Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Three of the best known piers in England and Wales have been put on the market for a collective price of £12.6m.

Owner Cuerden Leisure is selling Blackpool's South and Central Piers and the Grade II listed Llandudno Pier.
St John Stott, director at Cuerden Leisure, which also owns Eastbourne Pier, said the company was "restructuring its assets".
Blackpool North Pier was bought by a local businessman in 2011.
Collectively, they are on the market for offers of around £12.6m, with individual guide prices of £4.8m for Blackpool Central, £3.3m for Blackpool South and £4.5m for Llandudno Pier.
Blackpool Central Pier is home to a 33m high (108ft) Ferris wheel, Blackpool South Pier and Llandudno Pier were all built in the 19th Century.
Llandudno, which is 695m long (2,280ft), is the only pier with listed building status meaning any future owners would require Listed Building Consent to make changes to the structure.
Known as the "Queen of Welsh Piers", it nestles in the crescent bay between the outcrops of the Little and Great Orme.
Blackpool Central Pier, which stands at 341m long (1,118ft), and Blackpool South Pier, which is 150m (492ft), do not benefit from listed status, despite opening in 1864 and 1892 respectively.
Richard Baldwin, a director at Bilfinger GVA, which is selling the piers for Cuerden Leisure, said it would be very unlikely that a new owner would make significant changes.
He said: "In our opinion, the value is in the existing use and this is unlikely to change at either of the Blackpool piers."
A spokesman for the National Piers Society, which promotes the preservation and continued enjoyment of seaside piers in the UK, said: "These piers are all in good order and trading successfully, and, given that Easter is almost upon us, I have no doubt that they will quickly find a buyer or buyers."

represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

Examples:
Provided: "['Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence', 'The council hopes to borrow £11.3m for a new 130-room hotel in the Talbot Gateway area and expects future profits to cover the cost.\nHoliday Inn is the preferred chain although a deal is yet to be signed.\nThe town\'s hoteliers criticised the move, claiming there is enough four-star accommodation already available.\nA third-party company will provide accommodation services for the hotel, which will be owned by Blackpool Council.\nDeputy council leader Fred Jackson, said the hotel development would help to attract more conference business to the town.\n"All the delegates for conferences won\'t stay in the four-star hotel, so the other hotels in Blackpool will benefit from this development as well."\nHe added: "One of the criticisms we\'ve had in the past has been that the conferences no longer want to come because there is no quality hotel in the town centre."\nClaire Smith, president of the hoteliers\' organisation StayBlackpool, disagreed.\n"The conference accommodation offer has never been criticised, it always was the conference facilities that they were going on about.\n"Had it been a five-star hotel, that would add to Blackpool and we would have been in favour of it."\nIf planning permission is granted, the hotel is expected to open in two years\' time on the site of the East Topping Street car park.\nThe council said it had already raised £2.7m towards the cost of the hotel from the regeneration of the Talbot Gateway area.']" Match: "['Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story', 'Blackpool Council has said it will pay £14m for the construction of a four-star hotel as part of plans to attract visitors to the resort.']"

The two-storey building at Winkleigh Airfield, Devon, along with 9.5 acres of land and disused outbuildings, will go under the hammer next month.
The airbase was built in 1940 on remote moorland to defend Britain's western approaches from the Luftwaffe.
It was so strategically important that its existence was officially denied.
The watch tower and land is being sold on behalf of the official receiver at Clive Emson Auctioneers on 22 September at St Mellion in Cornwall and has a freehold guide price of between £35,000 and £50,000.
The tower is listed by English Heritage as a Scheduled Monument.


Question: Each day we feature a photograph sent in from across England.

this is part of a news article. represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

For instance, <<['This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article', "Canadian Henderson, 19, hit her lowest round of the year, an eight-under-par 63, at Blythefield Country Club in Grand Rapids, Michigan.\nClyburn, 26, is one of six players tied for second after carding a 64.\nWales' Becky Morgan and Northern Ireland's Stephanie Meadow finished on two under par after rounds of 69."]>>  to "['Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story', "England's Holly Clyburn is part of a chasing pack just one shot off Brooke Henderson's lead after the opening round of the Meijer LPGA Classic."]"

Find out how you can join in and submit your images and videos below.
If you are looking for inspiration, view some top tips from three of England's Big Picture photographers.
If you have a picture you'd like to share, email us at england@bbc.co.uk, post it on Facebook or tweet it to @BBCEngland. You can also find us on Instagram - use #englandsbigpicture to share an image there. You can also see a recent archive of pictures on our England's Big Picture board on Pinterest.
When emailing pictures, please make sure you include the following information:
Please note that whilst we welcome all your pictures, we are more likely to use those which have been taken in the past week.
If you submit a picture, you do so in accordance with the BBC's Terms and Conditions.
In contributing to England's Big Picture you agree to grant us a royalty-free, non-exclusive licence to publish and otherwise use the material in any way that we want, and in any media worldwide.
It's important to note, however, that you still own the copyright to everything you contribute to England's Big Picture, and that if your image is accepted, we will publish your name alongside.
The BBC cannot guarantee that all pictures will be used and we reserve the right to edit your comments.
At no time should you endanger yourself or others, take any unnecessary risks or infringe any laws while collecting any kind of media.

Here are a selection of pictures from around the country as the results are announced.


Question: this is the first sentence of a news article. represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: A London schoolgirl, who was missing over night, has been found safe and well.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

Detectives searching for 12-year-old Evelin Mezei from east London, said she was found by officers at 11:00 BST in Newham.
Earlier, police released CCTV of her with an unknown man on Monday night.
The still showed her at around 22:30 BST in Romford Road in Stratford, an hour after she was last seen by her mother in nearby Grove Crescent Road.
Evelin is a Hungarian national who came to the UK six months ago.

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary

Martina Lee Price, 15, from Darfield, Barnsley, was last seen on Saturday morning when she said she was going to a shop.
South Yorkshire Police suspected she may have been attempting to travel to Ireland.
A force spokesperson confirmed she had been located safe and well near Edinburgh.


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: A man is to stand trial accused of a series of rapes and sex attacks dating back to 1980.

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary.

Brian McTaggart is accused of a catalogue of rapes and assaults in Dundee, including an allegation that he attacked a pregnant woman and caused her to have a miscarriage.
The 52-year-old, of no fixed abode, made no plea or declaration to the 18 charges at Dundee Sheriff Court.
A hearing on whether he will be granted bail is to be held at the High Court.
Mr McTaggart is accused of having 11 different victims over the duration of the offences, and is also accused of setting fires at three separate addresses in Edinburgh in the past year.
One charge alleges that in 1983 he attacked one alleged victim at addresses across Dundee, kicking her down a flight of stairs and kicking and punching her in the ribs and back while she was pregnant, causing her to have a miscarriage.
He is also accused of driving a car at the woman in an attempt to run her over, and in another incident holding a hairdryer over a bath full of water, threatening to drop it in.
Sheriff Alastair Brown committed Mr McTaggart for trial and granted him bail, but this was opposed by the Crown. A bail appeal will be heard at the High Court.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

Simon Harris, 55, pleaded guilty at Birmingham Crown Court to indecent assaults on three boys aged between 13 and 14.
The assaults took place while he was employed at Shebbear College in Devon.
Mr Harris, from Pudleston, Herefordshire, has denied a further 27 sexual offences involving boys in Kenya.
He is due to stand trial over these charges, which include allegations of rape on victims as young as seven, from Tuesday.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Chesterfield have signed versatile midfielder Jordan Flores on a season-long loan from League One club Wigan.

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article.

The 21-year-old, who can also play in defence, returns to League Two with the Spireites, having helped Blackpool win promotion from the division while on loan at Bloomfield Road last season.
He scored in his only appearance for Wigan this term, in a 2-1 win over Blackpool in the League Cup.
Flores is reunited with former Latics manger Gary Caldwell at Chesterfield.
Find all the latest football transfers on our dedicated page.

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary.

The 31-year-old moves to the Latics after making six appearances at the U's so far this season.
Ibehre began his career at Leyton Orient and has had spells at Walsall, MK Dons, Southend and Stockport.
Meanwhile, striker Conor Wilkinson will return to Bolton after the League One game against Walsall on Saturday, when his one-month loan spell ends.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details.

Question: The Pittsburgh Penguins retained the NHL's Stanley Cup with a 4-2 series win over the Nashville Predators.

represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence!

A 2-0 victory in Nashville sealed the best-of-seven series as they claimed the trophy for a fifth time in six final appearances.
Patric Hornqvist gave the Penguins the lead with 95 seconds left, and Carl Hagelin scored into an empty net.
Victory meant they became the first team to retain the title since the Detroit Red Wings in 1998.
Penguins captain Sidney Crosby was named the most valuable player of the series for the second consecutive year.
"A good chunk of the team were returning but for the new guys it's pretty special," said Crosby.
"This was our goal at the beginning of the year - we knew it hadn't been done in a long time. To be able to accomplish it is a great feeling."

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence.

Second baseman Omar Infante hit a two-run home run in the sixth inning as the Royals turned round a 2-1 deficit with six unanswered runs.
The Giants, who are going for their third World Series in five season, had outclassed the Royals 7-1 in Tuesday's series opener.
The next three games take place in San Francisco, with Game Three on Friday.


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: There has been heavy fighting outside the Libyan interim parliament in the capital Tripoli.

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary:

MPs fled the building after heavily armed attackers tried to storm it. Some eyewitnesses say the gunmen were from the powerful Zintan Brigade of former rebel fighters.
However, a paramilitary force backing retired general Khalifa Haftar claimed it was behind the assault.
Authorities are struggling to contain militias that control parts of Libya.
A planned new constitution remains unwritten and the country has had three prime ministers since March.
On Sunday, the gunmen launched their assault on parliament in armoured vehicles. Black smoke rose above the building as militiamen loyal to the government responded.
The building was largely empty, with reports that officials had been warned in advance and had left the area.
The BBC's Rana Jawad in Tripoli says the sporadic rumble of heavy arms being fired was heard across the city as the militiamen withdrew to their bases.
Later on Sunday, Gen Haftar's militia - which calls itself the "Libyan National Army" - issued a statement demanding the suspension of parliament.
On Friday the group launched a major air-and-ground attack against Islamist militants in the eastern of Benghazi.
The government condemned the attack and declared a no-fly zone in the city, threatening to shoot down any military aircraft.
At least 70 people died in the fighting.

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

The fighting broke out on Tuesday night after Nasser al-Aker, a senior Islamist militant from Derna's Abu-slim Martyr's Brigade, was killed by members of IS.
IS established a base in Derna in October and the group has tightened its grip on the city in recent months.
Residents say that control of the city is split between two militant groups.
About 20 fighters were reported to have been killed in the clashes between IS and the al-Qaeda-linked Mujahadeen Shura Council of Derna, an umbrella group for local Islamist militias.
Salem Derbi, the commander of the so-called Abu Salem Brigade, was believed to be among those killed by IS.
The Shura Council released a statement following the death of Al-Aker declaring "holy war" on IS "until none of them are left".
The 55-year-old, who fought in Afghanistan and was once held in the UK on terrorism charges, was killed along with his aide.
Derna - a jihadist stronghold in the 1980s and 1990s during the insurgency against Muammar Gaddafi - has descended into chaos as Libya grapples with a power vacuum left by the overthrow of Gaddafi in 2013.
One witness told the BBC that residents were scared to go outside, leaving most shops and bakeries closed.
Libya's vast number of rival militias have long been running the show.  They've spun a web of localised conflicts on a city and regional level in recent years that has allowed IS's local sympathisers and foreign fighters to establish a foothold in two major cities: Derna in the east and Sirte in the West.
The political chaos engulfing the state also helped them flourish, but it is the very local nature of Libya's conflict - its small population and family ties - that may yet prove detrimental to IS's survival in Libya in the long term.
In the past month we've seen rival armed groups increasingly preoccupied by fighting against IS militants than against each other.
Why is Libya so lawless?
Islamic State gains Libya foothold
IS has expanded its hold on Libyan territory in recent months to include the whole of the central city of Sirte and Harwa to the east of the country.
Its capture of Sirte gives the group access to the road to the country's third largest city of Misrata, in the west.
The rapid rise of the group in Libya has alarmed Western powers, which fear it gaining a stronghold on the Mediterranean across from mainland Europe.
Libya's internationally recognised parliament is operating in exile in the eastern port of Tobruk after being forced from the capital, Tripoli. A rival parliament, the Islamist-dominated General National Congress, is nearly 1,000km (620 miles) to the west in Tripoli.
In an attempt to stabilise the country, the UN presented both factions with a draft proposal for a unity government on Tuesday.
The plan unveiled at talks in Morocco addresses terms of a truce and disarmament of armed groups.


Question:
represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story
------
The provided query could be '['This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article', 'The remains of a man found in Nepal have been confirmed as missing backpacker Matthew Allpress.']' and the positive '['Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary', 'His mother, Margaret, who lives in Luton, flew to Kathmandu to join a search effort when he failed to reappear in November.\nThe 23-year-old had been on a trekking holiday.\nTests on skeletal remains found on 10 May by two Nepalese foraging in a mountainous area have been confirmed as Mr Allpress, a family spokesman said.\nExperts used medical and dental records to confirm his identity, the spokesman added.\nThe examination was performed by doctors at a hospital in Kathmandu after a request by police.\nThe spokesman said: "Margaret, Matthew\'s mum, attended the hospital on Thursday to view the remains and to meet with the examining doctors who had carried out the autopsy.\n"The police have advised us that a new team of approximately 15 officers are being immediately deployed back to the area where the remains were found to search for, and hopefully retrieve, the remaining missing effects that belong to Matthew.\n"This process will take some time but as normal we will keep everyone updated as news comes to hand."\nMs Allpress met up with her Australian son\'s father, Mark, after flying to Nepal.\nThe spokesman added: "Mark and Margaret thank everyone for their thoughts and prayers."']' and the negative '['Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence.', 'A single human bone was first found in March close to junction 45 of the M1 in woods near Temple Newsam, Leeds.\nSearches at the scene in April later revealed most of a skeleton.\nWest Yorkshire Police said the man had now been identified as coming from eastern Europe. No further details have been released.']'

Question: It has been more than two years since 276 girls were abducted from a secondary school in north-eastern Nigeria by militant Islamist group Boko Haram.

Their kidnapping sparked one of the biggest global social media campaigns, with tweeters using the hashtag #BringBackOurGirls.
But most of the girls are still missing. BBC News looks at what we know.
On 14 April 2014, Boko Haram militants attacked a government secondary boarding school in Chibok, Borno state, where girls from surrounding areas had gone to take exams.
Many schools in the region had shut down. Boko Haram was targeting them because of their opposition to Western education, which the militants believe corrupts the values of Muslims.
But Chibok had not been attacked before, so it was felt safe to use the school for the important final year exams. Many of the pupils were Christians.
The gunmen arrived in the town late at night in a blaze of gunfire and headed for the school where they raided the dormitories and loaded 276 girls on to lorries.
Some managed to escape within hours of their kidnapping, mostly by jumping off the lorries and running off into the bushes.
In total 219 girls were taken away.
One of those who did escape told the BBC Hausa service the militants had said: "You're only coming to school for prostitution. Boko [Western education] is haram [forbidden] so what are you doing in school?"
In the past the militants had secretly swapped hostages for Boko Haram members or relatives in prison but this abduction and the blaze of publicity that followed came as the group was growing in strength and capturing territory.
Captives from the villages they were taking over were generally put to work, the boys as fighters while women and girls were often forced to become wives of men in the group.
Three videos have been released to date. On 14 August 2016, a Boko Haram tape showed about 50 of the girls and contained a demand for the release of imprisoned militants in exchange for them.
The group also said some girls had been killed or injured in government air strikes.
In April 2016 a video was broadcast by CNN, which appeared to show some of the kidnapped schoolgirls alive. In May 2014, Boko Haram released a video of around 130 girls gathered together reciting the Koran.
In May 2016 one girl was rescued from the Sambisa Forest, a remote area of north-east Nigeria near to the Cameroon border, where many Boko Haram militants have fled.
She was reportedly spotted by a vigilante group in the area, although the circumstances of her rescue are unclear.
She was named locally as Amina Ali Nkeki, aged 19, and may have had a baby. According to one Chibok activist, Amina said six of the schoolgirls had died but the rest were in the forest.
In October, 21 of the remaining students in captivity were freed.
The Nigerian government said their release was the result of negotiations with Swiss officials acting as intermediaries with Boko Haram.
There are conflicting reports but one security official told the BBC that four Boko Haram commanders were freed as part of a swap - this was denied by the Nigerian government.
Boko Haram leader Abubakar Shekau has said all the girls have converted to Islam and were "married off".
Last year, three women who claim they were held in the same camps as some of the Chibok girls told the BBC some of them had become fighters - though the testimony has never been verified.
Other rumours or reported sightings of the girls in neighbouring countries have turned out not to be true.
A journalist who is believed to have had contact with the militants, Ahmed Salkida, said in December that sources had told him that the girls were alive. The Nigerian army has since declared Salkida himself a wanted man.
The US, UK, France have been providing military support and intelligence to help in the search for the girls.
China and Israel have also given assistance.
A boosted regional force with 8,700 troops from Cameroon, Chad, Niger and Nigeria was launched last July.
Thanks to this renewed military impetus, over the last year the militants have been driven from towns and villages to their hideouts in the Sambisa forest - which cannot be accessed by road.
Thousands of people have been freed from Boko Haram captivity, but Amina was the first of the 219 girls to be found.
President Muhammadu Buhari has said he is prepared to enter into talks if a credible Boko Haram leadership can be identified. The group is said to have recently split over allegiance to so-called Islamic State.
Negotiations, brokered by the Swiss, helped secure the release of the 21 students, and Nigeria's Information Minister Lai Mohammed said that their release was "the first step" towards the liberation of all the remaining girls.

represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

His continued absence has increased speculation about his fate.
He was last heard from in March, when he released an audio message pledging allegiance to the Islamic State (IS) group.
Soon thereafter, Nigeria's military said it had recaptured all towns and cities from Boko Haram.
The military said on Sunday that it had freed 178 people held captive by Boko Haram in north-eastern Borno state.
It had also killed militants and captured a commander following airstrikes on the group's bases, it added.
In the eight-minute video, an unidentified young man speaks in the name of the Islamic State in West Africa calling on people to be patient: "We are still present everywhere we had been before."
The video shows the militants attacking a security checkpoint, seizing weapons, and slitting the throat of a man dressed in a police uniform.
Mr Shekau also failed to appear in a Boko Haram video released in June.
BBC Nigeria analyst Naziru Mikailu says this will renew speculation that he is either deep in hiding, or has been wounded and even killed.
Regardless of Mr Shekau's fate, it is clear from the video that some militants in Nigeria are still determined to fight, he says.
The  video is gruesome, but its production sleek and this suggests that it was produced with the help of IS-allied propaganda units, he adds.
The young militant spoke in the regional Hausa language, with an accent from the Kanuri ethnic group, to which Mr Shekau belongs.
Mr Shekau became Boko Haram leader following the killing of the group's founder, Muhammad Yusuf, in police custody in 2009.
Previous reports about his death proved to be untrue.
He sparked global outrage when Boko Haram abducted more than 200 girls from a boarding school in Chibok town in Borno state in April 2014.
He laughed in a  video clip, and said: "I abducted your girls. I will sell them in the market, by Allah. I will sell them off and marry them off."
The US government has offered a reward of up to $7m (Â£4.6m) for information about his location.
IS is based in Iraq and Syria, has a foothold in Libya, and has vowed to create a global caliphate.
Will new military base help defeat Boko Haram?
Why Boko Haram remains a threat
Profile: Boko Haram leader Abubakar Shekau


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: Schools in England are to receive £2.4bn for extra places and building repairs.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence!

The announcement by Education Secretary Justine Greening will help to create 600,000 more places by 2021.
Extra places are needed to keep pace with a rising school-age population - and to create places in a new wave of grammar schools.
But head teachers say the money for buildings does nothing for the "black hole" in day-to-day running costs.
This announcement on school places draws upon funding from the 2015 spending review.
There will be £980m for extra school places, including an expansion in selective schools.
Speaking last week, the education secretary promised a "new model" for grammars and said local communities would have a "choice over how selection works".
There will be £1.4bn to improve the condition of schools, with 1,500 school building projects to be funded.
But a recent report from the National Audit Office said that it would cost £6.7bn to get all schools in England into an acceptable state of repair.
Last week the public accounts committee published a hard-hitting report accusing the Department for Education of failing to recognise the seriousness of funding problems for schools.
Head teachers have been warning of having to cut staff because of budget shortages.
The National Association of Head Teachers said budgets were at "breaking point" and that the announcements over extra places failed to address funding problems for basic running costs, such as staffing.
"This is money that was already allocated to building new places and so it does nothing to help fill the £3bn black hole in day-to-day school spending," said the NAHT's leader Russell Hobby.
Education Secretary Justine Greening said: "This £2.4bn investment, together with our proposals to create more good school places, will help ensure every young person has the opportunity to fulfil their potential."

represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary

There have been more than 27,000 tweets using the hashtag #whatwouldyoucut since the campaign against the cuts started on Sunday.
The government insists school investment is at a record Â£40bn.
But the Association of School and College Leaders said this was only because pupil numbers are rising.
It argued that head teachers are having to make tough decisions about which services to cut.
The tweets included photographs of science experiments, school trips, sporting activities and performing arts events.
Lostock Hall Primary School in Stockport suggested its library could be a candidate for the chop.
The idea for #whatwouldyoucut came from a group head teachers in Cheshire East - one of the country's worst-funded areas in the country, which is set to loose out even more under the government's planned new funding formula.
ASCL interim general secretary Malcolm Trobe said: "This campaign shows what is at stake as a result of the education funding crisis.
"School leaders have to reduce their budgets significantly.
"Smaller budgets mean fewer staff and this impacts on every area of school activity. What would you cut? School concerts? Educational trips? GCSE courses? Mental health support? Sports events?"
Schools have been writing to parents warning them of tricky budget decisions to come, while groups of heads have been lobbying the Education Secretary setting out their difficulties.
The Department for Education said it was protecting per pupil funding so where pupil numbers rise, the amount of money schools receive will increase.
"The government has protected the core schools budget in real terms since 2010, but the system for distributing that funding across the country is unfair, opaque and outdated."
This was why it was bringing forward a new national funding formula, under which half of England's schools will receive a cash boost in 2018-19, it added.
One tweet suggested the length of school day could be shortened.
The Twitter campaign comes in the run-up to the Budget on Wednesday.
Currently, the level of funding per pupil is frozen and is expected to fall by 6.5% in real terms between 2015-16 and 2019-20 because of rising costs.
These funding pressures include increases to employer contributions to National Insurance and pensions, nationally agreed pay awards, and the new Apprenticeship Levy which comes into force next month and which many schools will have to pay.
Kevin Seaward, an Irish marathon runner and assistant head teacher, was part of the Ireland Olympics team in 2016.
He highlighted how extra-curricular sports activities had put him on a path to Rio.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Banners put outside a house in east Belfast where a man originally from Nigeria was due to move in were "blatantly racist", Alliance MP Naomi Long has said.

this is part of a news article. represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

For instance, <<['Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence', 'Media playback is not supported on this device\nThe main topics on the post-match agenda were, once again, captain Wayne Rooney\'s continuing worth to England and whether this was the sort of display Southgate needed to aid his bid to land the England manager\'s job on a permanent basis.\nRooney\'s worth to England was subjected to another forensic examination in the build-up to Southgate\'s first match in charge - and the 30-year-old was given a strong vote of confidence by the new manager.\nSouthgate sympathised with the sole focus on Rooney and admitted he could not understand the audible frustration of England\'s fans when he shot wildly off target near the end.\nHe said: "It\'s fascinating to get an insight into his world over the last 10 days. Every debate seems to focus on him. The onus on him is enormous, the criticism of him is, at times, unfair and yet he ploughs on and plays with pride and represents his country with pride."\nSouthgate compared Rooney to long-term England servants such as John Terry, Frank Lampard and Ashley Cole as he added: "They kept turning out and really put themselves on the line. Some other players have not put themselves forward at those moments and withdrawn from squads when the going has got tough.\n"Those guys are the people that really desperately wanted to play for England again and again and again and put their necks on the block. Wayne falls into that category."\nSouthgate\'s faith was clear as Rooney was kept on as captain and started against Malta, and all the indications are that he will keep his place in the next qualifier in Slovenia on Tuesday.\nThe Manchester United man may not be the force he once was but he is a player and personality who never hides irrespective of any personal struggles for form and his determination to always be involved was in evidence once more at Wembley.\nThis was, however, another indifferent performance that once again gave the impression that Rooney is increasingly being shoe-horned into England\'s plans rather than acting as a fulcrum for a manager\'s policy.\nHere Rooney, who is 31 later this month, was operating in a deep-lying midfield role spraying "Hollywood" passes left and right to the flanks but not providing any killer creativity, other than two shots which brought saves from Malta\'s heroic keeper Andrew Hogg.\nHe was figuring in a role that Tottenham\'s Eric Dier has played better in recent months - he was one of the relative successes amid the fiasco that was Euro 2016 - and the Spurs player will surely adopt the role regularly once more in the future.\nDele Alli, on target once and a danger on several other occasions, is best suited to the "number 10" role Rooney once fitted into neatly, while Harry Kane and Daniel Sturridge are ahead of England\'s captain as striking options.\nSo will Rooney now simply move around where he is needed and become England\'s bit-part player throughout this World Cup qualifying campaign?\nHe was on the ball enough but his influence was marginal. Only England\'s man-of-the-match Jordan Henderson (187) had more touches than Rooney\'s 177 and he made 153 attempted passes, bettered only by Henderson\'s 178.\nRooney gained possession on the most occasions, 14, but also lost it most for England with 25.\nSouthgate appeared to take issue with the England fans who jeered Rooney\'s late, wild attempt on goal, saying: "I don\'t understand [the booing] but that seems to be the landscape. I have no idea how that is expected to help him, for sure."\nThere are times when it looks like the fire that fuelled Rooney for so long has burned out and the trademark surges into opposition territory were barely in evidence against the massed ranks of Malta\'s defence.\nHe showed frustration, too, and was lucky not to receive serious punishment for a dangerous lunge at Malta captain Andrei Schembri that appeared to get some of the ball but also caught the Boavista player with what plenty would have adjudged to be excessive force.\nRooney may produce the goods in Slovenia but the pressure is growing as he prepares to win his 118th cap, a record for an England outfield player. He must deliver displays of significance soon.\nIt was an unspectacular start for Southgate as he succeeded Sam Allardyce but an effective one which claimed three points and avoided any of the accidents and embarrassment that befell England against Iceland at the Euros in France last summer.\nSouthgate will have wanted more goals and more tempo, especially in the second half - but what he wanted most of all will have been victory and that was never in doubt.\nGreater tests lie ahead for Southgate when it comes to measuring his credentials to become full-time manager after what is effectively a four-game audition period before the Football Association moves to the next stage of its selection progress.\nThe next qualifier in Slovenia will present more of an examination of how Southgate wants to set up his "brave" England in a foreign environment - the meetings with Scotland at Wembley on 11 November and the following friendly at home to Spain will offer even more conclusive evidence of his suitability.\nAs for the accusations that he is "too nice" to be in charge, they are understandably starting to grate on a man who has shown enough steel to captain the likes of Crystal Palace, Aston Villa and Middlesbrough, as well as making his way into management.\nSouthgate has looked comfortable in the England manager\'s skin this week and has clearly shifted position from early September when he insisted it was too early for him to take the top job.\nLittle did he know it would become available again so soon and now he knows this is a chance that might not come again for some time.\nIf he can secure wins against Slovenia and Scotland then it is hard to see how, the possibility of Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger\'s future availability permitting, the FA will look elsewhere.\nEngland\'s next World Cup qualifiers are important in any context - but especially for Southgate\'s ambitions to land a job he describes as "a huge honour and a huge responsibility".']>>  to <<['Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story', 'England started another new era with victory as manager Gareth Southgate opened his interim succession to Sam Allardyce with an attritional triumph over Malta.']>>

Michael Abiona, 34, was greeted with posters reading "Local Houses 4 Local People" at Glenluce Drive on Tuesday.
Mr Abiona, who has been living in Northern Ireland since 2010, said he was too afraid to move in.
Mrs Long said: "This sort of behaviour has no place in our community."
She added: "Any right-thinking person will condemn this blatantly racist behaviour and I have no doubt the vast majority of residents in the area will be sickened by it.
"Rather than Mr Abiona and his family, it is this kind of vile behaviour that should be unwelcome in our society."
First Minister Peter Robinson said: "Nobody should be judged on the colour of their skin, on their political or religious background, or their race."
However, he added: "I'm not sure this can be described as racism in terms of what the intention of the local people was.
"There is massive concern (about housing), and of course local in these terms means very local, you might have had exactly the same reaction if it was somebody from up-country moving into a local area where local people weren't able to get houses in the locality where they've been brought up in."
Anti-racist rallies have been held across Northern Ireland in recent weeks following a spate of hate crimes.
Mr Abiona, who has osteoarthritis, was allocated a bungalow in Garnerville by the Housing Executive.
He told the BBC's Good Morning Ulster he had gone to meet a boiler repairman at the property when he saw a group of people sitting outside.
"I thought they were just out enjoying the sunshine and having fun but then I saw the banners at the front of the building," he said.
"A woman told me the place should be meant for locals, she said there are a lot of local elderly and disabled people living in the area who have been on the housing waiting list for about nine years, so how come I got the house?
How the Housing Selection Scheme works
"She said it wasn't personally about me, it was about housing.
"She was even asking me if I am disabled and I said I am, but I was wondering why she was asking me this.
"I went through the normal channels of getting the premises."
Mr Abiona, who is active in race relations in Northern Ireland and serves in key roles in the Northern Ireland Council for Ethnic Minorities and the Nigerian Association, said he believed he was being targeted because he is black.
"It is not about me being elderly or local - it is about intimidation and discrimination," he said.
"A housing officer told me they were trying to resolve it, but with what was written on the banner I don't think I will be able to move in there.
"The safety of my son comes first. His mother told me she would not allow him to come and visit me there.
"My son comes first, so I'm not going to go back to the premises."
A resident of Glenluce Drive told BBC News NI that the protest was "not racist" and was about "a bungalow equipped for pensioners and disabled".
"They cannot put families into them," she said.
"We're actually horrified we're being called racist, because if you come up into our community at 3pm, and see the children getting out of school and the people, this is a mixed community."
Police removed the banners on Wednesday morning. A spokesman said: "Enquiries into the incident are ongoing."
Liam Kinney of the Housing Executive agreed the racist issue was "becoming slightly worrying in Belfast over the past few months".
"We have probably over 10 cases now, particularly in south and east Belfast, where people have been prohibited moving into properties that were entitled to those properties," he told the BBC.
"We have been working with local communities, local politicians, residents groups, police and whoever else we think could make an influence.
"But we need the support of everyone out there who can help on us this because it's not right and it should stop."
He said the Housing Executive  was "actively working with local representatives and agencies to try to resolve the issue".
Deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness of Sinn FÃ©in said on Twitter: "The racist intimidation of Michael Abiona at the house allocated to him in east Belfast is shameful and must be opposed and condemned by everyone."
Ulster Unionist councillor Jim Rodgers said "people must not take the law into their own hands".
"People genuinely ask me why are people from other countries able to get houses much quicker, but I point out to them that we have a points system for social housing that works reasonably well," he said.
"It's not allocated on a first-come, first-served basis.
"Some people are on the waiting list for years and they are annoyed that they don't seem to get any offers made to them, but it's not right for anybody to be singled out because of the colour of their skin, their religion or political views."
SDLP leader Alasdair McDonnell said it was "racist intimidation", and called on the Northern Ireland Executive to publish its race relations strategy.
"Unfortunately, this is not an isolated incident. Race hate crime has soared over the past year," said the South Belfast MP.
"We must not allow ourselves to become sanitised to the despicableness of racism - there should never be a culture here that dilutes racism or attempts to qualify it.
"The people who intimidated Mr Abiona from his home are not defenders of human rights, as their banners attempt to portray."

The message, 'Curry my yougrt (sic), oil my AK-47', was sprayed on a wall outside DUP councillor George Duddy's house on Sunday.
The police said the attack on Mr Duddy's home at Drumaquill Road was a hate crime.
The men, aged 26 and 37, were released on police bail on Wednesday night, pending further enquiries.
A number of properties in the Coleraine area were searched on Wednesday and items were taken away by police for examination.
Part of the graffiti refers to comments made in the Northern Ireland Assembly when DUP MP Gregory Campbell said: "Curry my yoghurt can coca coalyer."


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Concerns about local job losses have been raised in Perthshire after it was revealed insurance giant Aviva plans to cut 1,500 jobs by the end of 2017.

represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

The details emerged as part of the firm's Â£5.6bn takeover of pensions company Friends Life.
It is not yet clear where the cuts will be made.
Aviva's site in Perth employs about 1,300 staff, and local politicians have called for clarity on whether their jobs are at risk.
The insurer plans to generate Â£225m in annual cost savings by the end of 2017 as part of the Friends Life deal. Shareholders will vote on the takeover on 26 March, and it is expected to go through on 13 April.
The company had previously underlined its commitment to Perth by buying the Pitheavlis site in 2013 as its lease on the premises expired.
Perthshire MP Pete Wishart said he wanted to find out "as soon as possible" how the job losses would impact on Perth.
The SNP MP said: "It is really important that employees are not kept in the dark about their future and that any reduction in job numbers can be managed through means other than redundancy."
Mid Scotland and Fife MSP Liz Smith said the cuts would be "a real concern" for workers at the Perth site.
She added: "Employees at Aviva will want urgent clarity over their future and it is essential that this is given to them at the earliest opportunity.
"I also believe it would be prudent for the Scottish government to enter into early discussions with the company over their future plans in Perth.
"It is crucial that if we are to see significant redundancies that we see steps taken early to help those affected."
An Aviva spokesman said it was too early to identify specific teams, roles or locations for the job cuts.
He said: "When we are clearer on this, following completion of the deal, we will fully engage and consult with employees and their representative bodies.
"We appreciate that this news may be disconcerting for employees and we would look to ensure that any redundancies are kept to a minimum wherever possible, by using vacancies and natural turnover, for example."

Investment, exploration and new technology form the focus of this year's event at the Aberdeen Exhibition and Conference Centre (AECC).
Scotland's Economy Secretary Keith Brown and UK Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change Amber Rudd were among those in attendance.
Discussion on the EU referendum is also playing a part in the two-day event.
Jobs lost as a result of the downturn in the UK oil and gas sector could top 120,000 by the end of this year, according to a report last week.
Industry body Oil and Gas UK has estimated 84,000 jobs linked to the industry went in 2015, with 40,000 losses expected this year.


Question: represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Hampshire coach Dale Benkenstein says the county will use the loan market to find cover for injured bowlers Reece Topley, Liam Dawson and Chris Wood.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

Benkenstein's side were dominated by Yorkshire on day two of their County Championship match on Monday.
"It doesn't help when you're up against it before the game even starts," Benkenstein told BBC Radio Solent.
"We have to (think about loans). We need to get our heads down and we are already discussing some options."
Yorkshire's England batsman Jonny Bairstow made a double ton as the hosts declared on an emphatic 593-9 on Monday.
But Hampshire's bowling attack was without Dawson, who has an abdominal strain, Wood, who has a knee problem, and Topley, who fractured his hand on his debut.
"I can't really accept what we dished up with the ball," Benkenstein added.
"That performance out there in the field is not good enough. We have also learnt that we don't have time in this competition.
"We can't expect a miracle like we did last year in the last four games. The signings that we made were exactly for that reason."

Teenager Lukas Carey could be in line to replace him after a fourth defeat, this time at the hands of Middlesex, put them out of contention.
But Glamorgan will choose from an unchanged 13 at the Ageas Bowl as they look to steady the ship.
Hampshire are currently in fourth, one point off the qualifying places with a game in hand
"One common theme (in the competition) is the form of Colin Ingram," said Glamorgan coach Robert Croft.
"Jacques Rudolph showing some form at the top of the order, that's been good, and we've been very good with the new ball.
"But it's been inconsistent, and when you are that inconsistent, results catch up with you.
"Marchant has played in every game so far, and Lukas Carey is chomping at the bit, so we'll weigh up some options."
Glamorgan's Colin Ingram has risen to the top of the Professional Cricketers' Association most valuable player ratings for the competition, after taking 4-39 and hitting 83 in the defeat against Middlesex.
"It's nice to get a few wickets, I always enjoy being part of the game and contributing" said Ingram.
"In patches we've played really nicely and found ways to lose our way, but some young guys are learning a lot at the moment.
"Every game is an opportunity for someone to put their hand up and start something good, a few guys are looking for time in the middle and to get into good form."
Rilee Rossouw hit 156 to steer Hampshire to a four-wicket win at Somerset in their most recent game.
Rossouw is one of eight players with senior international experience in Hampshire's 14-man squad, alongside fellow South African Kyle Abbott.
James Vince, Liam Dawson and Reece Topley (England), George Bailey (Australia), Sean Ervine (Zimbabwe) and Fidel Edwards (West Indies) are all included, while Aussie all-rounder Ian Holland is added to the previous squad.
Hampshire (from): Tom Alsop, Rilee Rossouw, James Vince (capt), George Bailey, Liam Dawson, Sean Ervine, Lewis McManus, Gareth Berg, Kyle Abbott, Mason Crane, Fidel Edwards, Jimmy Adams, Ian Holland, Reece Topley.
Glamorgan (from): Jacques Rudolph (capt), David Lloyd, Will Bragg, Colin Ingram, Kiran Carlson, Chris Cooke (wk), Aneurin Donald, Craig Meschede, Marchant de Lange, Timm van der Gugten, Michael Hogan, Andrew Salter, Lukas Carey.


Question: represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Thousands of heart attacks and strokes could be prevented if the cholesterol-lowering drugs, statins, were more widely prescribed, research suggests.

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article!

The study of 175,000 patients, in the Lancet,
 said even very low-risk patients benefited from the medication.
The Oxford researchers says the NHS should consider giving statins to healthy people. The NHS drugs watchdog, NICE, is reviewing the evidence.
However, statins have been linked to side-effects such as kidney failure.
They are among the most widely prescribed drugs in the UK and have long been known to help people at high risk of heart attack and stroke.
However, there has been considerable debate over medicating healthy people - both whether it works at all and if it would be socially acceptable.
Researchers at the University of Oxford say they have investigated the issue in "unparalleled" detail.
Their review of 27 trials concluded that statins significantly reduced the risk of heart attack and stroke for everyone.
Current rules from NICE - the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence - recommend statins for people who have a 20% or greater chance of developing cardiovascular disease within 10 years.
Doctors look at a patient's age, blood pressure, cholesterol levels and lifestyle to work out the risk.
One of the researchers, Prof Colin Baigent, told the BBC: "We've been taught over the years that high cholesterol is the thing that matters; you mustn't have high cholesterol.
"But what we've actually learned is that, whatever your level of cholesterol, reducing it further is beneficial.
"Whatever your level of risk, the benefits greatly exceed any known hazard."
He calculates that lowering the threshold for prescribing statins to a 10% risk of cardiovascular disease within a decade would lead to five million more people taking the drugs.
This in turn would save 2,000 lives and prevent 10,000 heart attacks or strokes every year, he said.
Prof Baigent said: "Half of [these] deaths come out of the blue in people who were previously healthy.
"If we are going to prevent that half of cardiac or stroke deaths, then we've got to consider treating healthy people.
"It can't be done any other way."
He, alongside fellow researchers, is now calling on NICE to review the evidence for giving statins to more people.
NICE, which sets drugs policy for England and Wales, said it was updating its guidelines.
The organisation said: "New evidence on statin treatment thresholds that has become available since publication of the original NICE guideline, including the study reported in the Lancet, will be considered as part of our review."
Their conclusions will be published towards the end of 2013.
One of the questions will be over side-effects. Statins have been linked to liver problems, kidney failure, muscle weakness and an increased risk of diabetes.
Prof Shah Ebrahim, from the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, conducted a large review of the evidence last year.
His results
 urged caution, and Prof Shah said doctors should stop prescribing to healthy patients.
He now says: "This research provides further evidence that statins are an effective and safe way of reducing the risk of heart attacks and strokes even among people at quite low risk of these conditions."
He suggests that universal prescribing to the over-50s might be appropriate, as 83% of 50-year old men have a 10% risk of cardiovascular disease in the next 10 years.
"The benefits of giving statins to everyone over the age of 50 would probably save the NHS money in the long run, owing to the savings in health care costs from the heart attacks and strokes prevented."
However, he questioned whether it would be good for people or society to resort to mass medication for lifestyle issues.

The National Institute of Health and Care Excellence says blood-thinning drugs like warfarin are better for those with atrial fibrillation, which can increase a person's risk of stroke.
Experts say most doctors are already doing this.
The advice will affect hundreds of thousands of patients.
Atrial fibrillation (AF), which causes an irregular heartbeat, is the most common heart rhythm problem, affecting up to 800,000 people - roughly one in 100 - in the UK.
In AF, the heart cannot work as well as it should and blood clots can form, which, in turn, increases the risk of a stroke.
Aspirin has been used for years to help protect patients from strokes, but mounting evidence suggests the drug's benefits are too small compared with other treatments.
The guidelines acknowledge this - it is the first time they will have been updated since they were originally issued in 2006.
The advice to switch from aspirin to a blood-thinning drug such as warfarin instead should prevent thousands of strokes.
Newer anticoagulants other than warfarin may be most suitable as they do not require regular monitoring, says NICE.
Experts say if aspirin is to be stopped, it should be stopped gradually and only under the advice of a doctor.
Prof Peter Weissberg, medical director at the British Heart Foundation, said: "Strokes caused by atrial fibrillation are both common and preventable but only if the abnormal heart rhythm is identified in the first place and if effective drugs are given to prevent blood-clot development.
"The revised NICE guidance reflects accumulating evidence that warfarin and the newer anticoagulants are much more effective than aspirin at preventing strokes.
"This does not mean that aspirin is not important and effective at preventing heart attacks and strokes in other circumstances. Patients who are unclear on whether or not they should continue to take aspirin should speak to their doctor."
Prof Peter Elwood, an expert at Cardiff University, warned it could be unsafe to suddenly stop taking aspirin. "If aspirin is to be stopped, it should be stopped gradually," he said.


Question: represent the following document E.g. "['represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details', 'A man stabbed on a train station concourse has died, police said.']" == "['Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary', 'The victim, in his 40s, was taken to hospital with life-threatening injuries following the stabbing at Plymouth station, but later died.\nA 29-year-old man has been arrested on suspicion of murder and is in police custody.\nBritish Transport Police said it was working to identify the man and inform his family and appealed for any witnesses to come forward.\nMore on the stabbing and other Devon and Cornwall news\nDet Ch Insp Paul Langley said: "This was an attack on a man in broad daylight at a busy station in Devon.\n"At this time, it is believed the two men knew each other and had an argument at the station, which resulted in one of the men assaulting the other.\n"The victim was taken to hospital but he sadly died despite the best efforts of the medical teams."\nA spokesman for South Western Ambulance Service said paramedics attended to two male casualties, one with minor injuries and another with head and shoulder injuries.\nThe ticket office of the station has been closed off due to the incident, leaving passengers unable to buy or collect reserved tickets.\nA spokesman for Great Western Railway said: "Access to Plymouth station is restricted and the ticket office remains closed while police continue to investigate the incident this morning.\n"The station remains open, with tickets available on platforms and on-board trains."\nNetwork Rail said trains were "running as normal".']" != "['Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence!', "Ben Gilkes, 25, of Stratford Road, Sparkhill, will appear at Birmingham Magistrates Court, West Midlands Police said.\nA man was arrested on Friday after the child was taken to Birmingham Children's Hospital with serious head injuries, police said.\nThe baby remains seriously ill since the assault in Hall Green on Friday, they added."]"

Question: Fernando Alonso has insisted he will not take a year off Formula 1 next year, following claims from McLaren boss Ron Dennis that he could.

Alonso is contracted until the end of 2017, but McLaren struggled in their first season with engine partner Honda.
And on Saturday, McLaren chairman Ron Dennis said a "sabbatical" for the Spaniard had been a "consideration".
Alonso has admitted the idea was discussed some months ago, but told BBC Sport on Sunday: "I won't do it."
The two-time champion's revelation is the first time he has categorically said he would be on the grid in 2016.
Alonso, 34, said on Saturday only that it was his "intention to race and I think I will race".
Dennis said on Sunday ahead of the season-ending Abu Dhabi Grand Prix: "There is no question Fernando and Jenson [Button] are the drivers for next year. End of story."
Asked whether Alonso could take a year out if the car turned out to be not as good as he was hoping, Dennis said: "That's not an option, we are totally committed. We know where we are going. We're going in the right direction. We are very confident with where we are on next year's car and very optimistic about all the work Honda is going and we anticipate being much stronger from the beginning of the season."
The confusion stemmed from Dennis' response to a question in a news conference about ambiguity over Alonso's future arising from events at the Japanese Grand Prix.
During the race at Suzuka at the end of September, Alonso criticised the Honda engine over the team radio and said its performance was "very embarrassing".
After the race, he told BBC Sport that he "didn't know" whether he would race at McLaren next year.
Later that day, he sent a series of tweets reaffirming his commitment to McLaren, saying: "No-one should have any doubt that I have three years with McLaren and my career in F1 will end with this team, hopefully winning everything."
Nevertheless, insiders have continued to express doubts about whether Alonso could stomach another season at the back of the grid if Honda is not able to significantly improve its engine for 2016.
There have been suggestions since Japan that, if the Honda engine remains uncompetitive in 2016, Alonso could take a year out and come back to fulfil the final two years of his contract in 2017 and 2018.
Dennis was asked whether there was any chance Alonso might not drive in 2016 if the car was uncompetitive in pre-season testing.
Media playback is not supported on this device
He replied: "He will definitely finish his career in McLaren. I have an open mind to anything.
"Some of the ideas have involved those sorts of considerations, sabbatical years, etc, but at this moment in time I would say we believe we know where we'll be and we navigated a difficult weekend in respect of our drivers.
"I took quite a high level of flak out of that weekend, it was a challenge to navigate through it.
"We have a great number of driver options. We have two of the best drivers in the world in our cars. When we have to take the decision, we will take it together and at this moment in time our drivers of next year are Fernando and Jenson Button."
McLaren insiders have expressed their dismay at Dennis's remarks, which caught Alonso by surprise.
Alonso said: "I don't know what his intention is behind or what he means with some of the things.
"Of course, we all want to improve and put the car on winter testing and see how competitive we are and we are hoping for the best."

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary:

Bottas, on whom Williams have a contractual hold, is Ferrari's number one option should they decide not to retain Kimi Raikkonen alongside Sebastian Vettel.
Sources close to the deal say Ferrari and Williams have discussed Bottas's transfer but have no agreement yet.
Williams view Button as a leading candidate should Bottas leave.
Should the 2009 world champion join Williams in 2016, it would bring his career full circle.
Media playback is not supported on this device
He made his F1 debut for Williams in 2000 before moving on to Benetton/Renault, BAR - which became Honda and then Brawn - and finally McLaren in a career in which he has won 15 grands prix.
McLaren have not yet decided who they will pick to drive alongside Fernando Alonso in 2016.
The team have a contractual option to retain Button, which means that the 2009 world champion cannot join another team unless McLaren decide not to keep him - or fail to decide until after whatever date is set in the contract as the team's deadline to do so.
Their other options are their Danish reserve driver Kevin Magnussen, who raced for McLaren alongside Button in 2014, and the Belgian rising star Stoffel Vandoorne, who is leading the GP2 championship. McLaren have contracts with both men.
Williams said they could not comment on driver contracts and Button said he had not yet considered his future.
"I've had a lot of questions thrown at me about what I am doing next year but I have not thought about anything, seriously," the 35-year-old said.
"I just have to get my head down and concentrate on improving the car and then in a couple of months we will sit down and talk about next year."
Media playback is not supported on this device
Bottas, on whom Williams have an option for the next two seasons, said he "did not know" whether he would be at Williams next season.
"Nothing is confirmed," the Finn said. "We have to wait and see. As a driver, you want to know as soon as possible but sometimes you have to wait."
Although Ferrari have pursued various options, sources close to the team say they have decided to put off a decision on Raikkonen's future until later in the summer.
Ferrari president Sergio Marchionne said last month that Raikkonen's "future is in his own hands" amid concerns at the team that he is not performing well enough compared to team-mate Sebastian Vettel.
These come on the back of his poor season in 2014 during which he was comprehensively out-performed by former team-mate Alonso.
Ferrari technical director James Allison said this week in an interview with an Italian magazine that Raikkonen was as fast as Vettel but that his results were being affected by the fact he was making more mistakes.
Raikkonen said: "I don't know any more than I knew at the start of the year. For me, the whole thing hasn't changed for months. If I knew I would easily say. Unfortunately I don't know.
"Somehow I end up every year in the same position, and it makes no difference if I have a contract or not. There is no contract, but there is an option now.
"I have made it very clear to the team what I would like to happen, and it is to be here next year."
If Bottas leaves and Button stays at McLaren, Williams may still look to McLaren's driver pool for a partner for Felipe Massa, on whom they have an option and is expected to stay.
Magnussen and Vandoorne could both be of interest to Williams.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Theresa May launched the Conservative Party's campaign for local elections in England, pledging to "protect and enhance workersâ€™ rights" when the UK leaves the EU.

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

Liberal Democrat Sarah Olney ousted ex-Conservative MP Zac Goldsmith after campaigning on the issue of Brexit.
Welsh Lib Dem leader Mark Williams said voters were saying they did not want a so called "hard Brexit".
The Conservatives have said the result "doesn't change anything" and ministers remain committed to leaving the EU.
Mr Goldsmith resigned his seat and stood as an independent in the southwest London constituency after the government backed a third Heathrow runway.
Celebrating overturning a 23,015 Tory majority, Mr Williams said Welsh Liberal Democrats were "proud" to have worked hard on the campaign.
"This win is not just about Richmond Park, but it is an important statement from the electorate that the government cannot continue to take us down the road to a hard Brexit, which would see us far poorer outside of the single market," he said.
"That would be bad for people in Richmond Park, and it would be disastrous for people in Wales, whether in towns and cities, or in small rural communities."
He added: "Sarah's victory must be a wake up call for both the government and politicians of all parties."
The Conservative Party said in a statement: "This result doesn't change anything.
"The government remains committed to leaving the European Union and triggering Article 50 by the end of March next year.
"In addition, we will continue to take decisive action in the national interest to secure the UK's place in the world."


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: A teaser for Disney's new live-action version of Beauty and the Beast became the most-viewed such clip of all time with 91.8 million hits in its first 24 hours, the Hollywood Reporter says.

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary

The 90-second clip had nearly four million more views than the previous title holder Star Wars: The Force Awakens, it says.
The new film features Emma "Harry Potter" Watson as Belle and Dan "Downton Abbey" Stevens as the Beast.
The film is due out in March 2017.
Beauty and the Beast, directed by Bill Condon, retells Disney's classic 1991 animated film.
Perhaps what is most impressive about the numbers is that the trailer does not actually give much of a glimpse of the film at all.
It contains only a fleeting view of Watson and the Beast's trademark growl - and the unmistakable tones of Sir Ian McKellan, who plays Cogsworth in the film, and Ewan McGregor, who voices Lumiere.

The South Korean megahit had been the site's most-played clip for the last five years.
The surreal video became so popular that it "broke" YouTube's play counter, exceeding the maximum possible number of views (2,147,483,647), and forcing the company to rewrite its code.
But the song has now been overtaken by another music video - Wiz Khalifa and Charlie Puth's See You Again.
The heart-wrenching ballad has now been streamed 2,895,373,709 times; beating Psy's current count of 2,894,426,475 views.
Adding it up, that means See You Again has been streamed for a total of 21,759 years. If one person was to listen to each of those streams consecutively, they'd have to have started during the glacial peak of the last Ice Age.
"I joined YouTube in 2007 hoping to make a video that would reach 10,000 views," wrote Charlie Puth on Twitter. "Just heard about See You Again... Wow."
The song was written for the action movie Furious 7, playing over the closing credits in tribute to the actor Paul Walker, who died in a car accident before the film was completed.
With its unabashedly sentimental lyrics ("it's been a long day without you my friend/ And I'll tell you all about it when I see you again"), See You Again has become one of the most frequently requested pop songs at funerals in the UK.
It was the best-selling song worldwide in 2015, and received best song nominations at both the Grammys and the Oscars.
The music video features the final scene of Furious 7, in which the two main characters Dominic Toretto (Vin Diesel) and Brian O'Conner (Cody Walker, filling in for his brother, Paul), drive side-by-side, sharing a smile for the last time before they pull onto separate roads and drive into the sunset.
As the camera pans up into the sky, a title card reads "For Paul" and the video ends.
The video reached 1 billion views in six months, and hit 2 billion last September. However, its reign as YouTube's most-watched clip may be short-lived.
Luis Fonsi's summer smash Despacito has racked up 2.5 billion views in just six months, and it shows no signs of slowing down.
The Puerto Rican song - sung in a mixture of Spanish and English - has been number one in the UK for the last eight weeks, thanks in part to a remix featuring Justin Bieber.
Whoever takes the title, though, its good news for Universal Music, which owns all of the songs.
Meanwhile, 47 of the top 50 clips on YouTube are music videos, proving the importance of the streaming site to the music industry - despite the fact the two sides are locked in a battle over royalty payments.
According to analysis by Midia Research, every stream on YouTube generates $0.001 for the music industry.
If accurate, that means Wiz Khalifa and Charlie Puth's song has earned $2.9m (Â£2.2m) from YouTube  - roughly the same amount it has made from 665 million plays on Spotify.
Follow us on Facebook, on Twitter @BBCNewsEnts, or on Instagram at bbcnewsents. If you have a story suggestion email entertainment.news@bbc.co.uk.


Question: represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: Warrington missed out on the chance to extend their Super League lead with a shock defeat at Huddersfield.

represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary

The hosts came into the game bottom of the table, but took a well-deserved half-time lead when Aaron Murphy went over in the corner.
Warrington offered little in attack, and Danny Brough extended the Giants' lead with a penalty and a drop-goal.
Leroy Cudjoe's late try sealed the win for Huddersfield, who remain 12th after fellow strugglers Leeds beat Hull FC.
Warrington remain top of the league after extending their winless run against Giants to five games, but Tony Smith's side are now level on points with both Catalans and Wigan.
Wolves were poor in possession and were perhaps fortunate not to concede more points, as both Joe Wardle and and Oliver Roberts were held up over the line for the home side.
The visitors were able to prevent Jermaine McGillvary scoring for an eighth successive match for Huddersfield, but persistent errors in attack saw them lose in consecutive games for the first time this season.
Huddersfield head coach Paul Anderson: "Just the win is pleasing. It was important in regard to where we're at.
"But we can't rest on our laurels, we need another 12 like that if we are to give ourselves a chance.
"We want to be in the top eight, not the middle eight."
Warrington head coach Tony Smith: "It's a concern. We're not happy and we're going to change our training routine. We're going to do things differently.
"I thought our defence was terrific but we couldn't match Danny Brough's kicking game.
"He kicked us to death twice last year and he was at it again."
Huddersfield: Brierley; McGillvary, Cudjoe, Connor, Murphy; Brough, Wood; Johnson, Hinchcliffe, Huby, Wardle, Ta'ai, Lawrence.
Replacements: Rapira, Leeming, Mason, Roberts.
Warrington: Russell; Penny, Hughes, Atkins, Evans; Gidley, Ratchford; Hill, Clark, Sims, Westwood, Currie, Westerman.
Replacements: King, Philbin, Jullien, Wilde.
Referee: Richard Silverwood.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

The 25-year-old, who has played 20 games for Rovers this term, dislocated his acromioclavicular (AC) joint in the 24-20 defeat by Leeds in July.
The injury comes as a blow for a Hull KR side looking to retain its Super League status though the Qualifiers.
Rovers, who finished second from bottom in Super League, host Batley in their Qualifiers opener on Sunday.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: A driver filmed screaming obscenities at BBC presenter Jeremy Vine as he cycled on a narrow road has been found guilty of road rage offences.

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article:

Shanique Syrena Pearson, 22, made a gun sign and threatened Mr Vine during the row in Kensington, west London.
She was convicted of using threatening, abusive or insulting words or behaviour.
Pearson was also found guilty of driving without reasonable consideration for other road users.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence:

Balin Hobbs, 52, was cycling on the hard shoulder of the M5 when police forced him from the road and into a service station near Cullompton, Devon.
He admitted riding a pedal cycle on a motorway and resisting arrest, at Exeter Magistrates' Court.
He was given a 12-month conditional discharge and ordered to pay a Â£20 victim surcharge.
More on motorway cyclist and more Devon stories
The court heard how Hobbs cycled to Devon from London to attend the court hearing because it was against his spiritual beliefs to be driven in petrol or diesel vehicles.
It took him three days and he slept on the courtroom steps the night before.
Hobbs was heading towards Bristol on the M5 on his bike during the afternoon of April 29 when police caught up with him.
He overtook the police car, and they forced him from the road after a further two miles when he went into a service station at Junction 28.
He wrestled with officers as he was arrested and put into a police van, the court heard.
Hobbs, whose address was given as Hennock, Devon, but who is living in London, said: "You are putting me in shackles for no reason."
Hobbs, who had no previous convictions, defended himself in court, and said: "I was definitely on the M5 on my bike."
But he claimed the police had "intimidated, harassed and harangued me" adding: "I did not intend to cycle on the M5 but I had to try and find my way to Bristol and then London."
Following the hearing, he mounted his bike to begin the journey back to London.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: The US Federal Reserve has cut its growth forecast for 2014 because of the harsh winter weather.

The central bank is now predicting growth of between 2.1% and 2.3% for this year, down from its March forecast of 2.8% to 3%.
However in its accompanying statement, the bank said that economic activity had "rebounded in recent months".
As expected, it has also trimmed back its stimulus programme by $10bn (Â£5.9bn) a month to $35bn.
The central bank has been buying bonds to keep long-term interest rates low and encourage banks to lend.
This is the fifth cut in purchases since December and it is expected to stop buying bonds altogether by the autumn.
However the chair of the bank, Janet Yellen, stressed that this was not a pre-set programme and if necessary it would change course.
As far as interest rates go, the bank said they would remain near zero "for a considerable time" after the bond buying ends.
Questioned as to how long that might be, Ms Yellen said there was "no mechanical formula" and that it "depends on how the economy progresses".
It was another small step in withdrawing the exceptional policies the Fed undertook in the wake of the financial crisis. But it was very clear from Janet Yellen's comments that it will be a long time before the US is truly back to health.
The Fed's main interest rate is currently close to zero and it's likely to stay there for a "considerable time". And when they do start raising it, the Fed's policy makers expect it to be a long wait before it gets back to levels that would be considered normal.
They remain concerned about the residual effects of the financial crisis, which they suggest means the economy's potential to grow may be lower.
So here we are, seven years on from the onset of the crisis, looking at an economy that was actually relatively quick to rebound, and still the lingering after effects will last for years more.  So too will the need for treatment in the form of abnormally low interest rates.
Currently, most market watchers do not expect them to rise until at least the middle of 2015.
Ward McCarthy, chief financial economist at Jeffries and Fed watcher for 30 years, said:
"It's clear they do not have a specific time frame for rate rises. But there also seems to be a wide range of opinions internally as to how quickly they should normalise rates [once they start rising]."
Mr Ward thinks interest rates will rise in the second half of 2015.
"Janet Yellen has made clear the condition of the labour market is the top priority and she's still very dissatisfied with it. She wants to buy as much time as possible for people on the fringes of the labour market to get back in."
On inflation, Ms Yellen said she expected it to remain at or below the target of 2% until the end of 2016. Low inflation would enable the bank to keep interest rates low.
The Federal Reserve expects growth to pick up again in 2015, sticking to its prediction of 3% to 3.2% expansion.
"Economic activity will expand at a moderate pace and labour market conditions will continue to improve gradually," the central bank said.
"Household spending appears to be rising moderately and business fixed investment resumed its advance."
Kim Rupert from Action Economics in San Francisco said: "Steady as she goes, with respect to policy. [They] want to make sure the recovery is for real and is in place and are still maintaining a very accommodative posture."

The IMF now says the global economy will expand by 3.3% in 2015, compared with a previous forecast of 3.5%.
Last month, the IMF lowered is forecast for US growth to 2.5% in 2015 from an earlier estimate of 3.1%.
The US is a drag on the world economy, according to the IMF, because of "an unexpected output contraction".
The US economy contracted at an annual rate of 0.2% in the first quarter of the year after being hit by bad weather.
The IMF said Greece's crisis was having a only a marginal effect on the global economy and it left its eurozone growth forecast for 2015 unchanged at 1.5%.
It predicted Germany would grow by 1.6% and France by 1.2%, also unchanged from the previous forecast.
The IMF has left its forecast for growth in China unchanged at 6.8%, despite the recent stock market volatility.
"The bubble has burst," Olivier Blanchard, director of the Research Department at the IMF, said of the Chinese stock market's wild swings.
But he did not say that China's stock market volatility would drag down the global economy.
The IMF also cited Greece's debt crisis as a continuing risk to the global economy, but said the events in China and Greece "have not changed the broad outlook picture for the global economy".
In 2016, the IMF expects global growth to strengthen to 3.8%.


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: One in 10 women in Britain finds sex painful says a large study of more than 7,000 women.

The reasons vary from physical issues to anxiety.
We spoke to four women who have experienced painful sex.
Natasha Kilby, aged 34, had experienced pain during sex throughout her long-term relationship with her partner but after receiving treatment they got married in December 2016.
"The problem started at university. Every time I thought about having sex, I felt horrible and I didn't want him to touch me.
"Eventually I was diagnosed with a very rare form of thrush, but by that point, the pain had created psychological barriers.
"The only way I could have sex was by getting really drunk or I'd force myself to do it, which upset my partner.
"I felt like I wasn't in a real relationship. For some time we only had sex once a year.
"I didn't want to get married until we solved the problem because I didn't feel like I could be a proper wife - our 'sex' life consisted of a peck on the cheek.
"I began to receive counselling, which worked and now our relationship is improving.
"The thought of having a baby used to be impossible but now we are in a much better place."
Hannah Bradley, aged 19, has always experienced pain during sex.
"Sex has been painful since I first had sex three years ago.
"I went to the doctor who suggested that I change contraceptive, then I was treated with dilation for vaginismus and later I had a procedure to cauterise my cervix, but these did not solve the problem.
"I had psychosexual therapy for two months, but I believe that the problem is physical not emotional.
"Now they think I might have vaginal scarring and tightening after untreated lichen sclerosus.
"I found it very difficult that I could not have sex. I felt really left out of conversations with my friends, and like I could not understand their lives.
"I only felt pain and I was jealous of their experience.
"It makes me feel different. Most people my age have an active sex life and I cannot have that.
"It still upsets me. My partner is understanding but it is upsetting for him too. I want to have sex but I physically cannot.
"I hope that it will improve soon, but no-one knows what is wrong. I'm still young and sex should be part of my life"
Sarah (not her real name), aged 20, cannot have sex without extreme pain, which led to the breakdown of her relationship with her boyfriend.
"Sex became gradually more painful to the point where it was just impossible - my vagina would literally close up and not allow anything in without excruciating pain.
"The physical and psychological symptoms for vaginismus matched up with mine so I decided to go to my university's student health clinic.
"The nurse suggested that I do some stretches with my fingers every day and see how I felt after a couple of months - it was completely unhelpful and, if anything, I had even less confidence than when I walked in there.
"My GP later told me it can be a very psychological condition - my brain associates sex with pain and so my body does everything it can to prevent that pain.
"This condition has made me feel increasingly angry, frightened, isolated, inadequate, anxious and depressed.
"I fear not only sex but any kind of intimacy and I have lost interest in doing anything.
"This put a huge strain on my relationship, leading to daily arguments and constant self-blaming on my part. I kept thinking it was all my fault my relationship was ruined because my body was malfunctioning.
"Eventually we faced the fact that I couldn't continue with it any longer, with the guilt of depriving any form of physicality to the relationship as well as being constantly angry.
"I don't know what it will take to 'fix' me but I am coming to terms with the fact this is going to be my life for quite a while and I don't think I'll be able to have any form of relationship in that time.
"The psychological effects are more damaging than the physical - I strongly feel the shame of the inability to have sex.
"Health issues related to dyspareunia need to be looked into - we all what know erectile dysfunction is but we hardly know anything about how dyspareunia affects women's health."
Margaret (not her real name), aged 68, has not had sex with her husband for 16 years because of pain she experiences during intercourse.
"There is a link between the physical side and the emotional impact.
"At the beginning we had sex a lot and I never thought something like this would happen.
"GPs are impatient and do not take me seriously - they say that women my age should not expect an enjoyable sex life.
"I got used to it but it has an impact on our relationship.
My husband says that he does not mind that we cannot have sex but it is important to me and it makes me feel really sad - I  feel like I've cheated my husband of a proper sex life.
"I used to think that it would improve but now I have just given up on the idea that we will ever have a sex life again."
Produced by Georgina Rannard, BBC UGC & Social news team

A once-a-decade poll of 15,000 Britons found those aged 16-44 were having sex fewer than five times a month.
The figure compared with more than six times a month on the last two occasions when the official National Survey of Sexual Attitudes and Lifestyles was carried out, in 1990-91 and 1999-2001.
The study's authors say modern life may be having an impact on libidos.
Dr Cath Mercer, from University College London, said: "People are worried about their jobs, worried about money. They are not in the mood for sex.
"But we also think modern technologies are behind the trend too. People have tablets and smartphones and they are taking them into the bedroom, using Twitter and Facebook, answering emails."
She also said the survey suggested that couples aged 16 to 44 may be using online porn as a substitute for sex.
Men polled in 2010 to 2012 reported having sex 4.9 times a month and women 4.8. In both previous surveys the averages were more than six for both sexes both times.
The survey carried out by NatCen Social Research and analysed by researchers from University College London and the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine also asked older people about their sex lives.
It found 42% of women and 60% of men aged 65 to 74 had had sex in the past year.
Nonetheless, they were the age groups having the least sex - 2.3 times a month for men and 1.4 for women.
Among men, the 25-to-34 age group were having the most sex - 5.4 times a month - and for women it was the 16-to-24 age group, 5.8 times.
The latest survey, which is carried out every 10 years, also shows the age at which people start having sex is lower in the younger age groups.
The average age for the under-25s is 16 compared with 19 for men and 18 for women in the 65-to-74 age group.
Among other findings:
Genevieve Edwards, from Marie Stopes International, said: "A key insight from the survey is that people are having sex earlier and having children later, which means that, on average, women in Britain spend about 30 years of their life needing to avert an unplanned pregnancy, yet many are not being informed about or offered the full range of services.
"Long-acting contraceptives, for example, can be extremely effective and convenient but too many are never offered the choice."
But the poll - the full details of which have been reported in the Lancet - also revealed the extent to which people are forced to have sex against their will.
One in 10 women and one in 70 men said they had experienced it.
However, fewer than half had told anyone about it and even fewer (13% of women and 8% of men) had reported the crime to the police.
A selection of your comments:


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Riot police in Mexico has clashed with students who had seized 12 buses in order to travel to a protest in the central state of Guerrero.

Police confronted them using tear gas at a road block close to the city of Chilpancingo.
Eleven officers were reported injured.
The students were planning to demonstrate against the findings of an official inquiry into the disappearance of 43 trainee teachers from their college last year.
They accuse the authorities of covering up the involvement of corrupt Mexican politicians in the killings.
The confrontation takes place in the run-up for the first anniversary of the disappearance, on 26 September.
Police say they set up a road block in the municipality of Tixtla and tried to persuade the students to return to Ayotzinapa.
At least 200 policemen took part in the operation.
On Monday, protesters had ransacked the prosecutor's office in Chilpancingo.
Masked students reacted by hurling petrol bombs and setting fire to a lorry on the road, the authorities say.
They eventually gave up their attempts to travel to Chilpancingo.
The disappearance of the 43 trainee teachers from the Ayotzinapa Rural Teachers' College caused outrage across the country.
The young men had travelled to Iguala, also in Guerrero state, for a protest over job discrimination against teachers of a rural background.
An official investigation found that the local mayor ordered their arrest after they disturbed a planned speech by his wife.
They were handed over to a criminal gang, Guerreros Unidos (United Warriors), who killed them and incinerated their bodies in a nearby rubbish dump, the report said.
Relatives never believed in the official version. They said it was covering up the involvement of more senior politicians and perhaps the army in criminal activities in the region.
Earlier this month, independent investigators dismissed the official inquiry, saying it was flawed.
The Mexican government stood by its conclusions but announced it would send forensic experts back to the area where the bodies are supposed to have been cremated by the drug gang.
DNA testing has so far enabled forensic experts to identify only two of the 43 missing students.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence.

One of those killed was a serving police officer who had tried to halt robberies at a petrol station.
The government announced last month that it would stop subsidising petrol and prices would gradually increase through 2017.
An increase of 20% came into force on 1 January.
It brought the price of a litre of petrol to 18 pesos ($0.85; Â£0.70).
That makes the average price of a gallon of petrol around the same as the daily minimum wage - 80 pesos ($3.77, Â£3.07) - and the raise has caused outrage among people dependent on petrol for their jobs.
President Enrique Pena Nieto has called for calm, saying the price hike is necessary after a rise in global oil prices.
In a televised address to the nation, he said keeping the subsidy would have put the country's whole economy at risk.
He said raising the petrol price was a "difficult and unpopular but necessary decision".
Traffic ground to a halt in Mexico City as transport workers and lorry drivers set up blockades. Protesters called for the president to stand down.
In the central town of Ixmiquilpan, two protesters died during clashes with police who were trying to clear a major road between Mexico City and Laredo.
In Veracruz, one person died after being hit by a lorry in which alleged looters were trying to escape the authorities, police sources said.
Hundreds of shops were looted, with some emptied of clothing, TVs and other consumer goods.
Some skirmishes have broken out between rioters and people who have armed themselves with planks, machetes and rocks in an attempt to prevent looting.
In Monterrey in northern Mexico, at least six protest marches convened on the state government's palace in the centre of town. Gunfire erupted and some of the 10,000 protesters threw stones and broke stained glass windows.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: Vogue magazine has endorsed Hillary Clinton ahead of the US presidential election next month.

represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

The Democratic candidate will face Republican rival Donald Trump when Americans go to the polls on 8 November.
In an editorial, the magazine said: "Vogue has no history of political endorsements.
"Given the profound stakes of this one, and the history that stands to be made, we feel that should change."
Trump v Clinton: Who's ahead in the polls?
All you need to know about the US election
US Election 2016: Daily updates from the campaign trail
The article reminds readers the magazine has previously profiled Clinton six times.
Vogue, which has been led by editor-in-chief Anna Wintour since 1988, added Clinton "knows the challenges working women face".
"We understand that Clinton has not always been a perfect candidate, yet her fierce intelligence and considerable experience are reflected in policies and positions that are clear, sound, and hopeful," the editorial said.
But the magazine criticised "the chaos and unpredictability and the sometimes appalling spectacle of this election season".
On Wednesday evening, Clinton and Trump will go head to head in the final televised debate of the campaign season.
Follow us on Twitter @BBCNewsEnts, on Instagram, or if you have a story suggestion email entertainment.news@bbc.co.uk.

Internecine strife among Republicans over Donald Trump risked escalating into a political bloodbath as the party's most senior elected member, Paul Ryan, took the extraordinary step of effectively washing his hands of their standard-bearer. Diehard Trumpistas are enraged by Republican bosses shunning their own presidential nominee. During a conference call, one Congressman lambasted them as "cowards".
Clinton held her biggest campaign event yet, drawing 18,500 people to a rally in Columbus, Ohio, suggesting her base may be rallying round her after Sunday's vicious televised debate. The Democratic candidate also vaulted to an 11-point national lead in an NBC News-Wall Street Journal poll conducted over the weekend.
Nancy O'Dell, the woman who was the subject of lewd comments in the now-infamous Trump sex-boast tape, said: "There is no room for objectification of women," as she hosted her TV show Entertainment Tonight. The creator of The Apprentice, meanwhile, said he cannot legally release footage from the show, disappointing those hoping for a fresh batch of compromising Trump archive clips.
It's not just the Republican establishment that's split - the choice facing the nation has divided households, too, as the BBC's Rajini Vaidyanathan found out...
Following Trump's suggestion that Hispanics in Las Vegas prefer to be called Latinos, BBC Mundo treads carefully into the minefield of US ethnic identity politics.
BBC security correspondent Gordon Corera examines the murky claim that Russia is trying to hack the US presidential election.
And squillionaire Clinton supporter Warren Buffett released his tax details after Trump accused him of exploiting loopholes to dodge paying his dues.
66.5 million - the number of Americans who tuned in for Sunday night's second presidential debate, a sharp fall from the first one two weeks earlier, which attracted a record-breaking 84 million viewers.
But this time the two candidates were up against the NFL game between the Green Bay Packers and the New York Giants, which was watched by 16.6 million people on NBC.
Yet another member of the Bush clan has come out in support of Hillary Clinton.
Lauren Bush Lauren posted a black-and-white photo of the Democratic candidate on her social media accounts with the caption, "#ImWithHer ðŸ‡ºðŸ‡¸".
Her grandfather, former president George HW Bush, and cousin, Barbara Pierce Bush, have recently telegraphed their support for Clinton.
Can it be coincidence that Lauren Bush Lauren's father-in-law, fashion designer Ralph Lauren, has dressed Clinton for her big moments during this campaign season?
Both presidential candidates will hit the trail in the Florida, which some analysts say could hold the keys to the White House on 8 November.
As a legal battle rages over extending voter registration in this pivotal battleground state, Clinton will be on the stump down in Miami alongside former US vice-president Al Gore.
Trump will hold a rally at Panama City Beach up in the Panhandle.
Who is ahead in the polls?
48%
Hillary Clinton
44%
Donald Trump
Last updated October 10, 2016


Question: represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: A hospital has apologised for wrongly diagnosing a patient with bowel cancer.

The Royal Cornwall Hospitals Trust said the incorrect diagnosis was given in an automatically generated letter sent in November.
The trust, which has sites in Truro, Hayle and Penzance, said it has changed procedures and the mistake was "the result of an administrative error".
The error was revealed in the trust's board papers. The identity of the patient has not been released.
A trust spokesman said it had apologised to the patient and their family.
The spokesman said: "This was an isolated incident and as a result of the error changes have been made to ensure it cannot be repeated in the future."

John Dudding, 80, died in Derriford Hospital, Plymouth, three days after being given the drug in February 2012.
On Tuesday the inquest in Plymouth was told he was allergic to penicillin.
His allergy was recorded on his notes but the doctor who prescribed it said the section on allergies had been covered up with a post-it note.
Mr Dudding, from Sutton in Plymouth, was admitted to hospital after suffering a fall at his home.
He was given a red wristband showing he had an allergy when he was admitted.
Derriford Hospital had previously admitted a "serious error" but says it is for the inquest to decide if it contributed to his death.
On Tuesday the inquest heard Mr Dudding was in a terminal phase of his life and had significant kidney injury before having the antibiotic.
The inquest continues.