Question:
this is the first sentence of a news article. represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article
------
Given ['Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details', 'A married draughtsman from Liverpool, Nick Joynes travelled to the match with a number of friends, who all survived except Francis Joseph McAllister.'], a positive would be ['Represent the next text', "This is the full statement to the inquests from his brother, Paul Joynes:\nMy name is James Paul Joynes. I am the brother of Nicholas Peter Joynes, and I am speaking on behalf of my father, James, known as Peter Joynes, my mother, Patricia Joynes, my brother's wife, Gillian, his sister, Michelle, his sister-in-law, Elaine, his brothers-in-law, his nieces and nephews, Ian, Laura, Jessica, Sean and Emily, being the Joynes family of Lancashire:\nSpeaking on behalf of the Joynes family, I will say as follows in relation to Nicholas Peter Joynes, born on 20 September, 1961.  He was aged 27 when he died.\nMy parents have had four children, three boys and a girl.  I am the eldest, followed by Mark, 14 months later, and then Nicholas three years later.  My sister was born some five years after Nicholas was born. Nicholas was known to us all as 'Nick'.\nNick, as a little boy, was a quiet child, but we put that down to the fact that he had two older brothers, who tended to look after him.\nAlthough Nick was not an academic child, he got on quite well at school.  He loved sport.  His favourite sport was to play football, but he was generally a good all-rounder, enjoying athletics and cricket, also.\nProfiles of all those who died\nMy Dad did try to get Nick to play golf, but he did not take to it.  Nick was, however, a talented footballer and did at one point have trials at Liverpool Football Club but just didn't make the grade.\nNick played for Bootle Boys in his teens and his Dad takes great pleasure in telling people that when Nick was 14 his team won, Bootle Boys, won a local cup competition called the Dimmer Cup, and that is a cup that Jamie Carragher later played in when he was young.\nWe enjoyed many family holidays together, with most of them being spent in England. The family really enjoyed going to Ladram Bay in Devon, near to Exmouth,       where we would often stay in a caravan.\nNick loved this place so much that, when he was 18, he returned with his friends to have a small break there.\nNick left school at 16.  He immediately started an apprenticeship at OTIS elevators.  Dad and Mark were already working at this company at the time, which paved the way for Nick to join them.\nNick also attended Hugh Bird College in Bootle for one day a week, studying engineering on a day release from OTIS elevators.\nNick had a bubbly personality and always had lots of friends.  He got on well with people and enjoyed socialising, particularly at the weekends.  He enjoyed the social scene in the centre of the city.\nHe had lots of girlfriends, but kept his liaisons and relationships away from home. Nick liked to wear fashionable clothes, and always took great pride in his appearance.\nNick's best friend was Ian Price.  Ian was Nick's best man at his wedding.  Although Nick had a wide range of friends, I would class him as his closest.\nIan was a hairdresser, and he would use Nick as a model for competitions he was entering.  This meant that Nick would come home often with a variety of hair styles.\nHis Dad would then feel the need to pass comment on what he thought of the latest cut.  This situation was not unusual in our family.\nOne day Nick returned home with a pierced ear, which he revealed during Sunday lunch, much to my Dad's disgust, and on another occasion he came home with a tattoo of a swallow.  Nick, though, was able to take my Dad's comments and brush them to one side.\nNick had a real passion for music.  He enjoyed listening to David Bowie, Depeche Mode and a group called Japan.  He would regularly borrow vinyl records from myself and forget to return them.\nFollowing the Hillsborough disaster, Nick's wife, Gillian handed me some vinyl records from Nick's collection, and I was only to find that some of them were mine.\nThis made us all laugh.  His niece and nephew still play these records to this day.\nIn 1983, our family received the devastating news that my brother, Mark, had been killed in an accident in South Africa.  He had been working there as an engineer    since 1982.\nMy parents were away in Rhodes on holiday, and it was Nick who received the awful news from one of Mark's friends over the telephone at home.\nMark's death could have been prevented.  He did not receive the appropriate medical care.  Later, there was a successful prosecution.\nNick could not contemplate how Mark could have been let down so badly by the hospital in South Africa.  Nick was very close to Mark and Mark's death affected him greatly.\nHe never got over the fact that he had lost his brother.  He became very protective of us all.\nNick celebrated his 21st birthday at the Kirby Civic Suite in Kirby, Merseyside.  His party was well attended and was a fancy dress affair.\nNick and a group of friends went as hula girls, sporting grass skirts, and I remember my mother dressed up as a Japanese geisha girl.  It was a great party.\nNick's future wife, Gillian Shaw, was also there.  Shortly after this party they got together as a couple. Gillian was part of Nick's social group and they knew each other from the Hugh Bird College.\nBy now, Nick had secured himself an office-based job with OTIS elevators, having successfully completed his stint in the engineering department there.\nGillian was an air hostess, and because of her employment she moved from Liverpool down to East Grinstead in West Sussex.  Nick would regularly travel down to see her.\nWe have a memory of Nick when he was about 25 and had broken his leg while playing football.  Despite the cast on his leg, he would still travel down to see Gillian on his crutches.\nNick even went on holiday with his friends with his leg in plaster, and when he returned he had to have his leg reset at the local hospital.\nNick and Gillian were seeing each other for about three years before they got engaged.  Due to Gillian's employment, Nick, with Gillian, were able to travel to various parts of the world which he loved to do.\nHe travelled to Hong Kong, Dubai, Los Angeles, New York, Spain and Greece.  He loved the sun.  We always called him the sun worshipper, because, given any opportunity to sunbathe, Nick would take it up.\nNick loved Liverpool Football Club and supported them from an early age.  I think it was Mark that gave Nick the passion for Liverpool FC.\nNick would go to Anfield when he could, but he didn't generally go to any away fixtures.\nIn March 1988, Nick and Gillian purchased a house together.  They had set a date for their wedding in September 1988.  They were married at St Thomas's church in Melling in Merseyside, and it was a great day for all of us.\nNick and Gillian were so happy together. They made such a lovely couple.  They had so many dreams and such a great future ahead of them.\nI know Nick would have made a fantastic father.  His death has left a massive void in our family, and we miss him dearly.\nHe was a wonderful son, beloved brother, adored uncle and devoted husband. All our family feel such a tremendous loss."] & a negative would be ['Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary.', 'Ocho stars students from Archbishop Sentamu Academy and is to be performed in East Yorkshire and Barcelona.\nAn estimated 4,000 people from Britain and Ireland fought against General Franco\'s forces between 1936 and 1939.\nLiam Foster, a musician in the play, said: "It\'s a massive piece of local history none of us knew about."\nThe production, starring students aged 15-18, was written by Jane Thornton and features music by Dave Rotheray, lead guitarist for The Beautiful South.\nAndrew Young, of Hull International Brigades Memorial Group, said: "It is incredible to think eight ordinary working class guys put their life on the line to take a principled stand against fascism."\nFour of the Hull men, Jack Atkinson, Jim Bentley, Morris Miller and Robert Wardle, died.\nJoe Latus, Richard Mortimer, Sam Walters and Bert Wilson all returned.\nAll are commemorated on a plaque in the city\'s Guildhall.\nMr Wilson is recorded wrongly on the plaque as Leslie, because he was only 17 years old and used the passport of his older brother, Leslie, to get to Spain.\nAlthough full details of the men\'s service in Spain are unclear, Jack Atkinson died on 21 January 1937 in Jarama.\nRobert Wardle, aged 28, left his wife and two children to go to Spain and both he and Jim Bentley, 24, died near Calaceite on 31 March 1938 less than a month after they had arrived.\nMorris Miller, 22, who had written articles for the International Brigade newspaper, was the last of the four to be killed during a battle on Hill 666, near Gandesa in the Ebro offensive of 1938.\nHe is remembered on a concrete memorial on the hill. His cousin Jonathan Miller previously told the BBC: "It\'s a long way from Hull and it looks a lot different but there\'s a big connection, and Morris is the connection."\nSome of the Hull men went from London to Paris before going south to the Spanish border, followed by a tough climb on foot across the Pyrenees mountain range to join the war.\nJoe Latus arrived on an unknown beach carried by a fishing trawler, according to his daughter Dilys Porter.\nShe has a box of her father\'s mementoes including his identity card and one with the motto "It is better to die on our feet as a free man than live on our knees as slaves".\nHe returned to a career in the Merchant Navy, took part in the Dunkirk evacuation in World War Two, and later became a director of rugby league team Hull FC.\nMrs Porter said: "They are real heroes I think and ought to be celebrated as such."\nSources: National Archives/Britannica\nThe play opens at Archbishop Sentamu Academy on 27 June and is to be performed in various venues before going to Barcelona in July.']

Question: Anders Behring Breivik has told his trial in Oslo that a psychiatric report finding him insane in relation to the 77 killings he carried out was a "lie".

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

Breivik said his position was "entirely logical". There was "not the slightest possibility I will be judged insane".
Two reports came to opposing views on his sanity. The court's ruling on this will determine whether Breivik is sent to jail or into psychiatric care.
The court earlier heard more testimony from victims of the Oslo bombing.
Breivik, 33, admits to killing 77 people in Oslo and on Utoeya island last July but denies criminal responsibility.
The BBC's Lars Bevanger in Oslo says Wednesday's evidence is crucial from Breivik's point of view as it will determine the type of his detention.
The five-strong panel of judges will make the ruling on his sanity at the verdict in July.
Breivik is arguing against the first psychiatric report, which found him legally insane and suffering from paranoid schizophrenia, and in favour of the second, which concluded he was accountable for his actions.
He told the court that the psychiatrists compiling the first study had failed to understand he had deliberately suppressed his emotions to prepare for attacks.
By Richard GalpinBBC News, Oslo
It was probably Breivik's last chance to explain to the court why it should dismiss the report compiled by forensic psychiatrists last year, which had concluded he was insane.
The atmosphere in the courtroom was tense as Breivik tried to prove how the psychiatrists had misinterpreted almost everything he had said, having already reached their conclusion, he claimed, before they interviewed him.
But the prosecution put him on the spot by asking him to specify exactly what had been misinterpreted.
One of his first answers was bizarre. He was concerned they had omitted the pronoun "I" from all his quotes in the report. This, he claimed, made him seem "crazy and of little intelligence".
He also seemed caught out when asked what his sources were for claiming that since 1945 a number of Norwegians had been locked away in psychiatric wards for ideological reasons.
A psychologist watching proceedings told the BBC this came close to convincing him that Breivik was suffering from paranoiac delusion.
He said: "It is not me who is described in that report... Everything I presented was entirely logical. I don't see the slightest possibility I will be judged insane."
Breivik said those who compiled the report lacked the experience to analyse someone who had committed an "act of political violence", and that they were in shock because they had spoken to him soon after the attacks.
He also said they might have been pressured by Norway's government to keep his ideology from getting out.
Our correspondent says the issue of sanity is key for Breivik, who wants to show his actions were motivated by a political doctrine.
Breivik has said committal to a psychiatric ward would be a fate worse than death and he would do "anything to prevent" it.
Breivik himself has argued he should either be put to death or acquitted.
Our correspondent says most people in Norway who have been following the trial expect Breivik to be found sane, given the way he has conducted himself in court.
If so he could face 21 years in jail, which can be extended if he is thought a continuing danger to society. He would face compulsory psychiatric care if found insane.
Earlier, the court heard more testimony from those injured in the Oslo blast and more forensic evidence of the explosion.
Passer-by Eivind Dahl Thoresen described seeing flames out of the corner of his right eye, lifting his hands to his face and being thrown backwards.
Deafened, he said he tried to help another injured man before noticing he was himself bleeding heavily and lay down, shouting for help.
The prosecution also read a statement on behalf of another blast victim, who lost a limb.
Our correspondent says these are some of the first tales of the many victims of the July attacks and over the next eight and a half weeks of the trial, there are sure to be many more harrowing stories to come.
He says that in a few weeks time there will be 69 more coroner's reports - one for each of the deaths at the Labour Party youth camp on Utoeya island.
Relatives of victims sobbed during the evidence on both Tuesday and Wednesday.
Breivik watched the witnesses without any visible emotion.
On Wednesday he said if anyone should apologise for the killings it should be the ruling Labour Party.
"But instead they continue in the same direction, so the grounds for struggle are unfortunately even more relevant now than before July 22."
Breivik spent the first week of the trial giving his own version of events, saying his plan was to kill as many people as possible.
He says he was defending Norway from multiculturalism.

The display in Oslo opened four years to the day after Breivik killed 77 people in a bloody rampage.
Officials says it aims to help Norway come to terms with the terror attacks.
But experts and some relatives of the victims have warned it could become a magnet for right-wing extremists.
Concern has focused on the inclusion of some personal items belonging to the killer, including a fake police identity card.
Last week, Tor Oestboe, whose wife was among those killed, said he feared the exhibition would provide a "hall of fame" for the mass murderer.
Breivik killed eight people in a bombing in central Oslo and went on to gun down 69 more at a youth camp at nearby Utoeya island in 2011.
He harboured extremist right-wing views and claimed he had reacted against what he saw as a Marxist-Islamic takeover of Europe.
Nato Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg, who was prime minister of Norway at the time of the massacre, attended commemoration ceremonies on Wednesday.
He said he believed the exhibition, housed in the government complex targeted by Breivik, was necessary.
"July 22 is a dramatic event in the history of Norway. It cannot be hushed up, but must be treated with the dignity and respect that such a brutal incident must be dealt with," local media quoted him as saying.
Oeystein Soerensen, a political historian, told Norway's Dagbladet newspaper last week that the exhibition could become "a kind of twisted Mecca" for anti-Islam and right-wing extremist "tourists".
Mr Stoltenberg is due to attend the Labour Party youth camp on Utoeya island in August, which will take place for the first time since 2011.
A new memorial is also being unveiled on Wednesday to those killed on the island.
In 2012 a court in Oslo found Breivik guilty of a premeditated act of terrorism. and sentenced him to 21 years in jail.
He "acknowledged" the acts committed, but said he did not accept criminal responsibility.
His jail term can be extended if he is deemed to remain a danger to society.
He has since launched legal action accusing the Norwegian state of violating his human rights by keeping him in strict isolation in prison.
Earlier this month he won a place to study political science at Oslo's university, although he will do so from his cell and have no contact with staff or students.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: The way that England's railway network is run is set to be overhauled under plans outlined by Transport Secretary Chris Grayling.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

He wants each rail franchise to be run by joint management teams, including representatives from both the train operating company and Network Rail.
Mr Grayling said: "I intend to start bringing back together the operation of track and train on our railways."
The changes will start when each franchise is renewed in the future.
The minister said he wanted the changes to improve services for passengers, who are travelling on an increasingly crowded and expensive network.
"We need to change the relationship between the tracks and the trains on the railway," Mr Grayling said.
"In my experience passengers don't understand the division between the two.
"They just want someone to be in charge. They want their train to work. I agree with them," he added.
Each franchise will be run by one joint team, but the franchise owners and Network Rail will continue to exist separately.
The first new joint management teams will come into operation when the South Eastern and the East Midlands franchises are re-let in 2018.
Network Rail's chief executive, Mark Carne, said the new plan would "bring more joined-up working within the industry".
Lianna Etkind, of the Campaign for Better Transport, gave the proposal a cautious welcome.
"Rail passengers are not interested in the finer details of the management of the railways, they just want trains that are punctual, safe and reliable and don't cost the earth to use," she said.
"We hope that these reforms will work, but ultimately they will be judged on whether they actually deliver better and cheaper services for passengers."
The establishment of railway franchises, separate from the network infrastructure, goes back to the privatisation of British Rail in 1993 by John Major's Conservative government.
This separation, which is still in force, is held by some critics to be a significant source of delays to management decisions, repairs and train services.
Rail privatisation was partly reversed in 2002 when the previous infrastructure owner, the privately-owned Railtrack, was taken over by the government-controlled Network Rail in the wake of the Hatfield rail crash.
Mick Cash, general secretary of the RMT rail union, told the BBC the proposed changes were "a slippery slope to privatisation and the break-up of Network Rail" and that the union was "deeply concerned".
"We don't want to go back to the Railtrack days," he said. "It's quite clear they want to break up Network Rail, they want to privatise the rail infrastructure.
"We don't want to go back to the days of [rail disasters] Hatfield and Potters Bar - that's what happens when you get the private sector in charge of our infrastructure."
Shadow transport secretary Andy McDonald told the BBC that what the government "appears to be contemplating is yet further complexity, yet further fragmentation, and more opportunities for private entities to extract value out of our railway system".
He said that franchises should be brought back under public ownership as they come to be renewed.
However, Mr Grayling said the changes were "not about privatising Network Rail, it's not about handing over control of the track to train operating companies, it's about forging partnership alliances between the two".
I have never met anyone, no matter what their politics, who thinks it was a good idea to have one company running the trains and another running the track they run on.
But that's what they decided to do when they privatised the network 20 or so years ago.
I've heard of crazy situations, where train companies made money out of Network Rail when it overran on engineering work (they had to pay a fine).  Then the firm would make extra money running the replacement bus service too.
Different companies, with different priorities.
Now Chris Grayling has become the latest transport secretary to try to get Network Rail working as one with private companies to fix the problems together, rather than arguing about whose fault it is.
They are already trying something like it across Scotland and with South West Trains.
As for getting one private company running everything on a future Cambridge to Oxford line, some fear it's an attempt to privatise rail repairs, which ended disastrously under Railtrack.
Speaking to the transport secretary, though, he told me that he had no intention of making radical changes across the network, or breaking up Network Rail. He just wants the public and private sector, train and tracks, to work together - not against - each other.
The new management approach may also be applied to the running of the revived "Varsity Line" between Oxford and Cambridge.
The recent Autumn Statement confirmed that the line, which was closed in the 1960s, should be rebuilt and reopened.
The line will be designed, constructed and run by a new body called East West Rail, which will be separate from Network Rail.
Mr Grayling said that, on this line, the track would be publicly owned but run by a private company, and would "provide a degree of comparison with Network Rail to say 'can we build lines quicker and cheaper than we are at the moment?'."

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary

Transport Secretary Patrick McLoughlin said the government will hold talks with Virgin for a temporary contract.
A competition will then be run for a new franchise deal.
Mr McLoughlin added the first findings of a review into what went wrong will be released by the end of October.
The decision to give FirstGroup the route from December was withdrawn after "technical flaws" in the bid process were discovered.
Three senior civil servants have been suspended and the government faces a bill of Â£40m to compensate franchise bidders.
A Virgin Trains spokesman said the move meant it was in a position to "offer customers some short-term continuity".
By Richard WestcottBBC transport correspondent
The government's landed itself in a right old mess over the West Coast franchise and so they're trying something totally new to clean it up.
Ministers, Virgin, even First Group seem to all agree that it's best if Virgin keeps the trains going after its contract expires on 9 December.
But they can't run things for too long because it wouldn't be fair...EU procurement rules mean everyone must get a decent go at bidding for new business.
That's why ministers have had to set up another, short-term franchise competition, open to everyone, to plug the gap between the time Virgin's deal runs out, and the time a new, long-term contract is awarded to run the line.
Ministers also have to wait for a review to report back into whether franchising really works. And that's not due until Christmas. If it recommends big changes, it will lead to yet more delays.
So all of this is a rather messy way of buying some time until they sort everything out.
The whole fiasco's costing the taxpayer tens of millions of pounds but there is just the one piece of good news if you use the line: we're being reassured the service won't suffer.
The competition to run the line was cancelled on 3 October and led to the suspension of other franchise programmes including bids for Essex Thameside, Great Western and Thameslink.
The government has announced two independent reviews to focus on the West Coast competition and the wider DfT rail franchise programme.
The flaws in the bidding were discovered as the DfT was preparing to contest a legal challenge by Virgin to the decision not to award it the contract.
Transport Secretary Patrick McLoughlin said: "My priority now is to fix the problem and the first step is to take urgent action to ensure that... services continue to run to the same standard and passengers are not affected.
"I believe Virgin remaining as operator for a short period of time is the best way to do this and my officials and I will be working flat out to make this happen."
Mr McLoughlin said he hoped the preliminary findings of one of two reviews he has launched into the debacle will be released by the end of this month.
The chief executive of energy firm Centrica, Sam Laidlaw, will investigate "what happened during the West Coast procurement, and why," said Mr McLoughlin.
He told the Commons: "I have asked for the initial findings of this [Laidlaw] review by the end of October and expect to have a full report by the end of November.
"It will establish the lessons to be learnt," he added,
The transport secretary added the second review, led by the chairman of Eurostar, Richard Brown, "will report no later than the end of the year on lessons for the future franchising programme, so that it can be resumed as soon as possible".
He warned the House: "Before these reviews have been completed... any speculation as to the nature of the flaws is just that... speculation".
The West Coast route serves 31 million passengers travelling between London, the West Midlands, the north-west of England, North Wales and the central belt of Scotland.
FirstGroup had initially beaten current operator Virgin Trains to win the 13-year franchise.
BBC News transport correspondent Richard Westcott said the interim contract will last for two years while the longer franchise will be handed out around the time of the next general election.
The decision was a "messy solution to a mistake that is costing the taxpayer tens of millions of pounds" but the transport secretary feels it is the best way to keep services running without disruption, our correspondent added.
Ahead of the announcement, Labour warned that a decision to extend Virgin's contract could see taxpayers exposed to further legal costs.
Shadow transport secretary Maria Eagle also said it was wrong for the investigation into the bid process to be carried by Mr Laidlaw, who is also a DfT non-executive director.
She told the Commons the whole saga was "a monumental failure of this shambles of a government".
RMT transport union leader Bob Crow described the decision to extend Virgin's franchise as a "shabby deal" but said it was "no surprise". The RMT had been hoping the West Coast franchise would be run by the DfT in the public sector.
Meanwhile, Manuel Cortes, leader of the TSSA rail union, said: "This decision means that the long-running Whitehall farce, known as private rail franchising, continues at the taxpayer's expense."


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details.

Question: EU leaders have told Ukraine they are worried about ceasefire violations in the east of the country but will not send armed peacekeepers there.

"We can only talk about a civilian mission, not military," European Council President Donald Tusk told a news conference in Kiev.
Earlier Ukraine's President Petro Poroshenko said the EU or the UN should deploy peacekeepers to eastern Ukraine.
Pro-Russian rebels have been bombarding a village near the city of Mariupol.
On Sunday tank and mortar rounds pounded the village - Shyrokyne - near government-held Mariupol, a vital port city.
Mr Tusk said the EU would send a civilian "assessment" mission to Kiev, to explore ways to further boost security assistance for Ukraine.
The heavily armed rebels have been fighting government forces for a year in Ukraine's Donetsk and Luhansk regions.
The West accuses Russia of arming the rebels and sending in regular soldiers. Moscow denies that, insisting that any Russians on the rebel side are volunteers.
Mr Poroshenko says peacekeepers are needed to ensure proper monitoring of frontline areas and the rebel-controlled border with Russia.
Mr Tusk said: "We are concerned about reports of weapons still entering eastern Ukraine".
International OSCE observers were "not able to verify a withdrawal of heavy weaponry", he said.
Under the Minsk ceasefire deal signed in February both sides were supposed to pull heavy weapons back from the conflict zone.
Mr Tusk reiterated that EU sanctions against Russia would remain in place until the Minsk conditions were met in full.
On Sunday OSCE observers said they experienced the most intense shelling of Shyrokyne since fighting began there in mid-February. Heavy weapons including tanks were spotted in rebel-held areas near there, they said.
Fighting hits Ukraine's EU ambitions - by Tom Burridge, BBC News, Donetsk:
As the leaders met in Kiev, we could hear the steady boom of shelling in a bombed-out neighbourhood, on the edge of Donetsk.
Valentina, 54, emerged from her blackened apartment block, with most of its windows smashed, to tell us of "constant fighting, every single day".
"We're sick of all this," she said as tears filled her eyes. "It's affecting us psychologically."
We watched some 20 pro-Russian fighters travel back from the frontline on top of an armoured personnel carrier, and another group of around 20 replace them, heading towards the fighting.
A tank was parked up, idle for now. Tank shells were visible in the back of another vehicle. According to a rebel soldier, we were about 2km (one mile) from the frontline.
When you see and hear fighting on a daily basis in eastern Ukraine, at least some of the political and economic aspirations of European and Ukrainian leaders seem hollow.
The economic cost of the war undermines Ukraine's ambition for greater economic integration with the EU.
It also makes some political aspirations, like visa-free travel for Ukrainian citizens in the EU, highly unlikely.
Yet the EU leaders' visit is hugely symbolic. They are keen to show solidarity in the face of what they see as Russian-fuelled aggression in the east.
But the rebels will probably interpret the summit as another provocation.
EU Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker also attended the Kiev talks.
It is the first such summit since a key EU-Ukraine association agreement was signed last June. Talks will continue in Kiev on Tuesday.
The EU is anxious for Ukraine to enact far-reaching economic reforms to tackle unsustainable debts, inflation and widespread corruption.
The EU agreed to delay implementing the association deal with Ukraine until January 2016, in response to Russian complaints.
Russia is suspicious of the agreement, arguing that free trade could turn Ukraine into a conduit for cheap goods flooding into Russia.
Mr Juncker said Ukrainians' living conditions were "very difficult", and he pledged more EU financial assistance to help in the "painful" reform process. "Ukrainian citizens want to live in a corruption-free country," he said.
Reform of the heavily subsidised energy sector is a priority, BBC economics expert Andrew Walker says, as energy inefficiencies are a big drain on the national budget.

Petro Poroshenko's claim has not been independently confirmed.
Heavy fighting erupted on Wednesday in Maryinka and Krasnohorivka, west of rebel-held Donetsk.
The opposing sides have accused each other of shattering February's Minsk ceasefire, requiring them to withdraw heavy weapons from the frontline.
The Donetsk rebel leader spoke of huge losses in the Ukrainian army.
Alexander Zakharchenko, leader of the self-styled "Donetsk People's Republic", said the Maryinka fighting had left about 400 Ukrainian troops dead and up to 1,000 wounded.
"This was a counter-attack. If we had attacked, we would have captured Maryinka," he said on Friday.
Quoted by Russia's RIA Novosti news agency, he said 15 rebel fighters had been killed and 30 wounded.
Ukrainian officials said three government soldiers and about 80 rebels were killed in the intense fighting.
Tanks and other heavy weapons were used in the clashes, despite the terms of the Minsk accord agreed in February demanding that both sides pull heavy weapons far back from the frontline.
President Poroshenko told a news conference on Friday that Russia had massed troops on the border and in rebel-held areas "in unprecedented numbers" - but Russia again denied that its military was involved in Ukraine.
Mr Poroshenko said Ukraine has deployed 50,000 troops in the conflict zone to meet the threat.
He also said he would not allow any Russian forces to transit Ukraine in order to reach the Russian army in Trans-Dniester. Pro-Russian separatists run the breakaway region on Ukraine's western border, which remains legally part of Moldova.
The White House said US President Barack Obama spoke with his Ukrainian counterpart on Friday about the violence in the east of the country.
It said both leaders expressed their "deep concern" about fighting near Donetsk and urged rebels to respect the Minsk ceasefire.
Their concern was echoed by Alexander Hug, deputy chief of the OSCE monitoring mission in Ukraine, who told the UN Security Council that there had been "a significant deterioration of the security situation".
"The violence witnessed in and around the town of Maryinka close to the [frontline] constitutes a new worrying development in the conflict in eastern Ukraine," he said.
"Our assessment from the ground is that tension levels have increased and that ceasefire violations are becoming more frequent as well as more severe."
More than 6,400 people have been killed in eastern Ukraine since the conflict began in April 2014, when rebels seized large parts of two eastern regions, following Russia's annexation of the Crimea peninsula.
If there is a spike in fighting, like the battle in the town of Maryinka on Wednesday, then both sides know they cannot be seen as the aggressor, because they lose credibility and damage the negotiating position of their allies in either Moscow, or in European capitals.
Neither side wants to be seen as responsible for breaking the highly publicised, but so far unsuccessful, Minsk peace agreement.
And bargaining power for either side will become ever more crucial because in three weeks the European Union will decide whether to renew sanctions against Russia.
Read more from Tom


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article!

Question: The National Football League boss has said he "got it wrong" in dealing with the violence scandals that have plagued the American football league.

In his first public statement in a week, Roger Goodell apologised for his mistakes and pledged to implement new personal conduct policies.
"We strongly condemn and will punish behaviour that is totally unacceptable," he said.
He has faced calls to resign after a series of assaults involving players.
But the commissioner said on Friday he had not considered stepping down and that he had the support of the team owners.
"We will get our house in order," he said at a press conference in New York.
Mr Goodell announced the NFL plans to set up a new personal conduct committee and draft new rules for the league's players and staff, which he hoped would be in place for the Super Bowl in early 2015.
The NFL, and Mr Goodell in particular, have been criticised over their handling of an abuse case involving running back Ray Rice from the Baltimore Ravens.
Mr Goodell initially banned Rice for two games after he was accused of assaulting his then-fiancee and video emerged of him dragging her apparently unconscious from a lift in Atlantic City in February.
It was only after video of him punching her was posted online in August that Rice was cut by the Ravens and banned from the league indefinitely by Mr Goodell.
"I got it wrong in the handling of the Ray Rice matter," he said on Friday.
"But now I will get it right and do whatever is necessary to accomplish that."
The NFL has also come under fire for its handling of other abuse cases, including Minnesota Vikings running back Adrian Peterson, who has been charged with child abuse in Texas after allegedly whipping his four-year-old son.
In recent days, some NFL sponsors have made public statements urging it to do more to address the issue.
On Friday, Procter & Gamble announced it was dropping an on-field breast cancer awareness promotion it had been planning with the NFL.
"Domestic violence is completely unacceptable and we have strongly urged the NFL to take swift and decisive action to address this issue," said a spokesman.
"Our decision to cancel this on field activity was related to this ongoing issue.''
Other sponsors like PepsiCo and Anheuser-Busch have expressed concern. Women make up about 35% of the average television audience of games.
Mr Goodell said NFL staff would be required to undergo training on the prevention of domestic violence and sexual assault starting within 30 days.
He said the league will partner with the National Domestic Violence Hotline and National Sexual Violence Resource Center.
Correction 4 October 2014: This report has been amended to clarify the chain of events in the Ray Rice case.

It's now a week since Indianapolis Colts linebacker D'Qwell Jackson intercepted a pass by New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady and tossed the ball over to his team on the sidelines. There, it seems, the matter of the balls' pressures first came up and conversations were had.
Whether the words "deflated", "deflation", "deflating" or any other variant came up in the course of that chat is open to debate.
But what almost certainly was not said in the driving rain of Foxboro Stadium was "deflate-gate".
That would come later.
In a nutshell, the NFL is investigating claims the Patriots may have deflated the match balls to give themselves an advantage in Sunday's 45-7 win over Indianapolis that sent them to the Super Bowl.
According to reports, 11 of the 12 game balls they provided for the rain-affected match-up were under-inflated by about two pounds per square inch. If you deflate a ball in cold or wet conditions, it provides more grip for the quarterback, in this case Brady.
In a statement, the NFL said initial evidence thus far supports the conclusion that under-inflated footballs were used by the Patriots in the first half but were properly inflated for the second half.
However, the Patriots have denied any wrongdoing.  immediately after the game, and again throughout the week.
Strangely, no. Both teams supply their own balls for each game so Colts quarterback Andrew Luck used his own. Twelve balls are presented to the referee by both teams two hours and 15 minutes before the game. NFL rules on the types of ball to be used are painfully specific:
"The Ball must be a "Wilson," hand selected, bearing the signature of the Commissioner of the League, Roger Goodell," the rule in question begins in a faintly ridiculous manner.
It continues: "The ball shall be made up of an inflated (12 1/2 to 13 1/2 pounds) urethane bladder enclosed in a pebble grained, leather case (natural tan color) without corrugations of any kind. It shall have the form of a prolate spheroid and the size and weight shall be: long axis, 11 to 11 1/4 inches; long circumference, 28 to 28 1/2 inches; short circumference, 21 to 21 1/4 inches; weight, 14 to 15 ounces.
"The Referee shall be the sole judge as to whether all balls offered for play comply with these specifications."
The final line of that particular rule states that "a pump is to be furnished by the home club, and the balls shall remain under the supervision of the referee until they are delivered to the ball attendant just prior to the start of the game."
This certainly hints at a possible window of opportunity, but the league said on Friday that it could not yet determine whether the deflations were the result of "deliberate action" and certainly no one is pointing fingers at any 'ball attendants'.
Of course. The hashtag #deflategate has been used almost 350,000 times in the last week and has been one of the top trends on Twitter for several days.
And if anyone likes to keep track of these things, massrelevance.com has identified the individual who sent the first #deflategate tweet as one Ryan Edwards from Aurora, Colorado.
Newspaper headline writers have been having fun with this over in the US, while chat show hosts such as Conan O'Brien, Jimmy Fallon and Jimmy Kimmel have predictably taken aim.
Michelin Tyres couldn't let a good deflation gag pass them by, and for those of you who enjoyed seeing Bango, the mascot of the Milwaukee Bucks basketball team, moving and shaking with Thierry Henry at the O2 in London last week, then you really don't want to miss this brilliant vine of him, er, checking his balls.
It's a fair question. It's worth remembering that the Patriots scored 17 points in the first half when, according to the NFL, the balls were below their optimum pressure. Twenty-eight points were piled on by Brady and Co after interval, when the balls had been re-inflated.
And a tweet by Colts tight end Dwayne Allen is also worth considering.
"They could have played with soap for balls and beat us," he said. "Simply the better team."
After denying any wrongdoing in the wake of the game a week ago, head coach Bill Belichick appeared once again on Saturday - to hold a 'science-based' press conference to further deny anything untoward.
The Guardian reports "he was 35 minutes late. He spoke at length about ball textures, equilibriums, rubbing processes and atmospheric pressures. He name-checked Mona Lisa Vito, a character from the 1992 Joe Pesci comedy My Cousin Vinny."
Belichick went on to explain how the Pats had conducted their own experiments on balls this week - detailing how they simulated the game day situation which has landed them in hot water.
But the physics teacher routine just gave Twitter more ammo, and then a Vine appeared where Bill was mercilessly ridiculed for "handling dozens of balls this week".
Unfortunately the Pats have previous in this area. In 2007 they were embroiled in 'spygate', when an assistant coach videotaped New York Jets defensive signals at a game so Brady would know what they were changing the play to.
Media playback is not supported on this device
Fines totalling $750,000 and the loss of a first-round draft pick was the punishment on that occasion. The expectation is for something similar this time if found guilty, with commentators universally ruling out any prospect of the team being stripped of their Super Bowl berth.
However, as time wears on the spotlight is growing increasingly strong on Brady, whose performance in his news conference on Thursday failed to convince many observers.
An editorial on the ESPN website claimed "Tom Brady's tale doesn't hold weight", and called for him to be "benched" for the Super Bowl if found guilty.
Right, let's wheel out Kevin Costner at this point.
The Oscar-winning actor stumbled out of left field and straight into the 'deflate-gate' discussion on Friday when he decided to upbraid former Dallas Cowboys quarterback Troy Aikman for saying that it was "obvious that Tom Brady had something to do with this" in a radio interview.
"It's bold talk. I like Troy a lot and I like Tom a lot. And it's bold when you say somebody is lying," Costner told HLN TV.
The gate suffix is an ironic nod to the major US political scandal which eventually toppled President Richard Nixon, after his administration were involved in a break-in at the Democratic National Committee headquarters at the Watergate office complex in Washington.
This week there were two 'gates' when  Twirlgate hit the news after Eugenie Bouchard defeated Kiki Bertens in the second round of this year's Australian Open. Asked during her on-court interview to "give us a twirl", Bouchard reluctantly agreed, but the request was considered sexist and attracted a wave of social media outrage.
Other sporting 'gates' include:
Pizzagate: As players and officials from both sides clashed in the tunnel at Old Trafford after Manchester United's tempestuous 2-0 victory over Arsenal on 24 October 2004, United manager Sir Alex Ferguson was struck by a slice of pizza thrown by an Arsenal player, later alleged to be Cesc Fabregas.
Bloodgate: The events surrounding a faked injury to Tom Williams of rugby union side Harlequins in a Heineken Cup quarter-final against eventual champions Leinster in April 2009. Fake blood duped the referee into allowing Quins to send on a blood replacement, at the instigation of Quins coach Dean Richards. It was later admitted that Williams' mouth had been cut open immediately after the match in an attempt to cover up the fake injury. Richards was ultimately banned from rugby for three years.
Homeworkgate In 2013 during a tour of India, the Australia cricket team's South African coach Mickey Arthur instructed his players to write a presentation on how to improve the team following defeats in the opening two Tests. Vice-captain Shane Watson, Mitchell Johnson, James Pattinson and Usman Khawaja failed to do so and were all dropped for the next match. Watson left the tour, although returned later, while Arthur was sacked three months later.
Bladegate: In January 1994, top American ice skater Nancy Kerrigan was assaulted at the US National Championships in Detroit, her right knee clubbed with a metal baton after a practice session. Then it sensationally emerged the assault was a conspiracy hatched by Jeff Gillooly, the former husband of Kerrigan's ice dance rival Tonya Harding.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Former rap mogul Marion "Suge" Knight is suing Dr Dre, alleging that the hip-hop star and Apple executive hired hitmen to kill him.

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary

Knight alleges Dre was responsible for two attempts on his life.
And he claims Dre agreed to pay him 30% of his earnings for life, including his share of Apple's 2014 $3bn (Â£2.45bn) purchase of Dre's Beats products.
Dre's lawyers have dismissed the claims, saying he has had no contact with Knight for 20 years.
Knight and Dre were co-founders of Death Row Records.
Knight is currently in jail awaiting trial for murder. He is accused of running over and killing industry colleague Terry Carter in January 2015 in a car park in Los Angeles.
In the case filed in Los Angeles Superior Court, Knight said he had been defending himself as another man, filmmaker Cle Sloan, allegedly pulled a gun on him.
Several months earlier, Knight was shot seven times at a Hollywood nightclub in a party thrown by R&B singer Chris Brown.
The case, referring to Dre by his given name, alleges that "Andre Young is responsible for both crimes."
A lawyer for Dre told Rolling Stone: "Given that Dre has had zero interaction with Suge since leaving Death Row Records in 1996, we hope that Suge's lawyer has lots of malicious prosecution insurance."
Follow us on Twitter @BBCNewsEnts, on Instagram, or if you have a story suggestion email entertainment.news@bbc.co.uk.

this is part of a news article. represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

For example, '['Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence', 'Members of the public are being invited to express an interest in colourful beach huts on the Borders coast.\nScottish Borders Council recently got planning permission for 11 new buildings at Coldingham Bay.\nThe sites are owned by the local authority and then leased to tenants who can put up a hut.\nThere are currently 61 huts of various different colours constructed at Coldingham, some of which are believed to be about 100 years old.\nThe planning permission recently received also allows owners of the current beach huts to replace their facility, subject to conditions around style and colour.\nAn SBC spokesman said: "The successful block planning application was made by the council to allow owners to continue to display their individual tastes, while ensuring the huts conform to SBC\'s long-term plans for the site.\n"We would encourage anyone interested in acquiring a beach hut, or renewing their current hut, to get in touch."']' should be close to '['Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story', '.']'

Noel Lee, whose firm Monster helped launch Beats by Dre in 2008, says his company was betrayed and its technology "pirated".
He alleges he "lost millions" after Dre and Iovine "improperly took control" of Beats through a "sham" transaction.
After severing ties with Monster, Beats was purchased by Apple for $3 billion (£1.9 billion).
In legal papers filed in California, Lee alleges rap producer Dr Dre was barely involved in creating the headphones that carried his name.
But the range quickly became a highly desirable brand with celebrities and music fans, and Dre's endorsement was key to its success.
When the firm was sold to mobile phone manufacturer HTC in 2012, Dre and Iovine made $100m (£66m) each, Forbes estimated.
But Lee claims the deal forced him to cut his share in the company from 5% to 1.25%. He says he then had no other option but to sell his remaining stake for $5.5m (£3.6m) near the end of 2013.
His legal case describes the HTC deal as "fraudulent" and "a sham" intended to shift ownership of Beats to Dre and Iovine.
HTC later sold its shares back to the Beats.
Lee says if he'd still had his 1.25% stake, he would have received more than $30m (£19.8m) in the Apple deal.
His original 5% stake would have been worth around $150m (£99m).
A statement from Monster's law firm Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy says that Dr Dre and Jimmy Iovine "made millions off the work of Monster and Lee, while the plaintiffs lost millions".
There's been no response yet from Dr Dre's lawyer - or from Beats.
It's the second lawsuit against the firm since Apple bought it last year.
The first was brought by the Bose Corporation over patented technology for cancelling noise in earphones.
That case was settled under undisclosed terms in October.
Dr Dre and Jimmy Iovine are also being sued by David Hyman, who sold his music streaming service MOG to Beats in 2012.
That court case, filed shortly before the Apple deal was sealed, is taking place now in Los Angeles.
Jimmy Iovine is the co-founder of Interscope Records, a rap music pioneer that branched out to include acts like Lady Gaga and U2.
Follow @BBCNewsbeat on Twitter, BBCNewsbeat on Instagram and Radio1Newsbeat on YouTube


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article:

Question: More than 30,000 non-EU students a year have had their visas curtailed by the Home Office in the past three years, figures obtained by BBC News show.

represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary:

And 410 educational establishments had their licences to sponsor international students revoked in the same period.
The Home Office said it was cracking down on immigration abuse.
But the National Union of Students said international students were being "scapegoated" in order to meet targets on net migration.
The Home Office count incoming and departing international students when setting its targets on net migration, despite fears from some leading politicians that this risks harming UK universities.
The figures, released by the Home Office under Freedom of Information rules, show 99,635 students had their visas curtailed in the three years to the end of December 2015:
Of the educational establishments that lost their licences, there were
Some later had their licences reinstated - but, overall, the number of establishments holding them fell from 1,706 in 2013 to 1,405 by the end of last year.
In its response to the BBC's Freedom of Information request, the Home Office said it was unable to provide specific details of the types of institutions that had lost their licences.
But, in a statement, it said the revocations had been focused on "poor quality institutions".
During the period, no universities had their licences revoked - though a few had them temporarily suspended.
A Home Office spokesman said, since 2010, it had "cracked down on immigration abuse from poor quality institutions which were damaging the UK's reputation as a provider of world-class education, whilst maintaining a highly competitive offer for international students who wish to study at our world-leading institutions".
He said the strategy was working.
"Visa applications from international students to study at British universities are up by 17% since 2010, whilst visa applications to our elite Russell Group universities up by 39%," he said.
"We will continue to reform the student visa system to tackle abuse and deliver an effective immigration system that works in the national interest."
Where leave to remain is curtailed, individuals are given 60 working days' notice and "are encouraged to depart voluntarily", according to the spokesman.
"It they fail to do so enforcement action can be taken," he added.
But Dominic Scott, chief executive of the UK Council for International Student Affairs (UKCISA), said: "If these figures are correct, then they show that the Home Office's action against students has been even more draconian than previously understood.
"And many fear of course that it may have been more in pursuit of meeting a net migration target than addressing real abuse."
NUS international students' officer Mostafa Rajaai said the "shocking" figures were "clear evidence the Home Office is following a political agenda, rather than trying to remove real cheats".
"It has a clear disregard for the right to a fair trial and the past six years have seen the steady erosion of international students' rights within the UK," he said.
Mr Rajaai quoted NUS research suggesting most non-EU students thought the government was unwelcoming towards international students.
"If the government continues to scapegoat overseas students in order to hit its immigration targets, the damage to the UK's reputation as a desirable place to study will only worsen," he said.
"The only solution is for immigration targets to be scrapped completely."
According to official figures, 201,763 students applied for UK study visas last year.
These include:
According to an Office of National Statistics published in January, 192,000 international students arrived in the UK for long-term study in the year to June 2015 - down from a peak of 238,000 in 2010.
Most of this fall has been in further education, says the ONS, and is due to the tightening of immigration rules.

An oral question expresses concern about reports that the UK is "restrictively" applying the rules for gaining residence status.
Currently, the UK insists certain EU citizens must have personal health insurance in order to qualify as legally resident after three months.
It comes as many EU citizens apply for the permanent right to stay following the Brexit vote last year.
The requirement for health insurance applies to EU citizens that are not working, self-employed or qualify as looking or work. As such, students and full-time parents are among those most likely to be affected by the obligation.
The Home Office says that having the right to use NHS services does not count.
Although the requirement has existed for a number of years, a number of EU citizens say they were not aware of it.
While the Home Office does not remove people without insurance, it could hamper the ability of some to apply for permanent status.
EU nationals need to have lived lawfully in the UK, continuously for five years, to automatically get permanent residency rights.
For some, the requirement for "lawful" residence may include having personal medical insurance.
Conservative MP Sarah Wollaston is among those backing an online petition calling on the UK government to scrap the requirement.
However, the measure was upheld by the Court of Appeal after a case in 2014.
Among those pushing for a debate on the matter in the European Parliament is Dutch MEP Sophia in't Veld, who has previously said the rejection rate for residency applications in the UK is "completely unreasonable".
She is reportedly aiming to lead a group of MEPs who will investigate the experiences of EU nationals applying for permanent status and citizenship.
The Liberal Democrats claim that around 28% of permanent residency requests in the second half of last year were rejected or declared invalid.
The Home Office has denied that refusal rates have changed over the last year.
The European Parliament's civil liberties committee is also due to take evidence on the experience of EU citizens in the UK, as well as British nationals resident in other part of the EU.
You can watch the debate on Wednesday 1 March live on the BBC Parliaments online page.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: The stars of this year's Strictly Come Dancing have just been announced.

5 August 2017 Last updated at 09:08 BST
The professional dancers are already back in rehearsals for the 15th series of the show.
Ore Oduba was voted last year's winner and and lifted the glitterball trophy with his dance partner, Joanne Clifton.
Watch to see what advice he has to give to the new Strictly stars.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

She made the announcement on social media saying she had gone into the most recent series having decided it would be her last one.
She said this year's series had been her "best Strictly experience ever".
This series win was not her first.
She also won in 2011 with McFly's Harry Judd.
Aliona's been on the show for seven years.
Her previous partners include Rav Wilding, Matt Baker, Tony Jacklin and Gregg Wallace.
She had to pull out of the 2013 series after fracturing her ankle in training in rehearsals with dance partner Johnny Ball.
Vilani started ballroom dancing in Russia at the age of 11 and went on to study at the Broadway Dance Center in New York.
She moved to Los Angeles in 2006.
The professional dancers on the show are booked on a series by series contract, meaning no dancers are yet signed up for the 2016 series.
Ola Jordan, another Strictly dancer, has also  ruled herself out of future series too.
Jay and Aliona are taking part in the Strictly Come Dancing live tour which starts on 22 January in Birmingham.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: A builder has been cleared of killing his brother-in-law.

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article.

Adi Andrews, 46, was found at the bottom of a 13ft (4m) trench in Wormbridge, Herefordshire, on 22 October 2012.
Philip Parry, 51, had denied manslaughter, but pleaded guilty to breaches of health and safety regulations.
Mr Justice Popplewell directed the jury at Birmingham Crown Court to find Parry not guilty of manslaughter.
Parry, from Preston-on-Wye in Herefordshire, has been sentenced to 12 months in prison, suspended for two years after admitting failing to discharge his duties as an employer.
He was also given a curfew for four months and told to complete 100 hours of unpaid work.
Parry and his brother-in-law had been doing building work at the bottom of a trench on Whitfield Estate.

Michael Schallamach disappeared from Southampton, and police took the step this week of naming two convicted killers as murder suspects.
The 53-year-old's daughter Karen asked for help to enable the family to "bring him home and lay him to rest".
Kenneth Regan and William Horncy, who killed a family-of-five, are suspected of killing him.
Ms Schallamach said: "Whoever was responsible for his disappearance tried to cover up for their crime to create the impression he had just left us but we knew that wasn't the case, he would never have done that.
"He loved us and doted on his grandchildren who were forced to grow up without their grandfather around.
"We need to know what happened to him and where he is, so if it is possible, we can bring him home and lay him rest."
Hampshire Constabulary has said the disappearance of Mr Schallamach bears striking similarities to the murder of five members of the Chohan family, which Regan and Horncy were convicted of in 2005 and ordered to serve whole-life terms.
Mr Schallamach's wife Yvonne, received a letter from someone who claimed she had run off with the grandfather of two, which police regard as similar to a letter to business partners and family of Mr Chohan that suggested the family had fled back to India.
The last person to see Mr Schallamach alive, "by his own admission", was Kenneth Regan, police said.
Regan and Horncy murdered Armajit Chohan, his 25-year-old wife Nancy, their two young sons - 18-month-old Devinder and two-month-old Ravinder - and Mrs Chohan's 51-year-old mother Charanjit Kaur in a bid to steal his freight business and use it as a front for importing drugs.


Question: A street artist who painted several portraits of DJ Derek around Bristol has paid tribute to the 73-year-old.

Derek Serpell-Morris disappeared in July prompting high-profile campaigns by his family to find him.
Police confirmed on Wednesday remains found near Cribbs Causeway were that of the missing pensioner.
Artist Stewy said he chose to paint portraits of the the DJ around the city as he "symbolised multiculturalism and something positive about Bristol".
His final print of DJ Derek artwork will now be given to the family.
Stewy's first portrait of Derek Serpell-Morris was on the Star and Garter pub in July 2013, just before the DJ announced his retirement.
It has since been removed but there is another in Leonard Lane, painted in May.
The third, stencilled on a white gate in Richmond Avenue was made in February, when the DJ was still missing. Another tribute can be seen inside the St Werburgh's Farm pub.
Stewy said: "He symbolised something positive in Bristol, in embracing black music which people in his generation might have dismissed."
Stewy said there are no plans to create any more portraits of the popular DJ, as he did not want to profit from his death.
Instead, he is supporting local fundraising efforts to create a memorial mural of Mr Serpell-Morris which will be painted by the artist Inky.
DJ Derek, a former accountant, was known to thousands of music fans and played hundreds of sets at local clubs and pubs, as well as at the Glastonbury festival.
He was a resident of St Pauls in Bristol since 1978 and also appeared at gigs across the UK including the Big Chill, worked with Massive Attack and appeared in a Dizzee Rascal video.

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article.

DJ Derek, whose real name is Derek Morris, also appeared at the Big Chill and numerous gigs across the UK.
Avon and Somerset Police confirmed Mr Morris was reported missing on Thursday and a search for him is under way.
Mr Morris's niece, Jennifer Amy, said his disappearance is "completely out of character".
She said: "I've left numerous messages for him and he hasn't got back - if he goes away he always lets me know.
"His friends have been in touch to say he hasn't been in contact.
"We're all extremely worried."
And Bristol's elected mayor, George Ferguson, said on Twitter: "DJ Derek is a legend - I'll do all I can to spread word across #Bristol."
Geoff Barrow, from the band Portishead, has also tweeted his support while Bestival founder and DJ Rob da Bank hoped one of his "favourite ever" DJs would be found.
DJ Derek's disappearance is trending on the social networking site.
Mr Morris launched his DJ Derek career in his mid-30s after working in the accounts department of confectionery firm Cadbury's.
In 2006, he told the BBC's Inside Out that he left the firm after years of "domestic hell" before starting work as a DJ in a Bristol pub.
Over more than 40 years he established himself as a fixture on the city's clubbing scene.
As well as playing at Glastonbury, he has also released his own compilation album and appeared in a Dizzee Rascal video.
In 2012 he won the Lord Mayor's medal for his "outstanding" contribution to the music scene in the city.
Speaking to BBC Radio 4 after he was given the award, he said he finished most sets with the Bob Marley classic One Love.
He said: "It's a perfect signing-off record for a reggae set - let's get together and feel all right. So next time, people, let's get together and feel all right."
He played his final set before retiring at a London show in 2013.


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: A tout has been jailed for 24 weeks for trying to sell fake tickets to the Champions League final.

Pasquale Minichini, 35, from Naples, was spotted in Cardiff on Friday by an off-duty Italian police officer.
He was arrested after shouting "tickets" in the street and was caught with six fake tickets he was trying to sell for 1,000 euros (Â£870) each.
Minichini pleaded guilty to being in possession of an article for fraud at Cardiff Magistrates' Court.
He also admitted being an unauthorised person who attempted to sell a ticket.
Real Madrid beat Juventus 4-1 at Cardiff's renamed National Stadium of Wales on Saturday.
Prosecutor Edward Marsh said: "CCTV shows the defendant catching the attention of two males, showing them his mobile phone, then walking into the Money Shop.
"He was stopped coming out of the shop but left an envelope on the counter with six tickets in it. A lady came out from the shop and said that he had left them on the counter."
District judge Bodfan Jenkins said: "You came to this country, and to that game, in order to make money by selling fraudulent tickets at huge prices to people who would not have been able to gain access to the game."
Minichini, who was not involved in making the fake tickets, was also ordered to pay a Â£115 surcharge.

8 September 2016 Last updated at 11:45 BST
The former Manchester United footballer created a media storm after it was reported that he was drunk while being interviewed on live TV.


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: A Walkers crisps factory is facing closure, putting 380 jobs under threat.

Under the plan, production at the plant in Peterlee, County Durham would be moved to other sites in the UK, owner PepsiCo said.
It said the decision had been taken in an effort to find "crucial savings" and to ensure the long-term growth of the business.
Manufacturing managing director at the Peterlee site, Tracey Foster, said union consultations had begun.
In a statement, she said: "In order to improve the efficiency of our UK snacks manufacturing operations, we are proposing the closure of our factory at Peterlee.
"Crisps currently produced at the site would be manufactured at our other facilities in the UK.
"Peterlee has been an important site for our business but the changes we are proposing present significant productivity and efficiency savings crucial for ensuring the long-term sustainable growth of our business in the UK.
"We appreciate this is upsetting news for everyone at the Peterlee site.
"No decisions will be made without first consulting employees and their representatives. We would also like to reassure colleagues that we will be providing on-going support and assistance from this point onwards."
Labour MP Grahame Morris, whose Easington constituency includes the Peterlee factory, described the announcement as a "bitter blow" for East Durham.

this is part of a news article. represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

The Avana bakery in Rogerstone, Newport is to make the staff redundant by the end of November, the Bakers, Food and Allied Workers (BFAW) union says.
It comes just weeks after the site was bought by new owners Food Utopia from 2 Sisters Group.
There are around 552 people employed at the firm, with jobs under threat from earlier this year when a major contract was lost.
Unions say staff were told of the news at lunchtime.
"The company is looking to pick up business by launching its own products but this is a factory that has gone from 650 workers and a turnover of Â£55m down to around 140 workers and a much smaller turnover by the end of this year," said John James from the BFAW.
Rogerstone councillor Chris Evans has spoken to workers and he understands there will be significant job losses at the factory.
He said: "It's absolutely devastating news. Put simply this is a loyal workforce who deserve better."
South Wales East Conservative AM William Graham called on the Welsh government to hold talks with the firm, adding: "This news is hugely disappointing, particularly given the recent sale of the company."
Jobs have been at risk since February when the bakery lost a Marks and Spencer contract which was responsible for most of the site's production.
A Lancashire firm won the contract, ending a 77-year history with the Newport bakery.
Avana was set up in the late 1800s and used to have a bakery in Cardiff too, which closed when production was consolidated at Rogerstone.


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: All photographs Â© Internet Society / Panos Pictures.

To mark International Women's Day, photographers at Panos Pictures have teamed up with the Internet Society as part of the Shine the Light campaign to document women from 11 countries who are using technology to make things happen for their communities, families and themselves.
Here the women offer an insight into how they use technology to shape their lives.
Founder of ReDi School of Digital Integration, Berlin Peace Innovation Lab and Kids Have a Dream
"I studied peace studies for two years, looking specifically at innovation and technology, so how you can leverage the power of technology in order to create better collaboration between people, and ultimately come up with solutions that can be implemented to create a better society.
"I think peace is such a fluffy term to many people. And my question during my studies was, how do you make peace tangible?
"So if you could quantify peace by using technology, I thought that would be really interesting, and very helpful to come up, essentially, with the argument and the right data, that peace is more profitable than war.
"If we could show, in a very, very concrete financial way in financial terms, how peace is profitable, I hope that would lead to a much better society."
Human rights activist and social entrepreneur who founded ChunriChoupaal in Amsterdam, and the award-winning Community Technology Center for Women project in rural Pakistan
"I escaped a forced marriage in Pakistan, and one of the biggest reasons was because I was economically empowered. That's what I'm advocating for.
"It's very important for women, especially those who come from disadvantaged backgrounds, that they are economically empowered. And I think technology provides tremendous opportunities to be able to do that for women.
"It's just impossible to stay away from technology, because it's become such an integral part of our life now, and the fact that we are lagging behind and there are less women who are comfortable with technology, or less women in the technology field and into coding, that's really taking a toll on the whole of humanity."
International Women's Day has been held on 8 March every year since 1913, and has been recognised by the United Nations since 1975.
The UN says it's a time to reflect on progress made, to call for change and to celebrate acts of courage and determination by ordinary women who have played an extraordinary role in the history of their countries and communities.
The theme of this year's day is "Planet 50-50 by 2030" - aiming to achieve global equality in areas such as education and end all forms of discrimination.
'Little improvement' for women in work
Five images that reveal how women are treated
BBC Trending: Are Saudi women really that oppressed?
Why women can thrive in science-fiction
What will Michelle Obama's legacy be?
After training with AfChix (a network of African Women in Computer Science), she has experimented with digital design practices in Uganda and would like to move into app development
"I wasn't interested in web stuff, or computer stuff. But then my school was invited for the girls in ICT Day, and those ladies of Afchix Uganda  told us about their professions, how they were web developers and engineers. They said someone can do a mobile app that can change the world and that maybe, one day, I'll wake up and do the same thing.
"The reason I chose graphic design is that when I was young we used to watch cartoons like Power Rangers. And I was like, one day, I want to make my own animation. That's what I told my siblings. That's why I want to do graphic design, to make my dream come true."
A Finnish computer programmer, children's writer and programming instructor
"Computing, as an industry, is such a young field, that we're still building this body of work to explain and communicate it to the rest of the world. I think the very thing that I want to show is how coding can be as creative a tool as music or drawing or words.
"You create something out of nothing, with pure words and thought structures. Learning programming teaches you to look at the world in a different way.
"Our kids are going to live in a world where everything around them is a computer. One skill to navigate that world is definitely coding, but it's also about developing the imagination, attitudes and approach towards technology."
A change consultant in ICT in Mexico, working with groups such as Unicef on youth projects
"I was 10 years old when the computer arrived at my home, and basically that day, I started using the internet for hours at a time. This was in the 1990s, when parents didn't really care if you were spending too much time online, because they didn't understand what it was.
"And so I had, unmonitored, unrestricted access to the internet, maybe just filtered by how dial-up connections were at the time. And I just saw how my life truly changed because of that, because of the content I was exposed to, the friendships I made, how I learned about things that I would have never learned about otherwise.
"My aim is to give people working with youth the tools to use technology as a pretext to have more important conversations. So for example, sexual and reproductive rights organisations that teach people how to use condoms.
"Let's have a workshop where kids find out how a Wiki article is produced, and why the Wiki article on Aids might be totally difficult to understand for them, and understand how it came to be.
"Or how to assess results when you Google if you're pregnant or not, and how to take things with a grain of salt. Like you always tell people that they should be critical of information, so I want to give adults who work with youth special and concrete ways to give youth the tools to do that."
A multi-disciplinary Canadian artist and composer living in London
"I went to school for pure math and computer science, but even then, I was always really an artist.
"When I started studying math and computer science, I immediately started thinking about ways I could apply it to sound. Programming is like a secret power for me, that I can whip out and apply to my art in all sorts of ways."
An engineer in the Collaboration Technology Group at Cisco Systems
"My main advice would be to blaze your own trail.
"Don't assume that the only options available to you are kind of the ones that get pitched in the career fair brochure.
"That the main thing is to focus on what you like to do, what you're interested in, what makes you tick, and think about how your skill set can come together with those interests.
"And the technology industry is so dynamic that there are so many opportunities for anyone to blaze their own trail, that people should always think that's a possibility for them."
Responsible for the introduction of the internet to Thailand
"I had to leave my home town and had to move to the capital city, and then eventually move to another country for my education. So the moment I could see that my students could share resources with people in other countries, I was very happy, and I thought, 'This is means a lot for education.'
"My students will not have to travel that far, and can do whatever they'd like to do. At that moment I thought, 'The world's going to change.'"
A computer scientist, chief executive and founder of Openworld Ltd and founder of the regional organistion AfChix, a mentorship and capacity building initiative for women in computing across Africa
"When I was doing my first job I realised I was the only woman in the organisation at this time. So at one point, I kind of wished myself to find a girl that we could intern, just to make sure that I could see more girls in the workplace.
"And as I was thinking, 'Where are these girls, and why are they not joining this career?', I realised that it's about lack of information when making their career choices.
"So I just thought that maybe we could start to do some workshops to get awareness to the high school girls, that if you study computer science that is still a good point, and that will probably build you up well.
"I always tell girls, 'Even if you get into design, get into medicine, get into whatever it is, you're going to need some well-detailed computer skills. Whatever you want to be, you want to be a doctor, you want to be a lawyer, you'll need technology.'"
Animator and film-maker and founder of Respect Girls on the net, which campaigns to protect women and girls from harassment online
"My mom is an ICT teacher and my dad is an IT professional, so I was in touch with technology from the day I was born. I got to know about the world before my peers and how women were making change and it empowered me to go pursue my dreams.
"I want to be a film director to talk about social issues, through film. That's my dream now.
"Next week, I have a shoot about bullying. The Internet Governance Forum is happening in Sri Lanka, so we thought we'd do a short film at the same time. So it is about how a group of kids bully a girl through WhatsApp. It happens a lot here."
Founded Digital Rights Foundation and in 2015 was named in Time magazine's list of next-generation leaders, for helping Pakistani women fight online harassment
"Persevere. Stay at it. It's a field that has so many opportunities, but also so many frustrations that will come about because you're 'just' a girl.
"It's a field that has had women be involved in it from the get-go - Ada Lovelace, Grace Hopper, to name just a couple."
The Shine The Light campaign aims to highlight the work of women using technology via the hashtag #ShineTheLight.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: Muslim women in Cardiff have been offered self-defence classes over fears Islamophobia has been "normalised" since Brexit.

Women have reported being shouted at and spat at in the street and new figures show there was a rise in all reported hate crimes after the vote.
A gym in Canton is now offering women-only self-defence classes with a focus on hijab attack prevention.
South Wales Police said hate crime was "never acceptable".
The latest figures from South Wales Police show 2,466 hate crimes were reported to the force in the past 12 months.
This included a spike in July 2016 - the month after the EU referendum vote - but the figures have since fallen.
The Muslim Council of Wales claims the figures are the tip of the iceberg and says some women do not report hate crimes because they now consider the abuse a normal part of their lives.
Mohammed Alamgir, director of projects for the organisation, said hijab attacks - where headscarves are pulled - were becoming a problem in the city.
Mr Alamgir said: "For Muslim women it has become a normal part of their lives, to be attacked and belittled.
"A teenage girl was walking in Grangetown and a group of girls started name-calling, they pulled the back of her headscarf and dragged her to the floor.
"That is not acceptable. This is our country, this should not be happening in our city."
Haya Fitness gym in Canton has started self-defence classes after reports of Muslim women feeling too frightened to leave their houses after dark or on match days for fear of attacks.
The classes - open to all women who feel threatened by the increase in hate crime - teach them how to report verbal and physical attacks, as well as evasive manoeuvres if someone grabs them or pulls their headscarf.
One 27-year-old student, who moved to Cardiff with her family from Somalia when she was a teenager, says she is still shaken after being verbally attacked while getting on the bus.
She said the man, who has not been traced by police, ranted about Donald Trump and Brexit, and became more aggressive when challenged.
She got off the bus and waited an hour for the next one to avoid the man.
"It feels like it's normal for this to happen nowadays, but why?" she said. "Who said this is normal and why are we accepting it?"
"It's so scary walking down your own streets: every single time you go to town you look behind you and you're thinking someone's going to be there trying to tell me what they have seen in the news."
She reported the matter to the police but said she knows of other women who are too frightened of repercussions, gossip and nothing being done, to report incidents.
"Do I have to not stay late in the town? Do I have to not feel comfortable in my own headscarf or my own clothes even? It brings up tears... it is absolutely shocking," she said.
"Of course I'm going to report it: it could happen to my mum, my sister, my friend, it could be someone next door, it could be anyone tomorrow."
Another 20-year-old student was verbally racially abused as she walked through Caroline Street in the city centre with friends.
At the time she said they laughed it off, but she realises now she should have taken action.
"We get dirty looks all the time, muttering under the breath, it's so normal we don't even think twice about it," she said.
"Even if we were to report it, I don't think anything would be done - I mean how would they catch that person?
"Someone very close to me had alcohol poured on her, but she didn't report this, it was in Cardiff after a match, she had alcohol thrown on her and then racial abuse.
"She didn't report it, she didn't want to, just in case someone else found out and they began talking negatively about her.
"My dad says he doesn't want me going out after a certain time: it shouldn't be like that, we shouldn't have to tell the girls not to go out after a certain time, others should be educated on not harming them."
Counselling service Tell MAMA said women were more likely to be targeted by hate crime than men - due to wearing the hijab, abaya or niqab.
According to statistics complied by the service in 2015, 75% of all victims of Islamophobic hate crimes in England and Wales were women.
Director Imam Atta said: "Visible Muslim women are the ones that suffer anti-Muslim hatred and our work has also demonstrated that they are targeted mainly at bus stops, on public transport and at major train station hubs as people come and go from work."
South Wales Police said any kind of hate crime was a criminal offence and "never acceptable".
A spokesman added: "We believe that by taking action against perpetrators, supporting victims, and working in partnership, we can make the lives of those suffering from hate crime safer, protect their families, support the community, and prevent re-victimisation."

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary.

Activist Tess Asplund took part in a counter-demonstration during a Nordic Resistance Movement (NRM) rally in Borlange on Sunday.
She has been widely praised on social media, including by Harry Potter author J K Rowling, who has called her "magnificent".
Ms Asplund said she was "shocked" by the reaction.
The anti-racism activist told Swedish P4 radio station that her act was an impulse, as she thought the neo-Nazi demonstration should not be being held there.
Some 300 people attended the march. Others joined the counter-demonstration, many wearing clown costumes.
The picture, by photographer David Lagerlof, has been widely shared on social media and by newspapers and websites around the world.
Ms Asplund said it would be "great" if the photo made people pay more attention to the fight against racism and xenophobia but that she did not want to be seen as a symbol.
On Twitter, many users called her "hero" and "amazing". Others noted her "unbelievable bravery" and "courage".
A message of support from British author Ms Rowling has been retweeted more than 6,000 times and liked by more than 12,000 people.
Neo-Nazi movements have been on the rise in Sweden and other European countries as a result of the migration crisis. The anti-immigration Sweden Democrats Party is the third biggest political force in the country.
The country, which has a decades-old reputation for welcoming refugees and political asylum seekers, has introduced tighter border controls in an attempt to control the influx.
Alongside Germany, Sweden is one of the main destinations for migrants trying to reach Europe. Tensions there have been heightened by arson attacks on asylum centres and other cases of violence.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: A breed of dolphin usually found in deeper waters has been seen off the Mid Wales coast, a sea life charity says.

Cardigan Bay has one of Europe's largest semi-resident populations of bottlenose dolphins.
But the Sea Watch Foundation says a short-beaked common dolphin has now been seen from New Quay, in Ceredigion.
It says the smaller breed, with its yellow and white markings, usually gathers in groups in waters deeper than 164ft (50m).
Sea Watch Foundation - a UK-wide charity which monitors dolphins, whales and porpoises - said there had also been several sightings of the more commonly spotted bottlenose dolphins in the bay in March.
These were "likely to increase" into the summer as dolphins return to the sheltered bay with their young, the foundation said.
The charity's sightings officer, Kathy James, said: "Now is a great time to come to New Quay to observe its wildlife.
"You might get to witness some really interesting interactions between the two species."

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article!

8 December 2016 Last updated at 08:01 GMT
One place where they are quite common is off the Northumberland coast in northeast England.
But lots of seal pups have been dying there and no one knows why.
Now a new underwater study by scientists is hoping to find out what's going on.
Watch the brilliant footage of the seals' secret life underwater...


Question: Represent this text.

Question: Work to deliver access to superfast broadband to 40,000 homes and businesses is being delayed by the challenges of putting in fibre optic cables, BT has said.

The Welsh Government hopes to provide better internet to 96% of Welsh premises by the end of the year.
But BT said there were issues getting access to land or permission to dig in some areas.
The scheme is expected to cost more than Â£400m.
Superfast Cymru, which pooled Welsh and UK government money and EU funds, was set up because the commercial roll-out of superfast broadband only achieved 49% coverage.
It contracted BT to roll out the service but there are frustrations over "missed deadlines" and "broken promises".
Glyn Jones, of Pembrokeshire spring water company Princes Gate, said his firm had already been waiting 18 months and was running out of patience.
"It's something that we've been longing for for some time," he told BBC Radio Wales' Eye on Wales programme.
"We've had meetings with BTâ€¦ they seem to be full of promises as to when we'll have broadband.
"As a company we've given up waiting and we've leased our own superfast line. That will cost the businesses Â£1,000 a month between them.
"We can't have broadband hold us back as businesses."
BT Wales director Alwen Williams said the scale of the engineering challenges was "absolutely immense".
"Way-leaves have been - and continue to be - one of our most significant challenges - getting permissions to access the land that we need to access in order to lay the fibre cables.
"At the moment we have around 40,000 homes and businesses that are held up because we have a complex discussion or negotiation going on with various parties about how to gain access to land or permissions to dig, road closures."
But Julie James, minister for skills and science, said the Welsh Government was "frustrated" with information given out by BT.
"I meet BT quarterly to discuss the progress of SFC and we have long and involved conversations there about exactly what information could be on the website," she said.
"In fact the government took over the website last summer, as a result of that, and we've improved the website dramatically so now it's a lot more accurate in terms of whether you're going to get it and when you're going to get it.
"Nobody wants to be at the end of the programme. But we have assured people that we will get to them."

Dozens more towns and villages are due to be connected by 2016, as many firms say they are still missing out.
The Welsh government says it is on target to see fast internet available for 96% of premises under its £425m Superfast Cymru venture with BT.
In June 2014 superfast broadband was available in 58% of premises in Wales, compared to 78% across the UK.
Deputy Minister for Skills and Technology Julie James said: "By the time the Superfast Cymru programme is completed in spring 2016, Wales will be one of the most highly connected countries in Europe."
Ann Beynon, BT Director for Wales, said: "This is big news for Wales as people will now know when work will start for every single telephone exchange in Wales.
"It's probably the biggest engineering programme Wales has seen in the last ten years with the potential to improve the lives of individuals, families and businesses across Wales."
Broadband makes a major difference for businesses particularly those in rural areas.
It can mean more sales for some and helps farmers provide the information they need to file with government departments.
But many businesses say they are not benefiting from faster speeds.
Critics argue that converting telephone exchanges does not mean every firm will get faster broadband, as cabling from the exchanges to the premises will not necessarily support it.
Just under half of the spend - £205m - is coming from the Welsh and UK governments and European funds, with BT providing the rest.
Superfast Cymru is listing exactly where and when exchange work will take place. However, homes and businesses will still need to sign up with an internet service provider once the optical fibre network has reached their neighbourhood.
Communications regulator Ofcom reported in August that while Wales was catching up in the rollout of superfast broadband, the number of people signing up for it still lagged behind the rest of the UK.
Meanwhile, the Wales Audit Office is reviewing whether the project is delivering effective value for money.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: A new £18m rollercoaster ride at Alton Towers remains closed after a piece fell off the structure.

Forty-eight people had to be rescued from the 14-loop ride, called The Smiler, on Sunday.
A spokesperson from the amusement park said a small piece of debris had allegedly fallen from the track.
"The health and safety of our guests is our primary concern [and] the ride will remain closed whilst the resort's technical team investigate," they said.
Staff are working to reopen the ride as soon as possible.
The Smiler - which includes a drop of 30m (98ft) - opened in May.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence:

The Sky Swing had to be closed three times in December 2014.
During one incident 12 customers were stranded on the ride for 30 minutes. The emergency services put the ride into recovery mode and brought them all down safely.
Sayers Amusements, which owns the attraction, said they would put up a giant ferris wheel instead.
A spokesman said: "After there were some issues with the Sky Swing last year, it was decided that it would be best to change the ride this year.
"The giant wheel is still a spectacular ride which gives amazing views over Cardiff."
The funfair opens on Thursday and runs until 3 January.


Question: represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: Paris Saint-Germain and Ivory Coast defender Serge Aurier has been praised after "saving the life" of Mali forward Moussa Doumbia on Saturday.

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary:

After Doumbia was knocked unconscious in a challenge with Sunderland's Lamine Kone, Aurier intervened to stop the Rostov player swallowing his tongue.
Mali's manager Alain Giresse added that he spoke to Aurier after the game to thank him for his "superb reactions".
Ivory Coast went on to win the home 2018 World Cup qualifier 3-1 in Bouake.
"All the players realised that Doumbia was choking and was about to swallow his tongue," Giresse told French radio station RMC.
"That's when Aurier, with one of our players, quickly put him on his side and pulled out his tongue, because he was about to lose his life."
However, Aurier later caused controversy by making a throat-slit gesture towards the crowd after his side's third goal.
The celebration was the latest in a string of incidents involving the full-back.
In September, he was sentenced to two months in jail for elbowing a police officer, but remains free pending an appeal.
And in February, he was suspended by Paris St-Germain after appearing to use homophobic language to insult then-coach Laurent Blanc.
He had also called team-mate Angel di Maria a "clown" as he answered questions from fans on social media app Periscope.

Tiote, 30, who was a member of the Elephants squad that won the 2015 Africa Cup of Nations, collapsed and died during a training session with his Chinese club last week.
On Tuesday there was a memorial service held in the Chinese capital, attended by family, friends and former team-mates.
The BBC understands that Tiote's family wants him buried in his home town Yamoussoukro but the Ivory Coast Football Federation prefers Abidjan.
Hundreds of people, including former Elephants coach Herve Renard, were at Abidjan's international airport to receive Tiote's body on Thursday.
Manchester City striker Wilfried Bony, Celtic defender Kolo Toure and ex-Arsenal forward Gervinho were also among the crowd.
Toure described the former Newcastle United midfielder as "a great player, a warrior" and said he was "shocked" by his death.


Question: represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story!

Question: Members of Muirfield will have another vote on whether women can be admitted to their club.

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary

Last year's vote followed a two-year consultation process and fell short of the majority required to change membership policy.
Motions require a two-thirds of its eligible voters to back the move and only 64% voted in favour.
Details of a new ballot are expected within the next two weeks with a decision expected in early March.
The May motion fell 10 votes short of admitting female members and the Scottish venue was told by organisers the R&A it would not stage another Open Championship as a result.
Muirfield announced in June it wanted to hold a fresh ballot.
Run by The Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers, the privately owned links course last hosted the Open in 2013.

represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary!

Stewart Streit, 81, is the only player to win the British, Canadian, US and Australian women's amateur titles, and Bell, 79, was a Curtis Cup captain.
In September 2014 the Royal and Ancient voted to allow women members for the first time in its 260-year history.
In February, the Princess Royal became one of the first women to join.
Along with Stewart Strait and Bell, a further eight women have also become members of the club.