, your question is still too broad.

3424: <p>this is the first time I'm in meta, so I don't really know how it work but but one of you suggesting me to ask this on meta</p>

<p>I want to reopen my question <a href="https://anime.stackexchange.com/questions/8051/is-there-any-famous-doujinshi-artist">is there any famous doujinshi artist?</a> but it close as too broad, I already tried to make it not too broad by adding this</p>

<blockquote>
  <p>Maybe not world wide but national wide? </p>
</blockquote>

<p>but apparently it's not enough, how can I make this question not too broad?</p>

<p>Thanks for your concern </p>
 27: <p>Think about your questions for a moment, you're asking us "Who are the famous dojinshi artists?". How do you define "famous"? How "famous" is "famous"? Do you want the top 5? top 10? top 1000?</p>

<p>That's why it's <strong>too broad</strong>, you need to scope your question down only to the practical parts, ask a clear question that can be given a clear answer. Right now, there can't be a clear answer to your question.</p>

<p>If you think there can, please refine your requirements. Right now, your question is <em>still</em> too broad.</p>
