Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story.

Question: Russia must wait to learn if it can send a team to next month's Olympics after calls for it to be barred from the Rio Games for operating a four-year, state-sponsored doping programme.

Media playback is not supported on this device
The International Olympic Committee (IOC) said it will "explore the legal options" before deciding whether to implement "a collective ban" on all Russian competitors for the global showpiece, which starts on 5 August.
In the meantime, the IOC says it plans to re-test all Russians who competed at the 2014 Winter Olympics in Sochi.
This follows the findings of the McLaren report, which said urine samples of Russian competitors were manipulated across the "vast majority" of summer and winter Olympic sports from late 2011 to August 2015.
The IOC also said it will:
Calls for a blanket ban on Russia - from both the Olympics and Paralympics - followed the publication of the McLaren report on Monday.
IOC president Thomas Bach said the findings of the report were a "shocking and unprecedented attack on the integrity of sport and on the Olympic Games".
Wada president Sir Craig Reedie described the "scope and scale" of the findings as a "real horror story".
He said his organisation wanted the IOC to "decline entries, for Rio 2016, of all athletes" submitted by the Russian Olympic and Paralympic committees.
Mutko, meanwhile, has denied that the government directed the doping programme in Russia.
He also told the Interfax news agency he was hoping for a "reasonable" decision from the IOC on Russia's participation in Rio.
BBC Radio 5 live sports news correspondent Richard Conway:
"Is what Russia has done here so bad that it warrants a collective ban, as no Russian can be above suspicion and therefore no Russians should go to Rio? Or is it a case that individual sporting federations should decide for themselves if certain Russian athletes can go? It's a very complicated area.
"It looks, on the face of this statement, as though the IOC is edging towards a blanket ban. Russia want to be at the Olympics. It would be a national humiliation for them not to be. So they will fight on to try to make sure their athletes are there next month."
Commissioned by Wada, it looked into claims made by Grigory Rodchenkov, the former head of Russia's national anti-doping laboratory.
He alleged he doped dozens of athletes, including at least 15 medallists, in the build-up to the Sochi Games.
He said this was the result of an elaborate plot with the Russian government, which exploited its host status to subvert the drug-testing programme.
Russia topped the table in Sochi, winning 33 medals, 13 of them gold.
Rodchenkov, now in hiding in the United States, also alleged he doped athletes before the 2012 Olympics in London, the 2013 World Athletics Championships in Moscow and the 2015 World Swimming Championships in Kazan.
It has already suspended a number of senior sports officials following the publication of the McLaren report.
Despite his denial of any state-sponsored doping programme, sports minister Mutko told the R-Sport news agency he had suspended anti-doping advisor Natalia Zhelanova as well as Irina Rodionova, deputy head of Russia's state-funded Sports Preparation Centre, and two other officials.
McLaren said Zhelanova and Rodionova had worked closely with Russian deputy sports minister Yury Nagornykh to cover up positive tests since 2011. Nagornykh has also been suspended.
Football's world governing body Fifa will look at claims in the report that Mutko was involved in covering up positive dope tests by footballers.
Mutko is a Fifa council member, the president of the 2018 Russia World Cup organising committee, president of the Russian Football Union and a member of Uefa's executive.
Russia's track and field athletes are already barred from competing at the 2016 Olympics in Rio as a result of doping violations.
The International Association of Athletics Federations, the body that governs world athletics, voted in June to maintain a global competition ban on the All-Russia Athletic Federation (Araf).
Araf hopes to overturn the suspension and will find out by Thursday if its appeal to Cas has been successful.
He is the Canadian law professor who led the independent commission that looked into allegations of state-sponsored doping in Russia.
He said his investigative team had found 580 positive tests were covered up across 30 different sports in the build-up to the 2012 Olympics in London and during the 2014 Winter Olympics in the Russian city of Sochi.
McLaren added he had "only skimmed the surface" in his 57-day investigation.
Now the IOC and Wada want him to "complete his mandate" by identifying athletes who benefited from the doping programme.
Media playback is not supported on this device
Toni Minichiello, coach of British Olympic heptathlon champion Jessica Ennis-Hill, told BBC Radio 4 there was "no need to ban a nation".
"Who are the real victims here?" he said. "The real victims are athletes that missed out on medals.
"Let's ban these hundreds of athletes, re-test them all and not allow them to go to Rio or any future Olympics. That decimates a Russian team anyway.
"There needs to be a huge investment in anti-doping at major championships to make sure things don't happen again."

represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence
------
Fewshot example: "['Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence', 'It says the closure of some power stations will have left spare capacity on the system at just 1.2% - the worst for a decade.\nThe grid has secured extra supplies by paying Â£36m to have several plants on standby and by asking some industries to switch off power.\nThe move will add 50 pence to the typical household energy bill.\nHowever, it also means overall spare capacity is now expected to be about 5%.\n"It\'s clear that electricity margins for that coldest, darkest half hour of winter are currently tighter than they have been, due to power stations closures", said Cordi O\'Hara, National Grid\'s director of market operations.\nTo ensure the lights stay on, for the second year running, National Grid will pay firms like Centrica and SSE to keep power plants in reserve.\nIt is also paying large energy users, such as Tata Steel, to switch off.\nA total of 2.56GW of power has been secured, which National Grid said would increase overall margins to 5.1%.\nThat is still lower than the spare capacity available last winter after similar measures.\n"As system operator, we feel we\'ve taken a sensible precaution again this winter to buy some extra services", said Cordi O\'Hara.\n"Together with the tools we already use to balance the network these additional services will significantly increase the energy reserve available this winter."\nKeeping the lights on is getting more challenging.\nEU regulations have forced older polluting power plants to close.\nLow wholesale power prices have continued that trend making some plants uneconomic to keep open.\nAround 2GW of power has come off the system since last year with the closure of plants including Barking Power Station, Ferrybridge and Littlebrook.\n"The economics of generation are terrible" said Peter Atherton, a utilities analyst at Jefferies Investment Bank.\n"Every gas fired plant is losing money. And new build is not delivering. Hence the underlying margins are getting worse".\nThe government insists that the lights will stay on this winter.\n"Our priority is to ensure that British families and business have access to secure affordable energy supplies that they can rely on", said Energy Minister Andrea Leadsom.\n"National Grid have confirmed that our plan to power the economy is working - and it means that the lights will stay on this winter as well as making sure our homes and businesses have the gas and electricity they need in the future."\nNational Grid is now looking at whether it will need to secure more standby generation for the next two years.\nIt had been assumed that the spare capacity on the power network would hit a low in the coming winter and then increase in subsequent years.\nBut National Grid now says that owing to uncertainties, it is no longer clear that margins will recover in the winter of 2016-17.\nNational Grid will now consult on this and will publish final margin figures for the coming winter in the autumn.']" == "['represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story\n\n\nExamples:\n\'Shrewsbury boss Paul Hurst has told young goalkeeper Callum Burton that he must be ready to take his chance if he gets a first-team opening next season.\' == \'After making his Town debut on the final day of the 2015-16 season, Burton was limited to just three mid-campaign appearances on their bench in 2016-17.\nBut Hurst must now decide if Burton, 20, will be second choice next season following the release of Mark Halstead.\n"Sometimes you never know until they\'re thrown in," Hurst told BBC Shropshire.\n"Sometimes circumstances dictate and then it\'s sink or swim time.\n"There\'s enough people that have gone on to have careers who I\'m sure have made their debut due to circumstance rather than the manager thinking \'he\'s ready to play and I\'m sure he\'s going to do superbly well for us\'."\nThe reportedly once much-coveted Burton\'s experience has so far come in non-league, having had loan spells with Nuneaton Town and Southport in the Conference in 2014-15.\nHe was then loaned out again to sixth-tier level last season, first rejoining Nuneaton Town, before then going to fellow National League North side Telford.\nWhile Jayson Leutwiler will remain Town\'s first-choice keeper, Hurst now has to decide whether he needs to bring in a more established back-up keeper.\nMeanwhile, BBC Shropshire reports that experienced Irish midfielder Gary Deegan has been made available for a free transfer this summer.\' != \'Scotland\'s domestic football season kicks off on Friday with three Scottish League Cup ties.\nThistle number one Tomas Cerny had already been ruled out through injury and deputy Ryan Scully is struggling with a thigh strain.\nSo they turned to 31-year-old Crawford, who was released by Alloa Athletic.\nCrawford, who only played 12 times for the Wasps last season as they suffered relegation from the Scottish Championship, featured for the Premiership side as a trialist in a friendly against Greenock Morton last weekend.\nThistle will become the 10th side for whom he has played should he debut against the Diamonds, with Ayr United and Dumbarton among Crawford\'s former clubs.\nScully, who signed a new two-year contract in May, was hoping to establish himself as first choice after a run of games at the end of last season following an injury to Cerny.\n"I got a taste of the action towards the end of the season," said the 23-year-old ahead of Thistle\'s visit to Excelsior Stadium.\n"It was a great experience for me to play at the highest level in Scotland and it gives me the extra bit of confidence knowing I can play at that level.\n"With Tomas\' form last year, it was going to take an injury for me to step in, but it is up to me now.\n"If I get my chance then hopefully I can take it."\'', 'The risk of blackouts this winter has increased compared with a year ago, according to National Grid.']"

Gian-Franco Kasper, a Swiss ski official, made the comparison during an IOC board meeting in Pyeongchang.
The board is debating whether to suspend the entire Russian team from the Games following a doping scandal.
"I apologise unreservedly for any offence I have caused. I am truly sorry," Franco Kasper said.
The International Ski Federation President was discussing a proposed blanket ban on Russian athletes when he made the Holocaust comment, referring to the World War II genocide that saw six million Jews killed by Adolf Hitler's Nazi Germany.
He reportedly said: "I'm just against bans or sanctioning of innocent people. Like Mr Hitler did - all Jews were to be killed, independently of what they did or did not do."
When challenged by reporters at the time, Franco Kasper responded: "Why not? Of course it's more extreme. But just the fact that the place you come from makes you guilty, I'm not OK for this, really not."
Russia did not receive a blanket ban from the IOC from the 2016 Olympics in Rio, opting to leave the decision to individual sports' governing bodies.
A report in December 2016 claimed Russian medallists from summer and winter Olympics had benefited from a state-sponsored doping programme between 2011 and 2015.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story:

Question: The head of Amnesty International in Turkey has been charged with membership of a terrorist organisation and remanded in custody pending trial, the group has said.

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

Taner Kilic was detained on Tuesday in the province of Izmir along with 22 other lawyers.
The arrests were part of a crackdown following last July's failed coup attempt.
Amnesty called the charges "a mockery of justice".
The human rights group's secretary general, Salil Shetty, demanded Mr Kilic's immediate release and said charges against him should be dropped.
"The charges... show just how arbitrary, just how sweeping, the Turkish government's frenzied pursuit of its perceived enemies and critics has become," he said.
Amnesty's Turkey researcher Andrew Gardner tweeted: "Human rights defender, Amnesty Turkey chair Taner Kilic remanded in pre-trial detention. No credible evidence presented at hearing. Shame!"
Amnesty has been a vocal critic of the crackdown on suspected coup plotters. It said last year it had "credible reports" of detainees being subjected to "beatings and torture, including rape".
Mr Kilic is accused of using an encrypted messaging application called Bylock that the government says was used by followers of the US-based Islamic preacher Fethullah Gulen.
President Recep Tayyip Erdogan accuses Mr Gulen of instigating the coup attempt - a charge the cleric denies.
Amnesty said in a statement that Mr Kilic denied "ever having downloaded or used Bylock, or even having heard of it".
More than 40,000 people were arrested and 120,000 sacked or suspended in the aftermath of the failed coup. They include police, military personnel, teachers and public servants.
Last month police arrested 1,000 people and issued arrest warrants for another 3,224 in an operation across 81 provinces.
The police force also suspended more than 9,000 officers over alleged links to Mr Gulen.
Mr Erdogan's critics say he is using the coup as a pretext to crush dissent and purge opponents.

represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary

Cumhuriyet newspaper's editor-in-chief Can Dundar and its Ankara representative Erdem Gul have been charged with espionage.
Prosecutors accuse them of working with a US-based cleric to discredit the government.
The harsh punishment being sought has intensified press freedom concerns.
EU Enlargement Commissioner Johannes Hahn said he was "shocked" at the severity of the sentence sought by prosecutors.
Human Rights Watch said the two "were doing their job as journalists and no more than that".
In its report last May, Cumhuriyet published video of police finding weapons in trucks that it said were linked to Turkish intelligence.
The Turkish authorities insisted the trucks, which had been intercepted near the Syrian border, were in fact bringing aid to Syria's Turkmen minority.
But the report caused uproar and prompted President Reccep Tayyip Erdogan to file a lawsuit against the journalists.
Mr Erdogan said the video footage was a state secret and vowed on TV that the journalists "would pay a heavy price".
The pair were detained in November and told the BBC they were kept in solitary confinement for 40 days before being allowed to share a cell.
The government accuses them of helping the Hizmet movement led by Fethullah Gulen, who lives in self-imposed exile in Pennsylvania.
Mr Erdogan has accused Mr Gulen of plotting against him, although Mr Gulen denies this.
Mr Dundar and Mr Gul are accused of working with Hizmet to create the impression that the Turkish government was helping terror groups, thus weakening its ability to rule.
They face charges of espionage, attempting to overthrow the government and support for a terror organisation, Hurriyet reported.
If convicted, they will receive an "aggravated life sentence", which includes tougher conditions and restricted leisure hours, the Dogan news agency reported.
Turkey has come under mounting criticism for its treatment of journalists.
Last week, US Vice-President Joe Biden called on Turkey to protect freedom of expression during a visit to the country and also met with Mr Dundar's wife in a show of support.
Press freedom 'a major concern'


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: "Maverick" is a word that seems to follow Craig Venter around.

this is part of a news article. represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

Examples:
Provided: "['Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence', 'Mrs Patten told the country how to make the most of its rations during World War Two and went on to front her first TV cookery show on the BBC in 1947.\nThe author, widely considered to be the first celebrity chef, wrote more than 170 books and had worldwide sales of more than 17 million.\nHer family said she died on 4 June "from an illness stoically borne".\nBorn Marguerite Brown, in Bath, she first learned to cook for her family, aged 13, after her father died and her mother had to return to work.\nShe worked as a home economist at the Eastern Electricity Board, as an actress in repertory theatre, and a promoter of the Frigidaire refrigerator brand.\nDuring World War Two, her cookery ideas were broadcast on the BBC radio programme Kitchen Front.\nShe was a regular contributor to BBC Radio 4\'s Woman\'s Hour programme from 1946 and made her final appearance in 2011.\nMrs Patten refused to describe herself as a celebrity chef, telling one interviewer: "I am not.\n"To the day I die, I will be a home economist."\nShe has had countless TV and radio shows and was awarded an OBE for services to the "art of cookery" in 1991 before becoming a CBE in 2010.\nMrs Patten, who had a stroke in 2011, continued to contribute to TV and radio food programmes into her 90s.\nWoman\'s Hour host Jane Garvey tweeted: Before everyone else there was Marguerite Patten. Really fond memories of @BBCWomansHour programme with her in 2009. RIP #cookerylegend\nFood critic and broadcaster Jay Rayner tweeted: Farewell Marguerite Patten, a long life well lived. I interviewed her a few times and she was always a delight.']" Match: "['This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article', 'Cookery writer and wartime broadcaster Marguerite Patten has died aged 99, her family has announced.']"

The biologist and entrepreneur turned the effort to map the human genome into a competitive race and, in so doing, was vilified by the scientific community.
Dr Venter has certainly not gained a reputation for modesty about his achievements. "Is my science of a level consistent with other people who have gotten the Nobel? Yes," he was once quoted as saying.
And he is a very wealthy user of Lear Jets and private yachts.
But his efforts in the field of human genomics have undeniably helped speed up the entire process.
After the publication of the human genome, Dr Venter turned his attention to another grand project: the creation of a synthetic life form.
Scientists at the US-based J Craig Venter Institute have been busily working on the endeavour for more than a decade. They have now published details of the result, an organism called Synthia, in the prestigious journal Science.
Born in 1946, as a boy, Dr Venter did not exemplify good scholarship and at 18 he chose to devote his life to the surfing pleasures of the beaches in Southern California. Three years later, in 1967, he was drafted into the Vietnam conflict.
As an orderly in the naval field hospital at Da Nang, he tended to thousands of soldiers wounded during the Tet offensive.
This inspired two important changes in him: a determination to become a doctor and a conviction that time should never be wasted.
"Life was so cheap in Vietnam. That is where my sense of urgency comes from," he said.
During his medical training he excelled in research rather than practice. By the 1980s, the early days of the revolution in molecular biology, he was working at the government-funded US National Institute of Health and soon realised the importance of decoding genes.
But the work was messy, tedious and agonisingly slow. So, in 1987, when he read reports of an automated decoding machine, he soon had the first one in his lab. This speeded things up - but not enough.
Then came Dr Venter's real breakthrough. He realised that he did not need to trawl the entire genome to find the active parts, because cells already use those parts naturally.
He switched his attention from the DNA blueprint to the messenger molecules (called RNA) that a cell makes from that blueprint. He was then able to churn out gene sequences at unprecedented rates.
His success shocked some, most notably the co-discoverer of DNA, James Watson, who famously dismissed the relatively crude results obtained as work "any monkey" could do.
The criticism, and the failure to secure further public research funding, prompted Dr Venter to leave the NIH in 1992 and set up a private research institute, The Institute for Genomic Research.
And, in 1995, he again stunned the scientific establishment by unveiling the first, complete genome of a free-living organism, Haemophilus influenzae, a major cause of childhood ear infections and meningitis.
His greatest challenge to the establishment came in May 1998, when he announced the formation of a commercial company, Celera Genomics, to crack the entire human genetic code in just three years. At that point, the public project was three years into a 10-year programme.
Both efforts published their results in 2001. What some saw as Dr Venter's disregard for scientific conventions such as open access to data brought him opprobrium in some circles.
Nevertheless, the financial rewards were enough to leave him in a highly unusual position for a scientist - with enough money and resources to do the science he wanted without having to tap the usual bureaucratic sources for funding and infrastructure.
In 2006, he formed the J Craig Venter Institute which would spearhead the labour to create the world's first synthetic life form. Dr Venter kept the scientific journals and the media abreast of developments, trumpeting several key advances as he edged closer to his goal.
But he has pursued other projects in the meantime. Dr Venter has roamed the oceans in his yacht, Sorcerer II, collecting life forms in an unprecedented genetic treasure hunt.
The project aims to sequence genomes from the vast range of microbes living in the sea, to provide scientists with a better understanding of the evolution and function of genes and proteins.
The synthetic life breakthrough, when it was announced, was not without controversy. But Dr Venter will have come to expect that.
"I think they're going to potentially create a new industrial revolution," he said of the synthetic microbes.
"If we can really get cells to do the production that we want, they could help wean us off oil and reverse some of the damage to the environment by capturing carbon dioxide."

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary

13 February 2016 Last updated at 07:51 GMT
He's so popular that he's been touring to promote a new book about him.
Tuna's owner tell us why she thinks people like him so much.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details.

Question: The UK has already placed its monetary policy in the hands of a Canadian, the Bank of England governor Mark Carney.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence:

Now it's going to fall to another Canadian to decide whether the British government's secrets should indeed remain secret.
She is Elizabeth Denham, who has recently taken up her new role as the UK's information commissioner, who oversees freedom of information (FOI) and data protection.
Previously she was the information commissioner in the Canadian province of British Columbia, where she was particularly noted for a hard-hitting investigation last year into a ministerial official deleting emails covered by an FOI request.
Ms Denham found that records had been wilfully destroyed, emails had not been properly preserved and FOI searches had been negligent.
She rejects the provincial government's criticism that the tone of her report was too harsh. "There was a poor record of government compliance," she says. "You can start off with audits and go as far as you can with more gentle methods, but when there's a serious allegation then it was important that the office took whatever means necessary."
In her first interview since becoming UK commissioner in July, Ms Denham told me about her plans for the FOI side of her new responsibilities.
She takes over from Christopher Graham, who succeeded in making internal processes at the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) more effective and tackling a huge backlog of complaints that was undermining the organisation's work.
However, some people who worked in Mr Graham's ICO expect Ms Denham to be more outspoken and aggressive in relations with government than he was.
Ms Denham particularly wants to improve the transparency of public services delivered by private companies, as more and more national and local state functions are outsourced. She says she will be raising this issue with ministers.
"Private contractors above a certain threshold for a contract or doing some specific types of work could be included under the FOI Act. The government could do more to include private bodies that are basically doing work on behalf of the public," she says.
The new commissioner also plans to review how her office tackles public authorities with a poor track record of handling FOI requests.
Currently those that fail to meet legal deadlines for at least 85% of applications may be subject to a period of special monitoring. She suggests that condition, which allows authorities to be late on 15% of requests, is not tough enough.
"I'm going to be looking at that threshold. Looking at this from the outside, most of the public would have the view that more than one in 10 not getting a timely response to a request is not a sign of success."
She will also face the challenge of those major public authorities that have demonstrated persistent failings, such as the Metropolitan Police and the Cabinet Office. "It is something on my radar. I would expect the Cabinet Office to be leaders in FOI."
Ms Denham proclaims her opposition to the government's suggestion that fees should be introduced for those who want to appeal against her office's decisions to the Information Rights Tribunal.
"Introducing new fees could potentially lead to a chill in requesters making use of the appeal process. From a high-level principle stance, I think having no charge for applicants is positive for the entire system."
One issue she pursued consistently in British Columbia was the "duty to document" - an obligation on public agencies to create records of all significant decisions. "If you've got FOI and you want it to work, the right records have to be created in the first place," she argues.
She's especially worried by the growing impact of technology: "What concerns me is that in a digital age when everybody walks around with their devices clutched to their chests or in their pockets, we all become our own records managers."
Ms Denham is unhappy about potential evasion of FOI via the use of private email. "People shouldn't be using private email accounts to conduct government business. If they do, legally it's subject to FOI - however, it frustrates the purposes of FOI from a search perspective."
Following pressure from her, the British Columbia government has enacted a "duty to document" law. So does she think the same change should be implemented in the UK?
"I think the principle is right. I need to understand more about the legal context in the UK to see where such a duty should rest."
The new commissioner is impressed by the UK government's leading international record in producing open data, but she rejects the argument that more proactive publication of information could make the FOI system more or less redundant.
"Government will pick the datasets that are easy to publish or non-controversial and get them out there. Sometimes we get to see shiny open-data projects, and that's great, but a lot of the information the public has a thirst for doesn't always come out. There's no replacement for the right to ask for the information that a citizen wants, and that means the right legislative regime and an independent overseer with teeth."
The main surprise in the seven weeks of her job so far has been the volume of FOI in the UK - both in terms of applications made to public authorities and also complaints to the ICO.
Earlier in her career she was an FOI officer for a regional health authority in Canada, and she is sympathetic to the challenges faced by staff who deal with the public's information requests.
"It's a very tough job to be the internal champion of freedom of information. Really those jobs need to report to a senior executive for it to work effectively, and they need to be given the tools and the resources to do the job."
Ms Denham has responded to one controversy that has already arisen by ordering a review of the involvement of her staff in political activities. This was prompted by the recent revelation by the information law blogger Tim Turner that an ICO manager running a team that handles complaints about councils and political parties is actually the Labour leader of Stockport Council.
Mr Turner argued that this meant Alex Ganotis, the team manager involved, who has authorised many ICO decisions, has an unacceptable conflict of interest.
Ms Denham stresses that she has no reason to think any previous decisions have been made improperly, but says: "It is important that we look at our policy on staff engagement in political activities and how the scope of their work is reflected. I do appreciate the importance of our decisions not only being independent and objective, but also being perceived as such."
Although there are naturally significant differences between information law in the UK and Canada, many broader issues (from digital technology to fostering a culture of openness) arise in both countries, and the institutional framework is similar.
"My mandate at the ICO is very much as it was in British Columbia," she says. "So it's about promoting access and privacy rights, educating the public, providing advice to public agencies, investigating complaints and making independent adjudications. Those are very much the same."
"I looked at the role as a combination of being a teacher, a counsellor, a police officer and a decision maker, all wrapped up in one agency."
At the time Elizabeth Denham was applying for the post, the UK's freedom of information law was being reviewed by a government-appointed commission. Contrary to widespread expectations that it would call for restrictions on FOI, the commission generally backed the law as it stands.
"I was concerned that it might lead to recommendations where individuals' FOI rights might be diminished," she says. "I didn't want to come into the UK in an environment where there were recommendations to dilute the very good law in place. I'm very, very pleased that report really was positive about how well FOI is working in the UK and that it was striking the right balance."
Now the future effect of freedom of information in the UK is very much up to her.

this is part of a news article. represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

E.g. ['represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence.', 'A 19-year-old man remains in custody after the death of Martin Maughan, 27, in West Walk, Sneinton, early on Saturday morning.\nBut the stabbing of a 38-year-old man in Mill View Close on Sunday morning is being treated as a separate incident.\nThe second victim has not been identified and no arrests have been made in connection with his death.\nA 43-year-old man arrested after the killing of Mr Maughan has been released on bail.\nChief Inspector Mark Stanley said extra patrols have been put in place in Sneinton to reassure residents.\n"(Crime) scenes have been established at both of the incidents to make sure all available evidence is secured and preserved.\n"The early indications are that these incidents are confined to people who are known to each other and who were at addresses they were invited to," Ch Insp Stanley said.\nThe second victim was holding a party celebrating the life of his friend when he was stabbed, the BBC has been told.'] == ['Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story', 'The fatal stabbings of two friends in Nottingham within 24 hours are "not believed to be linked", police said.']

Mrs May is "supportive" of him continuing in his role until 2021.
Pressure has been building on Mr Carney to clarify how long he intends to stay in the job.
Newspaper reports over the weekend suggested he was planning to leave in 2018. However, he is now thought to be leaning towards extending his tenure.
BBC economics editor Kamal Ahmed said: "All the people I've spoken to, close to Mark Carney, suggest he is more towards staying than leaving."
When Mr Carney became governor in June 2013 he committed to serving for five years. Since then he has made clear he is considering extending his stay, saying he would clarify at the end of this year whether he would stay for the full eight-year term that governors usually serve.
Some reports suggest he would like to stay to steer the UK through the challenges of Brexit. But he told a House of Lords committee last week that should he decide to go it would be an "entirely personal decision". Mr Carney has a wife and four daughters, who moved to London with him in 2013.
Speaking to reporters, Mrs May's spokeswoman said: "The PM has been clear in her support for the governor, the work he is doing for the country.
"It is clearly a decision for him, but the PM would certainly be supportive of him going on beyond his five years.
"The PM has always had a good working relationship with the governor of the Bank of England and intends to continue that."
Asked if Mrs May thought Mr Carney was "the right man for the job", the spokeswoman replied: "Absolutely."
It is thought Mr Carney might make an announcement on Thursday, when he holds a news conference following the publication of the Bank's Quarterly Inflation Report and the announcement of the result of its latest interest rate meeting.
Nothing I have heard over the last few weeks - and I have spoken to many people in Mr Carney's inner circle - suggests to me that the governor wants to leave in 2018.
To announce now that he will go in two years would see power immediately begin draining away.
The markets would also be left with a further layer of uncertainty to contend with.
And the voices of those politicians such as Jacob Rees-Mogg, a member of the Treasury Select Committee, and Lord Lawson, the former chancellor, who think the governor should resign immediately given his economic warnings before the referendum, would only become louder.
I think Mr Carney would also see it as a personal defeat.
The governor of the Bank of England, not staying to make Brexit a success, which he says it can be, but walking off the pitch at just the time the markets are calling for economic stability and certainty.
Read more from Kamal here
Over the weekend, the Bank of England reiterated that Mr Carney would make his decision public by the end of the year.
According to the Financial Times, one of the reasons Mr Carney wants to stay on is to defend the Bank of England's independence against attacks from pro-Brexit campaigners who have argued that the Bank produced deliberately gloomy economic forecasts to support the Remain campaign.
Conservative MEP, and prominent pro-Brexit campaigner, Daniel Hannan, has suggested he should leave his post.
"If he does stay, it's got to be on basis that he's not the rock star banker who presumes to tell Scotland whether to stay and Britain which way to vote, but rather sticks narrowly to his brief," Mr Hannan told BBC Radio 4's Today programme.
Many politicians have made it clear they would like Mr Carney to stay on, arguing that it would provide welcome continuity for business and the economy and may help counter any uncertainty caused by the Brexit negotiations.
Speaking to the BBC on Sunday, Business Secretary Greg Clark said: "I think Mark Carney has done a tremendous job, a fantastic job, during his tenure there. It is clearly a decision for him."
Mr Clark was financial secretary to the Treasury when Mr Carney was appointed by the then Chancellor, George Osborne, in November 2012.
"I think it was a brilliant appointment," Mr Clark said.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: Jeremy Corbyn has appeared to contradict a call by the Scottish Labour leader for a "new Act of Union" to "save the UK".

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence.

Kezia Dugdale made the suggestion last month as she outlined plans for a federal structure for the UK.
Mr Corbyn told BBC Scotland that, like Ms Dugdale, he wanted to set up a constitutional convention to look at arrangements across the country.
But the Labour leader added: "I would not use the words new Act of Union."
Mr Corbyn also said he did not believe a second referendum on Scottish independence was needed.
And he said he did not think devolving immigration controls to Holyrood would be possible, despite calls from a cross-party group of MPs and the Scottish government.
Speaking at an event in London in December, Ms Dugdale said a new Act of Union was needed to "save the UK for generations to come".
She called for a People's Constitutional Convention, modelled on the one set up in Scotland ahead of the creation of the Scottish Parliament, to "re-establish the UK for a new age".
Ms Dugdale added that the convention should be tasked with producing a "new Act of Union which would reaffirm the partnership between our nations and renew it for the future".
Her deputy Alex Rowley has also called for Scottish Labour - which was recently given new powers to set its own policies - to campaign for "home rule within a confederal United Kingdom".
Mr Corbyn said he wanted to look at the constitutional relationship across the UK, but said he "wouldn't use the words new Act of Union".
He added: "What we will be doing is looking at a new constitutional convention for the whole of the UK because there are issues of lack of democracy in parts of our political structure, such as the unelected House of Lords.
"There is a huge issue about regional government across England, and there is a need to have a discussion about the relative powers in Scotland, in Wales and in Northern Ireland of devolved assemblies."
Responding to Mr Corbyn, a spokesman for Scottish Labour said: "Kezia Dugdale has proposed a new Act of Union, to strengthen our union across the whole of the UK for generations to come.
"Being part of the UK protects jobs and the money we need to invest in our public services."
Scottish Conservative leader Ruth Davidson said: "I never thought I'd find myself agreeing with Jeremy Corbyn.
"But he's quite right to reject the idea of a new act of union; it's clearly little more than a Scottish Labour gimmick, from a party all at sea on the constitution."
The SNP's Ivan McKee MSP said: "This is a complete and utter embarrassment for Scottish Labour, with their position on the constitution fatally undermined by Jeremy Corbyn.
"Just last week Kezia Dugdale claimed that her London leader was backing her all the way, and that he supported her plan 'unequivocally'. But it's now clear that nothing could be further from the truth."
When asked about his views on an independence referendum, Mr Corbyn said "the agreement has been that a second one could be held" if it was wanted by the Scottish Parliament.
But he said it was "much more important" to address the economic issues facing the whole of the UK, as well as the Brexit negotiations with the EU.
He added: "I don't see the need for one, I'm not asking for one, I don't think she (Nicola Sturgeon) should call one."
On suggestions that Scotland and other areas of the UK could have their own immigration policy after Brexit, Mr Corbyn said this would be "very difficult" to implement as it would need "regional borders".
He said: "I have heard the argument in England as well, and in the case of Scotland I would say exactly the same - it has to be a UK-wide decision.
"Clearly Scotland, like other parts of the UK, does benefit from EU workers that come. It does benefit from their skills, and indeed people from Scotland do go to live and work in other parts of Europe. That is actually a good thing."

The Scottish Labour leader outlined her plan for a "federal solution" for the UK in a speech to the Institute for Public Policy Research in London.
It would see extra powers for English regions as well as Holyrood via a "People's Convention" for the UK.
The SNP said Labour had been promising "federalism max" for years but had "consistently failed" to deliver.
Ms Dugdale tasked former UK justice secretary Lord Falconer with exploring a federalist approach following the UK's vote to leave the EU in June.
Her deputy Alex Rowley has called for Scotland to "move beyond narrow unionism and nationalism" and wants Scottish Labour to campaign for "home rule within a confederal United Kingdom".
Ms Dugdale has now set out her own position, saying she is "not embarrassed" to have fought for the UK in the 2014 referendum.
She said: "We are now faced with a Tory government in Westminster which looks set to force hard Brexit on the whole of the UK. And an SNP government at Holyrood which wants to exploit the divisions to win independence.
"This is the position that the majority of Scots - the moderate, pro-union Scots and also many former Yes voters - find themselves in.
"More than ever, we have two governing parties in Scotland that are out of step with what the majority of people in Scotland want. The Tories want Scotland in the UK and out of Europe, and the SNP want Scotland in the EU, but out of the UK.
"Continuing to pull our country in each of these directions risks breaking the union once and for all."
Ms Dugdale pointed out that the 1707 Act of Union still underpins the relationship between Scotland and the rest of the UK, arguing that there should be a new act "for this new century".
She said: "The time has come for the rest of the UK to follow where Scotland led in the 1980s and 1990s and establish a People's Constitutional Convention to re-establish the UK for a new age.
"The convention should bring together groups to deliberate on the future of our country and propose a way forward that strengthens the UK and establishes a new political settlement for the whole of our country.
"Some may say this is unrealistic, but it would follow the model of the Scottish Constitutional Convention which, without government support, established the basis for the settlement that delivered a Scottish Parliament in 1999.
"It would also - for the first time - provide a coherent approach to answering the question of how our country is best governed.
"I would not want the convention to just deliberate and report, but to produce a new Act of Union which would reaffirm the partnership between our nations and renew it for the future. After more than 300 years, it is time for a new Act of Union to safeguard our family of nations for generations to come."
SNP MSP Linda Fabiani, who sat on the Smith Commission on further powers for Scotland, said Labour were "singing the same old song".
She said: "Labour have been promising a supercharged, powerhouse, federalism-max for years - and consistently failing to deliver it.
"In fact it was Labour politicians that specifically blocked the powers over the minimum wage they are now asking for. This is just the latest version of the same old song.
"Billions of years from now I half expect Labour politicians to be staring into the dying sun calling for a constitutional convention."
Senior Scottish Tory MSP Murdo Fraser has spoken in favour of a federal UK with a written constitution.
However his party backs the current constitutional settlement, with party chief whip John Lamont accusing Labour of targeting "even more constitutional upheaval".
He added: "Surely 10 years of SNP government obsessing over the constitution has taught us that this is the wrong priority.
"Like everything we see with Labour right now, it is a complete mess. It is little wonder that nobody has a clue what they stand for."
Green co-convener Patrick Harvie said Labour was using "valuable time to discuss changes in the UK constitution which seem vanishingly unlikely to happen, instead of the very real and urgent threat posed by Brexit".
The Liberal Democrats are long-standing supporters of federalism, with Scottish leader Willie Rennie saying it was "good to see momentum building for this" after Ms Dugdale's speech.
He added: "Federalism is Scotland's and the United Kingdom's best chance to flourish."


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: A girl who was kept in a cellar and repeatedly raped was the victim of a "shaming failing" by those who should have protected her, a report has said.

An independent review published by Salford Safeguarding Board said it was "difficult to think of a more vulnerable child".
The girl, who is deaf and cannot speak, was trafficked from Pakistan aged ten.
Her plight was only detected when she was found by trading standards' officers investigating a scam.
Ilyas Ashar was jailed for raping the girl, benefits fraud and trafficking, and his wife Tallat was jailed for benefits fraud and trafficking.
The pair succeeded in "in maintaining a cruel deception," the report notes.
The 76-page report said none of the various agencies protected the girl, who worked as a servant, when they came into contact with her.
It stated: "For a country with a reputation as a safe place in which human rights are upheld and with sophisticated arrangements for safeguarding children and vulnerable adults, this was indeed a shaming failing."
It highlighted key failures by official agencies:
It said there was a series of missed opportunities by different authorities.
The girl arrived from Pakistan on a forged passport which put her at twice her actual age.
She never had an interpreter when she was seen by different officials.
The girl had an employment contract with the couple ensuring she would neither have sex nor be locked indoors against her will, which could "have suggested she was vulnerable", said the report.
NHS staff were "too inhibited" about race issues to question the family.
The couple were originally sentenced at Manchester Crown Court in October 2013, but had their sentences increased in February last year, with Ilyas Ashar's extended from 13 years to 15 and Tallat Ashar's sentence raised from five to six years.
Social services said the girl, now in her 20s, had made a "remarkable recovery".

represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary:

The pair, then 10 and 11, were sentenced to an indeterminate period in custody with a minimum of five years following the attacks in the Doncaster village of Edlington.
The victims were nine and 11 years old.
A court order at the time granted the brothers anonymity until both are 18.
The application will be heard at the High Court in London on Thursday.
As the younger of the two brothers approaches his 18th birthday, lawyers acting for the pair are seeking an injunction to extend their anonymity indefinitely.
The brothers have appealed to remain anonymous in adulthood claiming that to identify them would breach various sections of the Human Rights Act.
In April 2009, the victims were lured away from a park to a secluded spot by the brothers who promised to show them a toad.
They were subjected to a 90-minute assault of violence and sexual humiliation which drew comparisons with the murder of two-year-old James Bulger in 1993.
The victims were throttled, hit with bricks, made to eat nettles, stripped and forced to sexually abuse each other.
The older boy had a sink dropped on his head, while the younger boy had a sharp stick rammed into his arm and cigarettes pushed into the wound.
Parts of the attack were recorded on a mobile phone.
The Daily Mail has reported the brothers have now both been released and given new names.
When they were sentenced, Judge Justice Keith at Sheffield Crown Court said they had committed the "prolonged, sadistic" crimes for no other reason than they got "a real kick out of hurting and humiliating" their victims.
The brothers had moved to Edlington just three weeks before the attack to live with foster parents.
Their victims were led to a "den" hidden from public view, where some of their injuries were inflicted, then another site beneath a ravine where an old sink was used to inflict serious head injuries on the 11-year-old.
Following the attack, the nine-year-old staggered covered in blood to a nearby house to raise the alarm.
The 11-year-old was later discovered unconscious in the nearby wood.
In 2012, a probe by Doncaster Safeguarding Children Board into the attack was branded a failure by then education secretary Michael Gove.
Nine agencies involved with the family missed 31 opportunities to intervene and the assault was said to be not only predictable, but entirely preventable.
Doncaster Council took disciplinary action against five members of staff and one former employee and offered "an unqualified apology" for the failings.
The judge heard the boys had a "toxic home life" of "routine aggression, violence and chaos".
One watched gory Saw movies and was familiar with Chucky films and pornography DVDs.
He smoked cannabis from the age of nine and drank cider.
At sentencing, the victims' parents and the Sheffield Star newspaper asked the judge to allow them to be identified.
This move was opposed by the defendants, the secure units in which they were being held, the police and Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council - and the judge refused to lift the reporting restriction.
He said: "The case has been regarded as raising important issues about the way children from dysfunctional families can go off the rails and about the lack of intervention at critical stages by the local authority social services department and other child protection agencies."
But he said that allowing identification could lead to problems for the brothers, their secure units and the brothers' family.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: At least 20 workers accused of working on an army-backed dam construction site in the south-western Pakistani province of Balochistan have been shot dead by a large group of gunmen, officials say.

Police say that the gunmen overpowered eight security guards, and shot the labourers on Friday night.
A separatist group said it was responsible for the attack.
Taliban militants, Baloch separatists and other groups fight in the Balochistan region, which borders Iran.
The separatist Balochistan Liberation Front said it carried out the attack. A spokesperson told the BBC that the target was the Pakistani army and those working for its construction projects in the province.
Police told Pakistani media that the attack appears to have been an act of targeted killing - all the dead were from outside Balochistan. The attackers fled on motorcycles. At least three labourers were wounded.
The attack took place near the south-western town of Turbat, police say, which is considered to be one of the restive areas of Balochistan. It is also the home town of the chief minister.
Senior Balochistan official Akbar Hussain Durran told the AFP news agency that the labourers were lined up and shot at point blank range after identifying themselves.
He said that paramilitary troops guarding the labourers fled when confronted by such a large number of armed attackers.
The Pakistani security forces are often targeted by separatists who accuse them of persecuting Baloch nationalists. Rights groups have also accused government forces of arbitrary killings, torture and enforced disappearances.
The army argues that it is fighting to keep Pakistan together.
Both the military and the insurgents - who want a greater share of revenue from the province's substantial gas and mineral resources as well as more autonomy - deny human right abuses.
Balochistan Home Minister Sarfaraz Bugti said that paramilitary Frontier Corps troops were searching in the nearby mountains for the attackers.
"We will chase them down and bring them to justice," Mr Bugti said. "We need help in this war against terrorists. Alone, we cannot fight."

represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

Examples:
Provided: "['represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary', "Storms in the Andes over the weekend had flooded the Maipo river, contaminating it with mud and rubble.\nBusinesses and schools had to remain closed and four million people were without drinking water.\nThe water company said it would take time to refill 15,000km (9,320 miles) of pipes.\nOfficials had said the water supply from the Maipo river had to be cut until the water flowed clear.\nAt least three people have been killed and 19 are missing as rivers overflowed and bridges were washed away.\nA 12-year-old girl was killed when the car she was travelling in with her family was swept away by a landslide in the O'Higgins region, south of Santiago.\nTwo more people died in Cajon del Maipo.\nMore than 60% of households in Santiago woke up on Sunday to find their taps running dry.\nMany queued to fill buckets and pans with water provided by the authorities.\nSome shops ran out of bottled water and some supermarkets reported scuffles between people eager to stock up.\nRestaurants and businesses in the affected areas were ordered to stay closed and schools were also told to delay the start of the school year, scheduled for Monday.\nThe flooding follows months of drought and a series of deadly wildfires which burned for weeks."]" Match: "['Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details', "Water supplies have been restored in most of Chile's capital Santiago after floods contaminated a major river providing most of the city's water."]"

The gunmen let the men off with a warning not to hunt in the area, after firing bullets into their vehicle, officials said.
No one was injured in Monday's attack near Panjgur town, which a separatist group said it carried out.
Hundreds protested in Balochistan on Tuesday against Arab hunting parties, which travel to Pakistan every year.
Farmers say the hunts endanger the birds and damage crops.
Pakistan issues dozens of permits every winter to the royal families of the Middle East to hunt rare Houbara bustards in its southern plains.
The princes and their wealthy friends consider the bird's meat to be an aphrodisiac.
The Supreme Court lifted a ban on hunting the birds earlier this year, after the government argued it helped build diplomatic relationships with Arab dignitaries.
The shooting incident happened in the remote hilly tracts in Gichk area, some 90km (55 miles) south of Panjgur.
A local paramilitary official told the BBC the hunters led by Abu Dhabi's Prince Saif bin Zayd al-Nahyan had been in a convoy of about 30 sports utility vehicles.
In the early evening one of the vehicles had gone to check for nesting bustards at a spot about 5km away.
"Some men on motorbikes caught up with them, stopped the vehicle, asked the Arabs to get off, and then fired gunshots into the vehicle, shattering its windows and flattening its tyres," the official said.
Another local official said the hunters' vehicle had later been towed under escort to a nearby paramilitary Frontier Corps camp.
The Balochistan Liberation Front (BLF) said it carried out the attack.
"Our fighters let the sheikhs go unharmed in view of our ancient mutual links and values and in the hope that in future they won't obtain lease of any area of Balochistan for hunting from the occupying country, Pakistan," a statement said.
Last month the BLF warned Arab hunters not to move in the area with a Pakistani security escort.
The group claims to have carried out two similar warning attacks in Turbat region, south of Panjgur, this season, but there has been no independent confirmation of this.
In February 2013, at least two Frontier Corps personnel were injured when a hunting party of Arabs was shot in the Turbat area. The attack was claimed by the BLF.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details!

Question: Newport Gwent Dragons will start their defence of the Singha Premiership Rugby 7s in Cardiff on Friday.

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary

They face Cardiff Blues, Ospreys and Scarlets in a round-robin event with the top two teams going forward to the finals in Coventry on Sunday, 7 August.
The other finalists will come from three groups involving the 12 English Premiership clubs.
"The Singha 7s has been an incredible success for the Dragons," said coach Nick Wakely.
Welsh regions have been included in the tournament since 2014, with the Dragons losing finalists in 2014 before beating Wasps to clinch the title in 2015.
Wakely, who coached the winners last season, says the event has been a valuable stepping stone for developing players.
"Angus O'Brien and Ashton Hewitt, Harrison Keddie have kicked on and hopefully will get more exposure this year," he added.
Keddie - who scored the winning try against Wasps in the 2015 final - is again included in a youthful Dragons squad.
Ospreys include Wales sevens specialist Morgan Williams and 15-a-side internationals Dafydd Howells and Jonathan Spratt in a squad which is coached by Tom Smith and Richard Fussell.
Scarlets include a number of Welsh Premiership club players and will be led by Carmarthen Quins' Iolo Evans and coached by Dai Flanagan.
Sevens specialists Evans, Jake Conway, Matthew Owen, Aron Evans, Shaun Pearce, Aaron Warren and Rhodri Jones all featured in last year's finals day at Twickenham.
Hosts Cardiff Blues include Wales seven internationals Adam Thomas, Ben Roach and Owen Jenkins in their squad.
They have also selected Wales Under-18 international James Botham - the grandson of England cricket legend Sir Ian Botham.
"We are lucky to have Adam Thomas, Owen Jenkins and Ben Roach, who are Cardiff Blues boys and have experience on the sevens stage,"  said elite performance pathway manager Richard Hodges.
"We've recruited them to be the real leaders in the group.
"Then we can expose our tier two academy, guys just out of the under-18s like Dane Blacker, Ben Jones, Callum Bradbury and Jimmy Botham."
Newport Gwent Dragons: Ross Wardle, Darran Harris, Harrison Keddie, Aled Brew, Ethan Davies, James Benjamin, Geraint Rhys Jones (capt), Elliot Frewen, Jonny Lewis, Arwel Robson, Chris Levesley, Luc Jones.
Ospreys: Joseph Scrivens, Steff Andrews, Will Jones, Dafydd Howells, James Ratti, Tom O'Flaherty, Morgan Williams, David Evans, Joe Gage, Phil Jones, Jay Baker, Jonathan Spratt (Capt).
Scarlets: Iolo Evans, Matthew Owen, Jake Conway, Shaun Pearce, Rhodri Davies, Ashley Evans, Aron Evans, Dion Jones, Rhodri Jones, Nathan Edwards, Scott Gibson, Aaron Warren.
Cardiff Blues: Adam Thomas, Ben Roach, James Botham, Luke Crocker, Joe Tomlinson, Ben Jones, Owen Jenkins, James Beale, Dane Blacker, Geraint Walsh, Ben Thomas, Declan Williams.
Fixtures (Friday, 22 July; all times BST): 19:00: Cardiff Blues v Scarlets. 19:25: Ospreys v Newport Gwent Dragons. 19:55: Ospreys v Scarlets. 20:20: Cardiff Blues v Newport Gwent Dragons. 20:50: Scarlets v Newport Gwent Dragons. 21:15: Cardiff Blues v Ospreys.

this is part of a news article. represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article.

The 36-year-old former Sale and Saracens fly-half, capped 38 times by England, will work under Exiles director of rugby Nick Kennedy.
Hodgson amassed 2,623 points in his Premiership career before making his final appearance in May 2016.
England women and former London Welsh assistant coach Matthew Ferguson also joins the club as scrum coach.
Irish, promoted back to the Premiership in May, begin their season against Harlequins at Twickenham in the London Double Header on Saturday, 2 September.


Question:
represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details
------
Examples:
'['Represent the natural language.', 'Donald Trump and House Speaker Paul Ryan have said they are "totally committed" to party unity in a statement following their meeting.']' == '['Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence', 'The two are trying to find common ground after Mr Ryan said he could not endorse the presumptive Republican nominee.\nHe has said the businessman lacked conservative principles.\n"We had a great conversation this morning," the two wrote in a joint statement.\n"While we were honest about our few differences, we recognise that there are also many important areas of common ground."\nThey said they would be having "additional discussions" but think they can unify the party and win the election.\nAt a press conference following the meeting, Mr Ryan said he was "very encouraged" by what he heard from Mr Trump.\nTrump v Paul Ryan - the split explained\nHow Trump captures the White House\nTrump softens stance on Muslim ban\nMr Trump arrived for the meeting at the Republican National Committee (RNC) headquarters in Washington amid protesters brandishing placards.\nPaul Ryan sounds like a man trying to make peace with his shotgun marriage. Sure, the circumstances are unfortunate, but maybe life together won\'t be that bad.\nThe House speaker, who once condemned Trump\'s proposed Muslim ban as "not conservatism", now says there are "core principles" of conservatism that tie them together. They both love the Constitution, it seems, and they\'re all about the separation of powers between the branches of government.\nBeyond that? Who knows. Mr Ryan declined to go into details during his Thursday press conference, instead talking about the processes being started, seeds being planted and differences being bridged.\nIt was not the endorsement, full-throated or otherwise, that Mr Trump desires, but it was a first step toward the reconciliation of a party that desperately wants to win back the White House in November.\nIf Mr Ryan eventually makes peace with what he called a "whole new wing" of the Republican Party that Mr Trump represents, this desire for power - for a prize that has been denied Republicans for two straight presidential elections - will be the driving force behind it.\nAfterwards, RNC chairman Reince Priebus, who mediated the talks in his office, said it was a success.\nIn December 2015, Mr Ryan harshly criticised Mr Trump\'s proposal to ban Muslims from entering the US.\nHe said it was "not what this party stands for and more importantly it\'s not what this country stands for".\nBut on Wednesday, Mr Trump appeared to soften, saying it was "just a suggestion".\nMr Ryan, who ran as 2012 Republican presidential nominee Mitt Romney\'s vice president, clashes with Mr Trump on many issues, including religious freedom and trade.\nHe has remained popular on Capitol Hill, after being urged to take over as Speaker of the House of Representatives in the autumn.\nMany who view him as a more electable figure than Mr Trump have urged him - in vain - to run for president.\nBut more Republicans are throwing their support behind Mr Trump, including Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell.\nThe New Yorker is one of the least politically experienced nominees in US history, having never held elected office.\nThat outsider status has appealed to voters who feel let down by Washington.\nA recent Gallup Poll shows that two in three Republican-leaning voters view Mr Trump favourably.\nBut protests have plagued his campaign, with particular focus on his plan to build a wall on the Mexican border and deport 11 million undocumented immigrants.\nSupporting:\nNot supporting:\nYet to comment:']' != '['Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence', 'The Republican president blamed Mitch McConnell for failing to pass measures on the US debt limit and healthcare.\nIt came a day after Mr McConnell, the Senate majority leader, played down reports of a rift.\nConservatives fear any tensions could imperil a big-ticket item in the Republican in-tray: tax reform.\nThe party\'s ability to govern is under scrutiny after a patchy legislative record this year despite its control of the White House, Senate and House of Representatives.\nEnd of Twitter post  by @realDonaldTrump\nEnd of Twitter post 2 by @realDonaldTrump\nIn Thursday morning\'s tweets, Mr Trump claimed that Mr McConnell and House Speaker Paul Ryan had failed to heed his advice to insert a debt ceiling measure into a veterans\' bill which the president signed into law this week.\n"Could have been so easy-now a mess!" he said.\nMinutes later, Mr Trump targeted the Senate leader again, faulting him for last month\'s failure to overturn Obamacare.\n"The only problem I have with Mitch McConnell is that, after hearing Repeal & Replace for 7 years, he failed! That should NEVER have happened!"\nJerry, I\'ll call him that, is a mild-mannered African American in his early 70s from West Virginia.\nHe grew up under segregation and it was to his family\'s deep dismay that he voted for Mr Trump last year.\nHe believes Mr Trump understands that America needs more discipline: no more young men walking round with their jeans halfway down their butts showing off their boxers, was how he described it to me.\nJerry hankers for a time when young men dressed well, behaved well and didn\'t answer back to their elders.\nWhen I asked him if he\'d be disappointed if Mr Trump failed to live up to his campaign promises of healthcare reform, tax reform and making American manufacturing great again, Jerry was clear.\nMr Trump, he said, would probably never achieve any of those things for three reasons - the media, the Russia investigation and the Republican Party.\nRead Katty\'s take\nMr McConnell, who was addressing a group of Kentucky farmers on Thursday, offered muted criticism of Mr Trump.\nHe said he was "a little concerned about some of the trade rhetoric" by the president.\nThe Senate leader added: "The assumption that every free trade agreement is a loser for America is largely untrue."\nA fiscal crisis is looming if Congress does not raise the US debt limit by the end of September.\nAt the same time, a separate budget battle is expected to unfold as lawmakers attempt to pass a massive government spending bill.\nMr Trump\'s latest tweets came a day after he issued a plea for unity and healing during a speech in Nevada.\nThe New York Times reported this week that Mr McConnell had doubts about Mr Trump\'s ability to save his presidency.\nOn 9 August, the two men engaged in a "profane shouting match" during a phone call, the newspaper also reported.\nMr McConnell and Mr Trump went into damage-limitation mode on Wednesday, playing down the claims.\nThe Kentucky senator said in a statement he and President Trump were "committed to advancing our shared agenda together".\nThe White House said the two would "remain united".\nMr McConnell riled Mr Trump earlier this month when he said the president had "excessive expectations about how quickly things happen in the democratic process".\nMr Trump told a crowd in Phoenix, Arizona, on Tuesday he would shut down the government if Congress does not grant the funding to build a wall on the US-Mexico border.\nBut eight votes from Democrats, who oppose a new border wall, are required for the debt ceiling bill to pass.']'

Question: Gareth Bale has played down the significance of his duel with Real Madrid team-mate Cristiano Ronaldo ahead of Wales' Euro 2016 semi-final against Portugal.

Media playback is not supported on this device
Their relationship has been the subject of intense media scrutiny, with both insisting there is no rift.
They meet in Lyon on Wednesday, Wales' first semi-final at a major tournament.
"It's not about two players, it is about two nations in a semi-final, 11 men against 11 men," said Wales' Bale.
"Everybody knows that really."
Bale became the world's most expensive footballer when he joined Real from Tottenham for £85m in 2013, surpassing the £80m the Spanish club paid Manchester United for Ronaldo in 2009.
The two players have formed a potent attacking three with French striker Karim Benzema, helping Real to win two Champions League titles in the past three seasons.
However, the relationship between Bale and Ronaldo has not always been harmonious.
The Portugal captain was pictured gesticulating angrily when Bale did not pass to him during a game in 2015, prompting speculation of discord between the pair.
Both have dismissed such talk, while former Real manager Carlo Ancelotti said in a recent BBC Wales documentary about Bale that the two players are "really close".
"Of course we get on very well at Madrid, we enjoy playing with each other," said Bale.
"He's a fantastic player, everybody knows what he can do. But we have always spoken about what we do, what we do ourselves as a team. We don't worry about the opposition."
Wednesday's match in Lyon will be Ronaldo's third European Championship semi-final, and he was part of the Portugal side which lost the 2004 final to Greece.
Bale's three goals have helped Wales reach the last four of a major tournament for the first time, and he has reiterated his belief that Chris Coleman's men could be crowned champions.
"We all believed from the start. As we have said many times, we didn't come here to make up the numbers," he added.
"We came here to do a job, we came to do the business. Ultimately we want to win the tournament.
"We know we're a step closer again but, the thing we keep saying time and time again, we can't think past the semi-final now.
"We have to concentrate everything on the semi. If we can get the job done, then we can look forward to the final."
With Wales making their first appearance at a major tournament since the 1958 World Cup, Bale is glad he no longer has to endure taunts from his Real team-mates.
"I remember [Germany midfielder] Toni Kroos saying we'd only have three games. So it would be nice to meet him in the final," he said.
"It was a good laugh and a joke - a bit of banter. I have had a lot of abuse over the years, when we used to lose and when we were 100th in the world. You have nine weeks' holiday instead of two.
"It is good to finally be in a major tournament actually doing great things with our national team. It is great to be part of and we have loved every moment of it and we will continue to do that."
While Kroos may await in the final if Wales make it, Bale can look forward to facing Real centre-back Pepe - if fit - as well as Ronaldo in Wednesday's semi-final against Portugal.
The Wales forward has also brought his Real physiotherapist, Jaime Benito, with him to France to work alongside the international backroom staff.
"I had a few injuries this year and coming to a big tournament I haven't experienced it before so I wanted to make sure I was fully fit and if there was a problem I can get it fixed straight away," Bale added.
"It's been a massive help for me and even the medical staff here have probably needed it more because they didn't want to take any of the others out for so long and leave any of the other boys without treatment. It was a good decision all round and it's working well."
________________________________________

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

The West Ham United defender injured his hamstring in their 1-0 Premier League win over Tottenham on Wednesday.
"The first information is that we should be happy if he only misses three games," said Hammers manager Slaven Bilic.
Wales play Northern Ireland at the Cardiff City Stadium on 24 March, and Ukraine in Kiev four days later.
Chris Coleman's Wales team are already likely to be without Real Madrid forward Gareth Bale, who is poised to return to action this weekend after a six-week lay-off with a calf injury.
Bale has not played since injuring his calf in Real Madrid's 5-1 win against Sporting Gijon on 17 January.
Wolves midfielder Dave Edwards says it will be difficult for him to secure a place in Wales' Euro 2016 squad following his foot injury.
The March warm-up games are seen as key fixtures as Wales prepare for the Euro 2016 finals in France.
Collins will miss West Ham's Premier League games against Everton and Chelsea, and the FA Cup quarter-final against Manchester United at Old Trafford this month.


Question:
this is the first sentence of a news article. represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

E.g.
['Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details', 'The Ghana Football Association (GFA) says it has parted company with national team coach Kwesi Appiah by mutual consent.'] == ['This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article', "Former coach Milovan Rajevac is being widely tipped to return to the post he held between 2008 and 2010.\nRajevac had originally been lined up to work as a technical advisor alongside Appiah.\nThe GFA says it will announce Appiah's replacement before October's Africa Cup of Nations qualifier against Guinea.\nDuring his first stint in charge, Rajevac led Ghana to the runners-up spot at the 2010 Africa Cup of Nations and the quarter-finals of the World Cup a few months later.\nAppiah had been under pressure since Ghana's turbulent World Cup campaign, where they failed to win a single match against a backdrop of off-field issues.\nA draw at home to Uganda in their opening Group E match in the 2015 Nations Cup qualifiers increased the calls for Appiah to move on.\nEven a 3-2 win away from home over Togo on Wednesday was not enough to save Appiah's job.\nAppiah and the GFA will meet next week to discuss the terms of his severance package."] != ['represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence', 'The bus carrying players and officials of the Ghana Premier League team was returning to its base in Kumasi after a game against Inter Allies in Accra.\nThe incident took place in the southern town of Nkawkaw, where the bus is said to have hit a stationary truck.\nThe team\'s deputy equipment officer Kofi Asare has been confirmed dead.\n"Management has been in shock and grief following Wednesday\'s unfortunate accident involving our team bus," Kotoko said in a statement on Thursday.\n"We regret to announce that Kofi Asare could not make it."\n"Meanwhile, head coach Steven Polack, midfielder Ollennu Ashitey and bus driver Nana Berkye are receiving treatment."\nThe statement added that players and officials who had sustained minor injuries have been treated and discharged, with a follow-up examination scheduled for Saturday.\nReports suggest there were around 35 people on board - nine of whom have already been treated and discharged from the hospital in Nkawkaw.\nIn a statement, the Ghanaian FA said it was \'devastated\' by the news.\n"Our thoughts and prayers are with Kumasi Asante Kotoko, particularly the injured officials and players, who are currently receiving treatment in Nkawkaw," it added.\nKotoko\'s league game against Accra Hearts of Oak, which was scheduled for Sunday, has been indefinitely postponed.\nAsante Kotoko is a famous football club based in Kumasi, Ghana\'s second-largest city.\nThe news has been met with an outpouring of grief on social media, says the BBC\'s Thomas Naadi in Accra.\nGhana\'s President Nana Akufo-Addo says he\'s saddened by the incident and has wished the injured a speedy recovery.\nAsante Kotoko had lost to Inter Allies, so ending a 10-game run without a defeat to leave the two-time African champions fourth in the league.']

Question: An extreme adventurer who became the first person to run, swim and cycle the length of the UK has completed the journey a fourth time - by boat.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence!

Sean Conway, from Cheltenham, completed the "ultimate triathlon" between Land's End and John O'Groats in May.
And just before 21:00 GMT on Monday, he crossed the finish line again - in a racing yacht.
It is thought Mr Conway is the first person to complete the trek using the four different methods.
He was part of a three-man crew, with skipper Phil Sharp from Jersey and boat owner Alex Alley.
They completed the journey in just under three-and-a-half days.
The trio left Land's End in their Class 40 racing yacht at 08:55 GMT on Friday and arrived in the north of Scotland - 620 nautical miles (1,150 km) way - 83 hours and 53 minutes later.
Mr Conway said it was "amazing" to have completed the challenge.
"This was a very different experience to my previous adventures because they took weeks and months to do.
"I didn't get a lot of sleep and we were battered at sea. It was a lot harder than I thought it would be.
"I think this is it now. I think I'm done with Land's End to John O'Groats.
"No doubt I'll row it or do it on a pogo stick at some point, but for now I'm happy with my four records."
Mr Sharp said: "We are tired but feel quite ecstatic to have finished.
"It was a bit hairy towards the finish... with strong tides and big overfalls in the dark.
"Overall having done it, I think this a good course, and we have now set a benchmark which we think others will go out and challenge."

represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

Roddy Riddle, who is from Inverness and has Type 1 diabetes, completed the 350 miles of the 6633 Ultra in just under seven days.
The event, held this year in Canada, is described as one of the world's coldest and toughest foot races.
To finish the race, competitors must complete the route in eight days or less.
In a post on Facebook, Riddle, who finished in second place, said: "350 brutal miles across the Arctic and I'm the first Scot to have ever finished the race."
He added: "But the most important thing is raising awareness for what can be achieved with Type 1 diabetes and to show it shouldn't stop you achieving your goals in life."
Riddle completed a marathon in the Sahara Desert in 2013.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Cheltenham Gold Cup winner Don Cossack will miss the Punchestown Festival in Ireland with a tendon injury.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

The horse, trained by Gordon Elliott, was set for a keenly-awaited rematch with Cue Card in the Punchestown Gold Cup on Wednesday.
Cue Card, who fell three fences from the finish in last month's Gold Cup, is now favourite for the title in Ireland.
Cheltenham World Hurdle winner Thistlecrack has been ruled out of the Champion Stayers Hurdle with lameness.
Thistlecrack, like Cue Card is trained by Colin Tizzard.

The Nicky Henderson-trained gelding's win added to his victories at the Cheltenham and Aintree festivals.
Sprinter Sacre's winning margin of just over five lengths was reduced from the 19 lengths in the Queen Mother Chase.
But it was still a comfortable win for the 1/9 odds-on favourite.
The seven-year old, who won the Queen Mother Champion Chase at the Cheltenham Festival before landing Aintree's Melling Chase, was clinching a 10th consecutive win over fences.
Sprinter Sacre has been described by jockey Barry Geraghty as jump racing's Pele as he performs with apparent effortless ease.
Sizing Europe, the distant runner-up in Cheltenham's Champion Chase, made a brave bid by taking out the pace before being overhauled at the final fence.
Henderson described his star performer's victory as "job done".
"He was at his best at Cheltenham, he wasn't quite as sharp at Aintree and wasn't as sharp today," added the trainer.
"To do all three (Cheltenham, Aintree and Punchestown) is very, very hard and he's had to work harder today than he has in the past.
Foaled: 23/4/2006
Sex: Bay/Brown Gelding
Runs: 16
1st: 14
2nd: 1
3rd: 1
"He didn't do anything wrong. He was clean and confident and fair play to Sizing Europe, who ran a hell of a race."
The two-mile feature race was the highlight on the first day of a meeting that will attract a total of about 100,000 racegoers.
The opening day of the meeting also saw Jessica Harrington's star youngster Jezki beating the Willie Mullins-trained Champagne Fever in the Champion Novice Hurdle and avenging his Cheltenham defeat.
Champagne Fever had won the Supreme Novices' Hurdle at Chelthenham, when Jezki only managed third.
However, on this occasion Barry Geraghty guided Harrington's horse to an emphatic 16-length victory with  County Hurdle winner Ted Veale beating Champagne Fever to the runner-up spot.
In Tuesday's other Grade One race, Mount Benbulben finally lived up to his tall reputation with a defining victory over fences in the Champion Novice Chase under Danny Mullins.
The Gordon Elliott-trained 14-1 shot has had jumping issues in the past, but was far more assured on this occasion, beating Tofino Bay by 22 lengths.
National Hunt chase winner Back In Focus was well beaten, while his stable companion Boston Bob was similarly held when suffering a heavy fall.
Davy Russell, who suffered a punctured lung and was replaced in Cheltenham's blue riband contest by AP McCoy, will be back on board Gold Cup runner-up Sir Des Champs in Wednesday's big race, the Punchestown Gold Cup.
The horse, trained by serial Punchestown winner Willie Mullins, was beaten seven lengths by Bobs Worth at Cheltenham and again faces third-placed Long Run, the dual King George VI Chase winner for Berkshire-based Henderson and amateur rider Sam Waley-Cohen.
Mouse Morris's First Lieutenant could also be a contender in Wednesday's big race after taking victory in the Betfred Bowl at the Aintree Festival.
Eleven Cheltenham Festival winners are expected to run during the course of the week in what is considered to be the strongest Punchestown line-up for many years.


Question: represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Three people have been arrested in China on suspicion of spreading malware that targeted Apple's operating system, Chinese officials have announced.

The Beijing Bureau of public security announced the arrest of suspects charged with spreading the WireLurker malware.
The bug was one of the first pieces of malware to penetrate iPhone's strict software controls.
It mainly infected devices in China.
The suspects - named only as Chen, Lee and Wang - were arrested in the Beijing area,  according to the statement posted on Chinese social network Sina Weibo.
The Chinese authorities also shut down the site that had been spreading the malware.
The malware was installed via software downloaded to Mac desktops from the Maiyadi app store.
It was then able to attack iOS devices connected to an infected Mac via a USB cable.
If a handset was jailbroken - a process used by some to remove Apple's restrictions - WireLurker backed up the device's apps to the Mac, where it repackaged them with malware, and then installed the infected versions back on to the iOS machine.
But, according to security experts, the malware was also able to infect non-jailbroken iOS devices.
It did so by taking advantage of a technique created by Apple to allow businesses to install special software on their staff's handsets and tablets.
This process has since been changed by Apple.
By the time WireLurker had been discovered, infected Mac apps had already been downloaded more than 300,000 times.
Apple took steps to block the infected apps and reminded users not to install software from third-party app stores.
A Windows version of the malware was also found.

The operation reportedly involved "hundreds" of workers repackaging second hand smartphone parts as new iPhones for export, with counterfeit phones produced worth 120m yuan ($19m).
The factory was discovered on 14 May but was revealed on social media by Beijing's public security bureau on Sunday, according to reports.
The operation was set up in January.
It was led by a husband and wife team, on the northern outskirts of the Chinese capital, according to Beijing authorities.
They said they had been alerted to the factory by US authorities which had seized some of the fake phones.
The reports come amid an official Chinese crackdown on counterfeit goods, with authorities pushing firms to trademark their goods.
China has also agreed to work with the US authorities to try to stem the large quantities of fake goods flowing between the two countries.
The discovery of the factory comes four years after fake Apple stores were found in Kunming city, China.
Discovered by blogger BirdAbroad, the fakes were so convincing she said many of the staff themselves were convinced that they were employed by the US electronics firm.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Highland Council has submitted a planning application to open up a look-out tower at Inverness Castle as a tourist attraction.

The North Tower commands panoramic views over the city of Inverness and the surrounding countryside.
Originally built in the 1840's as a prison, the tower is now owned by the Highland Council.
Councillor Thomas Prag said he hoped opening up the tower would help to boost visitors to the city centre.
Earlier this year the local authority joined the Scottish government in setting up a working group to look at the castle's future tourism potential.
But because the tower is owned by Highland Council it could be opened up to visitors sooner than other parts of the site.
In August, Tourism Minister Fergus Ewing said for years people had been calling for the castle to be made into a tourist attraction.
Earlier this year the Inverness Courier newspaper started an 'Open the Castle' campaign to support such calls.
Chairman of the Development and Infrastructure Committee, Mr Prag said the planning application was "an important first step towards the exciting project of opening up part of the castle to tourists and to local people.
"Like many others in our city, I have been dreaming of the day we might get to do something like this.
"The tower will be an excellent attraction for tourists and will help to boost visits to the city centre."

The Aberdeenshire station was once used by the Royal family when they travelled to nearby Balmoral.
Although no longer used as a rail station, it housed a tourist centre, retail units and a restaurant - all of which were destroyed by the blaze.
Plans have now been submitted that would see the station recreated.
Parts of the Royal Waiting Room were salvaged from the fire and a replica Royal carriage which had been on display was relatively undamaged.
The new planning application would see the station building reinstated - including the VisitScotland information centre, public library and restaurant - as well as the waiting room and carriage.
There would be a new exhibition space extending along the old platform and over the tracks, taking the form of railway sheds.
A new public square is proposed in front of the station, linking it to the nearby Victoria and Albert Halls and creating a destination point for the Deeside Way.
The plans have been submitted to the Cairngorms National Park Authority by Aberdeenshire Council, Historic Environment Scotland and a firm of architects.
It is hoped that work could start in November, with the station and exhibition space expected to be open towards the end of 2017.
Originally built in 1866, the station underwent a complete refurbishment in 2001 and was leased by Aberdeenshire Council to VisitScotland.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: A search-and-rescue helicopter retired from Navy missions is to be turned into a holiday home.

Stirling farmer Martyn Steedman bought the Sea King helicopter in an online MoD auction for £7,000 and decided turn it into accommodation.
It will cater for a family of five and will have a dining area in the cockpit, a mini kitchen and an en-suite shower.
The helicopter retired from active service in 1994 and was used in naval training until 2002.
The idea for the conversion came to Mr Steedman during the Sea Kings' final fly past over Stirling earlier this year, which marked the end of active service for the entire fleet.
He said: "We couldn't bear to see these much-loved helicopters go on the scrapheap and thought 'why not give one a new life in the country?'
The 17m (56ft) long Sea King ZA127 aircraft was driven 320 miles by road from Grantham, Lincolnshire, to Mains Farm Wigwams, Thornhill, Stirlingshire, on Tuesday before a crane lifted it into position at the campsite.

The elite US Marine Corps HMX-1 squadron, which provides air support to US Presidents, thundered over the cities, along with RAF Military helicopters and police air support.
Perhaps the most dramatic sight were the Osprey MV-22 aircraft, which can land and take off like a helicopter but then tilt their rotors to become conventional planes.
The Ospreys, which visited both the Celtic Manor summit venue and Cardiff city centre, were accompanied by Sikorsky VH-60N helicopters, a VIP version of the US Blackhawk.
The VH-60N, known as a "Nighthawk", will change its callsign to "Marine One" but only when the President is on board.
The Ospreys, operated by the same HMX-1 squadron, provide logistical support and carry members of the US Secret Service.
Members of the US Marine Corps squadron and several aircraft have been flown to a temporary base at RAF Fairford in Gloucestershire from Quantico, Virginia.
It's understood Monday's operation was a familiarisation flight for the US crews.
RAF Merlin helicopters, which can carry 25 fully armed troops, were also training in the area at the same time.
Police had earlier advised the public not to be alarmed by the helicopter activity.
People took to social media as the aircraft circled.
Rhian Lewis tweeted: "Not every day your desk starts to shake because of the giant helicopters buzzing around."
James Knight posted: "The amount of helicopters I have heard today makes it sound like were at war, not having a NATO summit."
The four Ospreys and two VH-60N "Nighthawks" - all painted in a distinctive olive green and white - later returned to their base at RAF Fairford.
They will take to the skies again when Air Force One carrying President Obama to the UK arrives on Wednesday.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Gunmen have kidnapped at least 27 Qatari hunters - including members of the ruling family - in a desert area of Iraq near the Saudi border, say police and the local governor.

The attackers were driving dozens of four-wheel drive vehicles when they swept into the hunters' camp at dawn on Wednesday, officials said.
They struck near Layyah, 190km (118 miles) from regional capital, Samawa.
A wide-scale search has been launched for the attackers, police say.
The Qatari foreign ministry released a statement saying it was working with the Iraqi government "at the highest security and political levels... to find out the details of the Qatari citizens' abduction and work on their release as soon as possible".
It said they had been hunting with official Iraqi permission - though Iraq's interior ministry accused the hunters of failing to abide by its instructions to remain inside secured areas.
The aim of the abduction was "to achieve political and media goals", the interior ministry said.
The remote area where the incident took place is highly tribal in nature and a Shia region, reports the BBC's Jim Muir in Beirut.
The Shia political parties which dominate the Iraqi government are highly critical of Qatar's role in supporting Sunni rebels in Syria - so this is bound to be a serious diplomatic incident, he says.
Iraq is one of several countries frequented by Gulf Arab huntsmen and falconers as they search for prey that either does not exist in their own countries or which has been almost hunted to extinction there.
Their favoured prey is the Asian houbara bustard, akin to a small turkey, and to find it and other similar species Gulf hunters often travel to Morocco, Iraq, Pakistan and Afghanistan.
They take with them their prized falcons, typically peregrines, sakers and lanners, which are expertly trained to home in on their quarry at high speed. According to a former CIA officer, in 1998 a CIA-run sniper team in Afghanistan observed Osama Bin Laden and his al-Qaeda followers gathered at a camp near Kandahar but they were ordered to take no action for risk of harming the Emirati hunters who were with them.
Other Gulf hunting expeditions have even extended as far as the Central African Republic in search of big game.
Two Iraqi officers providing security for the party were also taken by the gunmen but later released, officials said.
No details were provided on which members of the Qatari royal family were among those held.
Wealthy practitioners of the ancient sport of falconry from various Gulf states often travel to the area at this time of year.
The hunters had been escorted by Iraqi security forces but they decided not to engage a large number of gunmen, a police colonel from Samawa - the capital of Muthanna governorate - told Reuters.
"We are talking about at least 100 gunmen armed with light and medium weapons," he said.
More than 12 years after the US-led invasion and occupation, Iraq is still plagued by violent crime and militant attacks.
In September, 16 Turkish construction workers were freed a month after being kidnapped in the capital, Baghdad, apparently by Shia Muslim militants.
Falconry was an important skill for Bedouin hunters in the harsh deserts of Arabia and Syria and has been around for thousands of years.
But the Asian houbara bustard (or MacQueen's bustard) - a likely target of the kidnapped hunters - only came to prominence as a favoured prey in the 1970s, when lavish hunting trips became popular, and when the availability of four-wheel-drives and guns prompted a sudden decline in the species, which is now threatened.
The bird's popularity may be partly explained by its elegant plumage and because some consider its meat to be an aphrodisiac.
Arabs' pursuit of the Asian houbara has caused tension elsewhere. There has been growing hostility in Pakistan, where Gulf Arab hunting parties were until recently regularly granted permission to bring in falcons to hunt the Asian houbara despite a ban on locals hunting - and sometimes killed thousands at a time. Amid a conservationists' outcry, two months ago Pakistan's Supreme Court ordered a total ban on hunting of the species.

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary

Interior ministry spokesman Brig Gen Saad Maan told the BBC that the border force was functioning normally.
Earlier, al-Arabiya TV reported that Saudi Arabia had deployed 30,000 soldiers along the 900km (560-mile) frontier after Iraqi forces withdrew.
The Saudi personnel were fanning out along the border to prevent attacks by jihadist-led Sunni rebels, it said.
On Wednesday, King Abdullah discussed Iraq and the threat posed by the Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant (Isis) with US President Barack Obama in a telephone conversation.
Mr Obama also thanked him for the $500m (Â£291m) donation to the UN to help it address the humanitarian crisis caused by the insurgency in Iraq.
More than one million Iraqis have fled their homes over the month as Sunni rebels led by Isis overran Mosul, Tikrit and other cities and towns in the north and west. At least 2,461 people were killed in violent attacks in June, according to the UN and Iraqi authorities.
On Thursday afternoon, Turkey's Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu announced that a group of 32 Turkish lorry drivers who were seized last month in northern Iraq by Isis had been handed over to Turkish diplomats and would be flown to Ankara.
Mr Davutoglu said Turkey would continue its efforts to secure the release of 49 other Turkish citizens, including children, diplomats and special forces personnel, who were still being held.
India's foreign ministry said 46 Indian nurses being held by militants in Tikrit were safe, but were being forced to move to a new area controlled by the militants.
It added that 40 Indian construction workers abducted two weeks ago near Mosul were still being held, but were also unharmed.
Western officials in the Iraqi capital said they had no reason to believe that the reported Saudi troop movement had come in response to any direct threat along the border, the BBC's Paul Adams in Baghdad reports.
Their view was that such moves were more likely to represent a prudent step in light of the chaotic situation in Iraq, our correspondent adds.
About 10 days ago, there were reports of clashes between Isis and the Iraqi army in the town of Nukhayb, around 120km (75 miles) from the Saudi border, with witnesses talking about Iraqi troops fleeing towards the Shia holy city of Karbala, about 100km (60 miles) south of Baghdad.
Al-Arabiya published a video showing what the Saudi-owned channel said were about 2,500 Iraqi soldiers in the desert east of Karbala who had been ordered to leave their posts along the border with Saudi Arabia.
On Wednesday, up to 45 people were killed in clashes between Iraqi security forces and armed followers of a radical Shia cleric in Karbala, security sources told the Reuters news agency.
The clashes reportedly erupted when police and soldiers, backed by helicopter gunships, tried to arrest Mahmoud al-Sarkhi around midnight on Tuesday, after his supporters started blocking roads and setting up checkpoints around his stronghold in the city.
Meanwhile, the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, a UK-based activist group, reported that Isis had seized control of Syria's largest oil field, al-Omar in Deir al-Zour province, after rival fighters from the al-Qaeda-affiliated al-Nusra Front withdrew.