Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: California firefighters have continued to battle wildfires, which have scorched more than 11,000 acres and caused thousands to flee.

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary!

There were 13,000 new evacuations in San Marcos on Thursday evening.
Meanwhile, two teenagers were arrested on suspicion of starting two brush fires in San Diego's Escondido area.
The pair have not been linked to the larger fires that have destroyed 18 homes, caused $20m (Â£12m) in damage and claimed at least one life.
A badly burned body was found in Carlsbad, about 30 miles north of San Diego, on Thursday.
San Diego County Sheriff Bill Gore said investigators looking into what has caused so many fires since Tuesday will consider arson as a possibility.
Schools across the region were closed and a nuclear plant and a military base were earlier evacuated.
Months of drought have made California particularly prone to fire this year, and the crews managing the evacuations and battling the blazes have had to contend with sweltering heat.
But calmer winds on Thursday allowed aircraft - including four air tankers and 22 military helicopters - to be deployed to fight the flames.
On Friday, officials said five wildfires had been entirely contained and another was 90% contained.
More than 1,000 firefighters are now turning their attention to three other major brush fires, including two on the Camp Pendleton Marine Corps base.
Another large fire was threatening the San Diego suburb of San Marcos. That fire has grown to more than 3,000 acres (1,200 ha) and was only 10% contained, the state department of fire protection said.
They are actually fairly common in intense wildfires. Here's the science: Fires obviously generate a lot of heat, and heat rises. Heated air rises even faster when surrounded by relatively cooler air on the edges of major fires, and vortexes can form in particularly strong updrafts. If those vortexes contain flame, you've got yourself a firenado.
Read full article in Slate
The Legoland theme park in Carlsbad was closed due to power surges, while San Onofre nuclear power plant briefly evacuated non-essential staff as a precautionary measure.
And the campus of California State University-San Marcos, with almost 10,000 students, was shut down amid the university's final exams.
There have already been 1,400 wildfires across the state this year, twice the usual number.

Damin Pashilk, 40, faces 17 counts of arson and is suspected of involvement in numerous other fires in Lake County over the past year.
The massive Clayton Fire began on Saturday evening and has been fuelled by fierce winds.
It has wiped out whole blocks in the working-class town of Lower Lake.
It is 5% contained and poses a risk to 1,500 additional structures, said the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (Cal Fire).
Over 1,600 firefighters are battling the blaze that has left dozens of families homeless in the town 130km (80 miles) north of San Francisco.
In Lower Lake, houses have been razed by the flames, with only their brick chimneys still standing. Burned out hulks of vehicles litter the blackened landscape.
News of Mr Pashilk's arrest was greeted with gasps, cheers and applause at a community meeting at a casino being used to house evacuees.
He is from the nearby town of Clear Lake, said reports.
"The residents of Lake County have experienced senseless loss and endured significant hardship over the past year," Cal Fire Chief Ken Pimlott said in a statement.
"Mr Pashilk committed a horrific crime and we will seek prosecution to the fullest extent of the law."
The blaze is one of two dozen major wildfires raging across the US West, which have taken hold amid a five-year drought and high temperatures.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: Hibernian made a "pathetic and totally unacceptable" start as they lost 3-2 to Aberdeen in the Scottish Cup semi-finals, said manager Neil Lennon.

Adam Rooney gave Dons the lead after just 12 seconds, and Ryan Christie struck the second on 25 minutes.
Grant Holt, 36, headed Hibs' first and set up Dylan McGeouch's leveller, but Jonny Hayes' shot deflected in off Darren McGregor for Aberdeen's winner.
"I needed a 36-year-old to come on and get us playing," Lennon said.
"He was brilliant. We scored two fabulous goals and then we're in the ascendancy. They got a huge slice of luck with the third goal.
"The first 30 minutes was pathetic and totally unacceptable. It's nothing to do with tactics or formations, it's to do with decision-making and individual errors."
Media playback is not supported on this device
Lennon accused some of his players of "hiding" and "not taking responsibility".
"We didn't deserve to lose the game but you can't give a team like Aberdeen a two-goal head-start," he said.
"Anything can happen once it gets back to 2-2. It just wasn't our day, but I'm not happy with the way we approached the game.
"Gallant losers are losers."
Lennon, who has led his side to the Scottish Championship title, admitted holders Hibs had been "caught cold" as Rooney scored following a mistake by McGregor.
"Darren has a lapse in concentration," Lennon told BBC Scotland.
"Aberdeen haven't worked to score three goals. The first two goals are unforgiveable.
"They've got loads of character but they shouldn't have to fight back in the first place.
"They'll go away with loads of regret. They were as good as Aberdeen if not better.
"I felt we were good enough and had the players to go to the final and beat Aberdeen and it was certainly in evidence today for long parts of the game. "

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary.

The Guinea-born Frenchman, 26, was with Cercle Brugge in Belgium last season and previously played in France.
Richie Foran's Inverness have yet to register a point in this season's Scottish Premiership and have been knocked out of the League Cup.
They host St Johnstone in their fourth league game of the season on Saturday.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: BBC Sport's football expert Mark Lawrenson is pitting his wits against a different guest each week this season.

this is part of a news article. represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

Example:
Provided: "['represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence\n\n\nE.g. The 37-year-old Irish rider was badly hurt when his mount Galaxy Rock fell at the first fence in the Fulke Walwyn Kim Muir Challenge Cup.\nRacing was delayed for 30 minutes as McNamara was airlifted to Frenchay Hospital in Bristol.\nDr Adrian McGoldrick, chief medical officer for the Irish Turf Club, said the jockey would have scans overnight.\nHe explained: "JT has suffered a serious neck injury.\nJT, or John Thomas, McNamara is a leading Irish amateur rider who has been a winner four times at the Cheltenham Festival before, including when guiding Teaforthree to victory in the National Hunt Chase last year.\nHe won the same race in 2002 on Rith Dubh, was successful in the Cross-Country Chase with Spot Thedifference three years later and won the 2007 Fox Hunter Chase on Drombeag.\n"He is being looked after at the regional spinal unit but as yet he is still waiting for a scan."\nMcNamara was conscious after the fall but had difficulty breathing and was placed into an induced coma, said McGoldrick.\nHe added the jockey was placed on a spinal board as a precaution.\nFellow jockey AP McCoy told BBC Radio 5 live: "It\'s a dangerous sport and it\'s a sight that you see that unfortunately crops up; we\'re very lucky we have excellent medical care. We just hope he\'s going to be OK."\nMcNamara was thrown to the ground after his mount, trained by Jonjo O\'Neill, fell at the first fence in the sixth race of the Cheltenham Festival\'s third day.\nThe jockey, from Limerick, was injured in a steeplechase for amateur jockeys only.\nMcNamara finished fourth on Galaxy Rock in the Kim Muir at the Festival two years ago.\nGalaxy Rock was reported to be unhurt.\nAlso on Thursday, the David Pipe-trained racehorse Matuhi suffered a serious spinal injury and was put down after falling at the last fence in the Byrne Group Plate.\nEarlier, jockey Davy Russell was taken to Cheltenham General Hospital with a punctured lung, which rules him out of riding leading contender Sir Des Champs in the Gold Cup on Friday.\nThe 34-year-old, who rode the horse to victory at last year\'s festival, was injured in a fall from Un Beau Matin at the last in Wednesday\'s Coral Cup.\nHe had the injury drained in hospital and took up his first two rides on Thursday, but the problems resurfaced and Russell returned to hospital. == Amateur jockey JT McNamara has suffered a serious neck injury in a fall at the Cheltenham Festival.', 'The Office for National Statistics said that the slower pace in the January-to-March period was due mainly to the service sector, which sank to 0.3% growth against 0.8% at the end of 2016.\nIn the last quarter of 2016, gross domestic product increased by 0.7%.\nFriday\'s figure is a first estimate and could be revised in the coming months.\nEconomists had been expecting GDP growth to slow as consumers reined back spending in the face of rising inflation, but they had pencilled in a higher figure of 0.4%.\nChris Williamson, chief economist, IHS Markit, said: "The message is clear: the start of the year saw the weakest pace of growth for a year as rising prices have started to hit household spending."\nThe main drag on the service industry, which accounts for about 78% of the UK economy, came from the hotels, restaurants and the distributions sector, which fell by 0.5%, as increasing prices from rising inflation applied the brakes to retail trade,\nThe ONS said that output in the construction sector was also dragging on GDP after expanding by 0.2% in the first three months of the year following 1% growth in the fourth quarter of 2016.\nIndustrial production expanded by 0.3% over the period, with manufacturing increasing by 0.5% thanks to a jump in motor vehicle output, while agriculture growth eased to 0.3% in the first quarter from 1% in the final quarter of 2016.\nConsumers have been feeling the pinch since the beginning of 2017, with inflation sitting at its joint highest level for more than three years at 2.3% in March.\nThe squeeze on household spending power has led to weaker retail sales, which recorded their biggest fall for seven years in the three months to March.\nNancy Curtin, chief investment officer at Close Brothers Asset Management, said the data would add to uncertainties.\n"With the General Election just around the corner and Brexit negotiations afoot, any dip in the economy risks bringing further caution and uncertainty to businesses, which has a knock-on effect when it comes to investment and employment.\n"However the chancellor, with better than expected Budget tax receipts in his pocket, has room for manoeuvre and should be able to pre-empt any further slowdown which should help with business confidence," she said.\nSuren Thiru, head of economics at the British Chambers of Commerce, said the data confirmed his group\'s own survey that businesses were starting to feel the pressure.\n"It is increasingly likely that the slowdown in the first quarter is the start of a sustained period of more sluggish growth. Inflation is expected to continue to rise, increasing the squeeze on consumer spending power and firm\'s profit margins, pushing growth lower," he said.\nDespite the service sector slowdown, other economists pointed to more positive signs.\nLee Hopley, chief economist at EEF the manufacturers\' group, that "even with the pace of expansion dropping, we shouldn\'t be too hasty in dialling up the despair about the outlook for the UK economy.\n"There are clearer signs that the consumer is wavering as inflationary pressures have picked up, but the production related sectors of the economy are forging ahead thanks to an improving global picture and the more competitive pound.\n"Manufacturing also saw another solid quarter with output increasing by 0.5% and official data indicating that this positive trend was fairly broad based across sub-sectors."\nThe caution among consumers was underlined on Friday in separate figures from the British Bankers\' Association. These showed British banks approved the fewest mortgages in four months in March and consumer credit growth slowed.\nBanks approved 41,061 mortgages for house purchase last month, down from 42,247 in February, the BBA said. Annual consumer lending growth slowed to 6.1% from 6.5% in February, easing further from October\'s 10-year high of 7.2%.\nOn the face of it today\'s preliminary growth estimate is unadulterated bad news. The slowdown was especially sharp in services - the sector that represents four fifths of the economy.\nWithin that sector, it was retail slamming on the brakes. Normally, fuelled by cheap consumer debt, retail spending is the accelerator.\nIf you\'re a pessimist, this is proof that the gloomy Brexit predictions are coming true. The drop in the pound drove up the cost of imports and that\'s feeding through to rising inflation (latest figure is 2.3%). Compare that with pay rises (latest figure is 2.2%). The squeeze on living standards is back and so is the tight-fisted consumer.\nIf you\'re an optimist though, it\'s only the worst growth since "early 2016". As a shocking statistic, that\'s pretty underwhelming. And we\'ve been told for years that the sickness that caused the economic crash was an imbalance - an over-reliance on consumer spending and an under-reliance on productive industry. Now, manufacturing is growing, with the automobile sector - stimulated by a weak pound - driving it. To a pessimist, the weak pound is a sickness. To an optimist it\'s the cure.']" Match: "['represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details', 'The UK economy grew by just 0.3% at the start of the year, the slowest growth rate since the first three months of 2016, according to official figures.']"

Lawro's opponent for the midweek Premier League fixtures is The Coral frontman James Skelly.
After a five-year break the Merseyside band have a new album coming out and and are about to start a UK Tour.
Rehearsals before they hit the road meant Liverpool fan Skelly had to miss a trip to Wembley on Sunday to watch the Capital One Cup final.
"I had a ticket but it was the last day I had to sort everything," Skelly told BBC Sport. "So I had to watch on telly instead."
Liverpool's form has been inconsistent since Jurgen Klopp took charge in October but Skelly believes he will get things right.
He added: "I like Klopp a lot. He is a class manager, everyone knows that.
"It is going to take him a bit of time because he has an imbalanced squad but if we had our best team out all the time, we would probably be challenging for a top-four place now.
"It is really refreshing to hear him talk and he is passionate too. I sometimes sit right behind him in the main stand at Anfield, and I just end up watching him if the game is rubbish."
Skelly's best moment as a Liverpool fan was the 2005 Champions League final when they came back from 3-0 down at half-time to beat AC Milan.
"It has to be Istanbul," he explained. "Me and my mate tried to leave at half-time but we were locked in.
"Instead we just thought we would eat a load of choc-ices and eat the pain away but as we celebrated goal after goal we lost the choc-ices and ended up waving the sticks in the air. It would have made a great choc-ice advert actually."
Our scoring system has changed this season and a correct result (picking a win, draw or defeat) is now worth 10 points. The exact score earns 40 points.
Last week, Lawro got five correct results from eight Premier League games, with no perfect scores. He also incorrectly backed Liverpool to win the Capital One Cup
His score of 50 points saw him beat Nobby Butcher - aka Sacha Baron Cohen, who picked two correct results but no perfect scores for a total of 20.
Lawro and Nobby can still pick up extra points for their predictions for the Premier League games which were postponed at the weekend because of the Capital One Cup final - Liverpool v Everton and Newcastle v Man City.
Make your own predictions now, compare them to Lawro and other fans and try to take your team to the top of the leaderboard by playing the BBC Sport Predictor game.
All kick-offs 19:45 GMT unless otherwise stated
Lawro's prediction: 0-2
James's prediction: I think Everton are going to smash them. 0-3
Match report
Lawro's prediction: 2-1
James's prediction: 1-2
Match report
Lawro's prediction: 1-1
James's prediction: 3-1
Match report
Lawro's prediction: 0-2
James's prediction: 0-2
Match report
Lawro's prediction: 2-1
James's prediction: 1-1
Match report
Arsenal are my tip for the title but they were so disappointing in their defeat by Manchester United on Sunday.
The Gunners have so many good players but they are such a strange team - every time you think they will kick on, they throw in a performance like that.
Media playback is not supported on this device
Swansea put up a good fight against Tottenham and Lukasz Fabianski made some great saves to keep them in it, but they still lost and it is hard to see them getting anything at Emirates Stadium.
To have any hope of winning the title, Arsenal quite simply have to win.
If they don't, for whatever reason, their fans are going to have a real moan. Even if they do, there are going to be a lot of people doubting the Gunners ahead of Saturday's north London derby.
Lawro's prediction: 2-0
James's prediction: 2-0
Stoke are going well - previously they struggled a bit for goals but on a good day they have now got more than one match-winner, which makes a big difference.
Newcastle, who remain in the relegation zone, have not had a game for 18 days and have been at a training camp in Spain.
This is not the game they need right now and I just do not fancy their chances at the Britannia Stadium.
Lawro's prediction: 2-0
James's prediction: 1-1
A lot of people are looking at Tottenham and thinking they can win the league - and they probably think they can themselves as well.
But this is a tough game for them because West Ham are not just a skilful side, they are very strong too.
Lawro's prediction: 1-1
James's prediction: I want West Ham to win but Spurs are on a roll. 1-2
This game comes three days after Manchester City beat Liverpool on penalties in the Capital One Cup final and I don't see Jurgen Klopp's side getting much in the way of revenge.
Media playback is not supported on this device
Firstly Klopp must decide what kind of team to put out, but City manager Manuel Pellegrini has to put out another strong side because he cannot afford to drop any more points.
It is no coincidence that City play well when the spine of their team - Vincent Kompany, Yaya Toure, David Silva and Sergio Aguero - are fit and in form.
Just like at Wembley, Liverpool's first task is to stop City. Too many of the Reds players went missing in the first half at Wembley, and they cannot afford to let that happen again.
Lawro's prediction: 1-1
James's prediction: I said before Sunday that whoever wins the League Cup will lose this game, and I obviously hope that is the case now. I could never back against Liverpool anyway though. 3-2
The goals have started flowing for Manchester United again, and they have 11 in their last three games - although eight of them were against Shrewsbury and FC Midtjylland.
I think Watford will be a tougher nut to crack defensively and they will also look to hit United on the break, so they will cause Louis van Gaal's side some problems.
Lawro's prediction: 1-2
James's prediction: United are having a difficult time but Liverpool fans are not really in a position to be laughing at anyone at the moment. At least we are used to being pretty rubbish, while it is a whole new thing for their supporters.
Also, we can see there is a clear plan for us under Klopp now - things are a lot more uncertain for United but, if they get Jose Mourinho as their next manager, then they will have a couple of decent seasons. 2-2
Lawro was speaking to BBC Sport's Chris Bevan.
* Does not include score for postponed games
Lawro's best score: 160 points (week 19 v Guy Mowbray)
Lawro's worst score: 20 points (week one v Graeme Swann & week 23 v Ice Cube and Kevin Hart)

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

Lawro picked the winner in two of the four quarter-finals and six of the eight last-16 ties.
He enjoyed a 42% success rate in the group stage, correctly guessing the outcome of 15 of the 36 games.
The only group he failed to get a single result in was Group F, which saw Hungary and Iceland spring a surprise by finishing first and second.
Before the tournament Lawro chose 11 of the 16 teams that went through to the first knockout stage, including France, his pick to win the tournament on 10 July.
Along with more than 375,000 of you, Lawro is taking part in the new BBC Sport Predictor game. He is going head-to-head with pundits, presenters and commentators from across BBC Sport. He's doing well, though he's not top as things stand:
You can make your own predictions and take on your friends and other fans using the BBC's Euros Predictor.
Lawro was speaking to BBC Sport's Chris Bevan.
Match report and highlights
Lawro's prediction: 1-1 (Wales to win on penalties)
Match report and highlights
Lawro's prediction: 0-2


Question: The company constructing the new £330m Aberdeen Exhibition and Conference Centre has reported a surge in profits and turnover in its 50th year.

represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary

Stirling-based infrastructure and construction group Robertson said pre-tax profits climbed 81% to £21.4m in the year to March.
It also reported record turnover of £453m.
Robertson said there had been "continued and sustainable" growth across its 19 operating companies.
Construction and house building were among several businesses to perform particularly well.
It also expanded its offering in building services, civil engineering and rendering and roofing.
Robertson, which was founded in Elgin, currently employs nearly 2,000 people across the UK, having increased employee numbers by more than 600 in the past 18 months.
It expects its headcount to grow by a further 5% in the year ahead.
Group turnover in England has grown to a record level of £100m as part of the company's ongoing regional growth strategy.
Robertson said it had seen "major success" in the growth of its Partnership Homes business, which had now secured contracts to deliver over 2,500 homes over the next five years in Scotland.
Robertson Homes also reported growth in private housing development, increasing the number of units sold in the year by 65%.
It has started new developments in Dunbar, Strathaven and Mid Calder in Central Scotland and is currently operating on eight live sites.
Chairman Bill Robertson said: "We are delighted with the continued progress across all of our 19 operating companies.
"The group has now started delivering on its new five-year strategic plan with a strong focus on sustainability, innovation and productivity.
"The continued success of the group will be based on generating sustainable and appropriate margins for any work undertaken."

The six-month project at Havelock Europa is expected to "follow the wealth", where market opportunities arise in the UK and globally.
The Kirkcaldy-based firm also wants to extend its sourcing operation in China and grow further in Australia.
The company has already focused its marketing efforts in London.
Office refurbishments in the capital are among Britain's more lucrative opportunities.
The firm has been through a difficult corporate turnaround in recent years.
In announcing its full-year results, the Fife firm said 2016 was "challenging".
Havelock Europa was back into the black, with pre-tax profits of £183,000, following a 2015 loss of £2.7m.
Revenue was down in 2016, largely due to the loss of a major financial client, believed to be Lloyds Banking Group.
Sales fell from £73m in 2015 to £61m.
In trying to diversify its clients away from a few large banks and education refurbishments during academic holidays, the company is seeking to secure more clients from the health sector and student accommodation.
It is also looking for a wider range of retail clients, which have so far included big high street names such as Marks & Spencer, Primark, Accessorize and House of Fraser.
Havelock Europa employs 300 people at its Fife factory and marketing base, with offices also in China and Mansfield in the English Midlands.
The company's shares fell 12% in the hours after the annual results were published.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story!

Question: This week my eldest daughter announced she was moving out.

At the age of 23, she had found a flat-share she could afford. A wave of sadness swept over me - our family unit was crumbling. But, like many parents, I also felt a sense of relief that she had finally found a way out of the nest.
My wife and I both said goodbye to our respective parents well before our 21st birthdays and to us, there is something almost odd about still sharing a home with your mum and dad after your education is complete.
We learn today, though, that a quarter of all 20-34 year-olds in the UK still live with their parents. According to analysis of census data by the Office for National Statistics, since 1996, the number of young adults still at home with their mum or dad has increased by 25% to 3.3 million.
In some parts of Britain, the proportion is far greater. In Northern Ireland, a third of 20-34 year-olds are living with parents, compared to London and Yorkshire where the proportion is just 22%.
Britain's living habits appear to be changing - becoming more southern European, perhaps. While in Scandinavian countries, children tend to leave home by the age of 20 or 21, in Italy, Greece, Slovakia and Slovenia it tends to be late 20s for daughters and above 30 for sons. In Bulgaria, most men are still living at home at 35.
So what is going on?  In Britain, the biggest increase is found among 20-24 year-olds - 49% of that age group still live at home. One obvious reason for that is housing affordability - the ratio of house prices paid by first-time buyers to their incomes is now 4.4, up from 2.7 back in 1996.
Millions of parents will recognise the problem of a child in their late teens or early 20s unable to afford to buy or even to rent a home in some parts of the country. Certainly with my children, finding a decent and affordable place to live in London has proved immensely difficult.
But there are other reasons why young adults are not flying the nest as they once did. The big increase in the figures coincides with the economic downturn. The proportion of young people (18-24) who are unemployed has risen from 13% in 2008 to 19% last year. Without a job it becomes much harder to make that big move into the wider world.
Among 20-34 year-olds who live with their parents, 13% are without a job. Among those who live independently, it is 6%. Austerity more generally has meant that young adults may choose to study at a college or university close to the parental home, avoiding expensive accommodation costs.
Men are more likely than women to still be living at home in their mid to late 20s. For every 10 women, 17 men aged 20-34 are still shacked up with their parents. The main reason is that women tend to form partnerships with men older than they are - so more in the 20-34 age group are married or cohabiting.
I do wonder whether there is also a tendency for young people generally to settle down in a relationship later in life. More people go to university now and students are likely to wait until after their education before getting married or agreeing to cohabit.
Lifestyles may be changing, but Britain is far from unusual.  Of the 28 countries in the European Union, only six have a lower proportion of 25-34 year-olds living with their parents than the UK.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence.

This is the full statement to the inquests from his sister, Evelyn Mills:
Peter McDonnell was born on 9 February, 1968. He was the oldest of four children, namely, Patricia, Evelyn and Gerard, born to Gerard and Lillian McDonnell.
He was cherished and, even at the age of 21, when he died, Peter was still fondly known as 'our baby'.
He was always an inquisitive child, who loved to learn. He never played with toys; just tools. He spent many weekends and summer holidays at the Liverpool Museum, learning about dinosaurs and fossils, to the amusement of siblings, as he felt it necessary to share all the facts that he had learned.
As the baby of the family, he was spoiled by our parents and our siblings. He would fall asleep on the couch and get carried to bed because he didn't like to be on his own.
Profiles of all those who died
He would often find his way into the end of somebody else's bed in the middle of the night, even up to the age of 14.
The house was always well stocked with his favourite things - cornflakes, Kit Kats, bacon, mushrooms - a habit that proved hard for our mother to break, even after his death.
As a child, Peter went to St Finbar's Nursery School and on to St Francis of Assisi Primary School and then on to St John Almond Secondary School. It was at school that he became interested in sports, swimming and playing football.
He used to play with his brother Gerard for the Vale FC, a local team. Before joining Vale FC, he played for a team in Garston. He also played for his school team.
Peter went to his first football game with his cousin, John Cooper, who was a steward at Liverpool. As we could not afford to pay for tickets, he went to quite a few games with John.
He even went to Wembley with him one year. When he was 19, John told him he could be his second in command on the coach.
Peter played football with our brother, Gerard, for the local team, which still holds an annual cup game in his memory and awards the Peter McDonnell cup at their presentation evenings.
Peter supported Everton until the age of 11, when he changed teams to Liverpool Football Club because of Gerry.
When he started going to watch football matches by himself, he used to go with one of his best friends, Paul, who was also an Everton supporter. This meant that they went both to Everton and Liverpool games together, supporting each other.
His teachers commented that he was always a pleasant and willing student who was good with his hands. This was evident at home as he regularly took things to bits and put them back together.
Gerard saved up for a watch once and, after he bought it, one day he came home from work to find that Peter had taken it apart. He told him he just wanted to see what it was like inside and he would put it back together.
Even until the day he died, he was still taking things apart. There is still a Walkman that remains in pieces at our home.
His passion was making things and building. He went to Old Swan Technical College and left with a City and Guilds Foundation in construction, studying industrial, social and environmental studies, industrial skills and practices, technology and science and communication studies.
He also completed a youth training scheme in Riversdale College, learning bricklaying, tiling, plastering and joinery.
After qualifying, Peter worked for several local builders and also travelled to South Wales to gain some building experience with his uncle. He aspired to have his own business and was eager to learn to drive so that he could get a van.
I gave him an IOU for driving lessons towards his 21st birthday present. He never got to use it.
As work dried up during the recession, he made his way to London to try and find employment. He got very homesick and would return home to visit, with regaling stories of what London was like and how there were homeless people living in Euston Station.
On one such visit he returned to London with several old coats to give to the homeless as he was passing through the station. He was away from home for around six months and, whilst working in Southend-on-Sea, his friend was injured and they both returned home.
At the time of his death, he had just secured a contract with Cruden Building & Construction, where Peter was employed at the time of his death.
Peter was an outgoing, fun-loving person who always had lots of friends. He enjoyed socialising, going to the cinema, fishing, playing basketball and he loved music and was always going to see live bands.
One of his favourite artists of the time was Peter Gabriel and he saved up to go and see him in concert.
You knew when Peter was in the house. He was always lively and full of fun. He did impressions and joked about everything. He made everyone laugh.
He was very close to his nieces. My daughter, Gemma, and I remained at the family home until Gemma was four years old before moving across the road, and Peter would take her to nursery and look after her for me whilst I was at work.
He was really protective of her and she took his death very badly.
He was also godfather to Patricia's daughter, Rachel. I remember Rachel was terrified of bare feet and every weekend at our house Peter would come down the stairs with no shoes on and she would scream.
He used to tease her, but she was scared stiff. She still says that she can hear his feet coming down the stairs to this day.
Every Saturday, Patricia would bring her three daughters to visit and Peter would play games with his nieces, having tea parties and giving piggyback rides.
After his death, Peter has gone on to have nephews and great-nephews.
Peter made a mark on people wherever he went. After he died, the house was never empty. Friends and neighbours came to pay their respects and stayed even after we had retired for the night. He was loved and he is severely missed.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: Metal thefts from schools in Torfaen have left the county council facing an £86,000 repair bill.

Lead panels were stolen from the roof of West Monmouth School in Pontypool on 31 December causing the ceilings to collapse on the IT suite and art rooms and damaging student's exam work.
Henllys Church in Wales School and Croesyceiliog Comprehensive, both in Cwmbran, were targeted in November.
Torfaen said it was a "massive waste of council resources".
Council leader Anthony Hunt said the latest attack was "devastating for pupils" who returned after the Christmas break to find their hard work ruined.
The council has CCTV footage of the most recent incident which they have passed to the Gwent Police.
Mr Hunt said: "This is not the first time we have faced this problem in Torfaen and the roofs have all been treated with SmartWater, which has previously helped the police to trace and prosecute individuals.
"We have also replaced a lot of lead with substitutes, so thieves could end up with something that is worthless to them."

represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

The Department for Transport money will be given to the county council in two instalments with £3.3m in 2013-14 and £1.75m in 2014-15.
Harvey Siggs, from Somerset County Council, said initial repair costs were already over £1m, including £100,000 which had been spent on emergency repairs and storm damage clean up.
He added the council had also spent about £375,000 on road repairs.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: US President Barack Obama has apologised to the president of aid agency Medecins San Frontieres (MSF) for a bombing that killed at least 22.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

The US has said the bombing, which took place in the Afghan city of Kunduz, was a mistake and it was attempting to strike the Taliban.
MSF wants the bombing to be investigated as a war crime.
Mr Obama has also apologised to the president of Afghanistan.
"If it is necessary to hold individuals accountable, that will be done," said White House spokesman Josh Earnest.
Mr Obama "expressed his condolences" to MSF president Joanne Liu, said Mr Earnest.
"In the United States when we make mistakes, we're honest about it. We own up to it," he said.
Mr Earnest also hinted at the possibility of paying victims and their families, a Department of Defense policy.
He said he could not say legally whether the bombing was a war crime but the US "goes to great lengths to limit the loss of life" of civilians.
In a statement, MSF said they received the apology but it was still demanding the International Humanitarian Fact-Finding Commission (IHFFC) investigate.
MSF has said it would not trust internal military inquiries into the bombing.
The IHFFC was set up in 1991 under the Geneva Conventions.
MSF says the co-ordinates of the hospital were well-known and its bombing could not have been a mistake.
A number of inquiries have been ordered - by the US justice department, the Pentagon, Nato and an American-Afghan team.

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article:

The first, which occurred around 22:30 (19:30 GMT) on Monday, hit part of the facility in Saada province that was not being used, according to the charity.
All staff and patients had been evacuated by the time the second strike hit about 10 minutes later.
However, the Saudi-led coalition battling Yemen's Houthi rebel movement denied that it had bombed the hospital.
Asked by the Reuters news agency if he knew what had caused the blasts, spokesman Brig-Gen Ahmed al-Asiri said: "We cannot tell without investigation."
Gen Asiri has previously said the coalition has destroyed every fighter jet in Yemen.
The conflict in Yemen has left more than 5,600 people dead, including 2,615 civilians, since the coalition air campaign began in late March.
About two-thirds of the civilian deaths were caused by coalition air strikes, and the rest by the rebels and their allies, the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) said on Tuesday.
More than 15,000 people wounded in air strikes and fighting on the ground have been treated in MSF-supported hospitals in the past seven months.
The charity's hospital in Saada's Haydan district served 200,000 people and was the only life-saving facility in the region, receiving 150 emergency cases a week.
An MSF statement said that all staff on duty and two in-patients managed to escape between the first and second air strikes on Monday night.
The facility's director was slightly injured during the evacuation.
After visiting the site on Tuesday morning, MSF's project co-ordinator in Saada, Miriam Czech, said: "I was not able to go inside as we believed there were remaining bombs that have not exploded, but I can confirm that the facility is 99% destroyed."
The facility's director said that only the x-ray department and staffroom remained.
"It could be a mistake, but the fact of the matter is it's a war crime," MSF country director Hassan Boucenine told the Reuters news agency.
"There's no reason to target a hospital. We provided [the coalition] with all of our GPS co-ordinates about two weeks ago," he added.
This is the second attack this month on an MSF facility.
On 3 October, US aircraft bombed a hospital in the Afghan city of Kunduz, killing at least 22 people.
MSF has demanded an independent international investigation into the bombing, which it says was a war crime. The US has said the hospital was bombed by mistake and President Barack Obama has apologised.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: A teenage girl was assaulted while she walked home from school in Warlingham.

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article.

The girl was pulled to the ground and attacked in Chelsham Road at 16:45 GMT on Friday.
Her attacker was described as white, aged between 16 and 18, 6ft tall, with brown hair, pale skin and a square-shaped face.
Insp Dan Gutierrez, from Surrey Police, urged parents to remind their children to keep safe when they are out an about.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

The men, aged 51 and 24, were detained on Friday. A 25-year-old man who was arrested on Thursday has also been released.
Mr McKay, who was 36, was shot dead at his home on the Longlands Road last month. His funeral took place on Friday.
At least two armed men were involved in the attack.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: All pictures are copyrighted.

A selection of your pictures of Scotland sent in between 24 February and 3 March. Send your photos to scotlandpictures@bbc.co.uk or our Instagram at #bbcscotlandpics


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: Ten-man West Ham twice came from behind but Charlie Austin's injury time penalty gave Southampton their first victory under Mauricio Pellegrino.

Having failed to score in their last six home matches, Saints took the lead after only 10 minutes when Manolo Gabbiadini side-footed past Joe Hart.
West Ham's problems then spiralled, as Marko Arnautovic was sent off for elbowing Jack Stephens, before Dusan Tadic made it 2-0 from the penalty spot after Jose Fonte brought down Steven Davis.
Summer signing Javier Hernandez thought he had snatched an unlikely comeback for the visitors with two goals from close range either side of half time.
But the Hammers conceded a second penalty when Pablo Zabaleta bundled into Maya Yoshida and substitute Austin coolly slotted past Hart.
Referee Lee Mason had some important decisions to make throughout the dramatic match at St Mary's - and he got most of them right.
Mason was left with little choice but show a straight red to Arnautovic on 33 minutes, after the Hammers' record signing needlessly raised his elbow into Stephens' neck. The Austria international later apologised to the fans for his dismissal.
The first penalty was also an easy one to give, as former Saints defender Fonte pulled down Davis, but the second spot-kick in the 91st minute was a more contentious matter.
Zabaleta caught a rising Yoshida in the back, as he went to head the ball from close range, and Mason decided the Hammers defender had impeded his Southampton counter-part.
West Ham had earlier had a handball appeal against Stephens waved away, while the referee did not punish Mark Noble for his rash challenge on Saints midfielder Mario Lemina, who was making his debut following his £18.1m move from Juventus.
Before facing the Hammers, Southampton had not scored on home soil since 5 April - 576 minutes of football.
They had 29 shots against Swansea last week, landing only two on target in their goalless draw, so there was a collective sigh of relief around St Mary's when Gabbidani slotted home after Nathan Redmond's through ball.
Saints were only able to score from open play once during the match, but Gabbiadini and Redmond both went close with long-range efforts.
Substitute Shane Long had the ball in the net in the second-half but referee Mason had already blown for a foul on goalkeeper Hart in the build-up.
Media playback is not supported on this device
With their home ground out of use until next month following the athletics World Championships, it was always going to be a testing start to the season for West Ham.
They started their run of four consecutive away matches with an embarrassing 4-0 defeat against Manchester United last weekend, but put in a much-improved display at St Mary's - even after going down to 10 men.
Hernandez, who arrived for £16m from Bayer Leverkusan, lived up to his reputation as a potent poacher with his first two goals for his new club.
The Mexico international tapped in West Ham's opener after Fraser Forster parried Michail Antonio's shot into his path, and did the same again for his second goal - this time after Diafra Sakho's header came off the woodwork.
Boss Slaven Bilic said of his new striker: "We knew what we were getting with Hernandez: a really great player, great character, team player, really enthusiastic.
"You're expecting goals from him but on top of the goals, his determination; he sacrificed for the team in the best possible way."
While Hernandez looks to have settled in well, on-loan goalkeeper Hart still looked nervous at times and his confidence may be dented further after conceding seven goals in two matches.
Media playback is not supported on this device
Marko Arnautovic posted a message on social media after the game: "I want to apologise to all of the West Ham fans. Just want to let you know that I didn't want to let me team down and you fans. A big apology to you all."
West Ham manager Slaven Bilic on Arnautovic's sending off: "It is a big blow because you have to play with 10 men for a big part of the game. We have spoken about everything and that will stay inside the dressing room."
Southampton manager Mauricio Pellegrino: "It was a difficult game because we had everything under control after a sending off and two goals. This is football.
"West Ham are a strong team and they won a lot of balls in our box. It was a nice game to see, but difficult for a manager to be in."
Southampton host Wolves in the EFL Cup on Wednesday (19:45 BST), before returning to league action against Huddersfield on Saturday, 26 August (15:00 BST).
West Ham are also in EFL Cup action on Wednesday at League Two side Cheltenham Town (19:45 BST) before travelling to Newcastle on Saturday (15:00 BST).
Match ends, Southampton 3, West Ham United 2.
Second Half ends, Southampton 3, West Ham United 2.
Goal!  Southampton 3, West Ham United 2. Charlie Austin (Southampton) converts the penalty with a right footed shot to the centre of the goal.
Pablo Zabaleta (West Ham United) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
.
Penalty Southampton. Maya Yoshida draws a foul in the penalty area.
Penalty conceded by Pablo Zabaleta (West Ham United) after a foul in the penalty area.
Corner,  Southampton. Conceded by José Fonte.
Attempt blocked. Nathan Redmond (Southampton) left footed shot from outside the box is blocked. Assisted by James Ward-Prowse.
Foul by Ryan Bertrand (Southampton).
Joe Hart (West Ham United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Dusan Tadic (Southampton).
Mark Noble (West Ham United) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Attempt blocked. Mark Noble (West Ham United) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked.
Foul by Nathan Redmond (Southampton).
Pablo Zabaleta (West Ham United) wins a free kick on the right wing.
Corner,  Southampton. Conceded by Pedro Obiang.
Attempt blocked. Oriol Romeu (Southampton) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked. Assisted by James Ward-Prowse.
Substitution, Southampton. Shane Long replaces Steven Davis.
Substitution, Southampton. Charlie Austin replaces Manolo Gabbiadini.
Attempt missed. Nathan Redmond (Southampton) right footed shot from outside the box is close, but misses to the left. Assisted by Steven Davis.
Foul by Maya Yoshida (Southampton).
Diafra Sakho (West Ham United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Nathan Redmond (Southampton) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Foul by Pablo Zabaleta (West Ham United).
Attempt missed. José Fonte (West Ham United) header from the centre of the box misses to the right. Assisted by Mark Noble with a cross following a set piece situation.
Foul by Nathan Redmond (Southampton).
Pablo Zabaleta (West Ham United) wins a free kick on the right wing.
Substitution, West Ham United. Pedro Obiang replaces Declan Rice.
Foul by Manolo Gabbiadini (Southampton).
Chicharito (West Ham United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Goal!  Southampton 2, West Ham United 2. Chicharito (West Ham United) right footed shot from the left side of the six yard box to the top left corner.
Attempt saved. Diafra Sakho (West Ham United) header from the centre of the box is saved in the top centre of the goal. Assisted by Aaron Cresswell with a cross.
Attempt missed. Diafra Sakho (West Ham United) header from the centre of the box misses to the right. Assisted by Chicharito with a cross.
Foul by Steven Davis (Southampton).
Diafra Sakho (West Ham United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Corner,  Southampton. Conceded by Aaron Cresswell.
Attempt missed. Oriol Romeu (Southampton) left footed shot from outside the box misses to the right. Assisted by Nathan Redmond.
Substitution, West Ham United. Edimilson Fernandes replaces André Ayew.
Substitution, West Ham United. Diafra Sakho replaces Michail Antonio.

However, the draw did extend Chelsea's lead at top of the Premier League to nine points.
Liverpool keeper Mignolet made up for his first-half embarrassment when he was beaten by David Luiz's superb free-kick from 25 yards.
Georginio Wijnaldum's close-range header in the second-half gave Liverpool a draw they fully deserved, ending a run of three home losses in a row.
However, it could have been much better for Chelsea and worse for Liverpool when Costa went to ground 14 minutes from the end.
Referee Mark Clattenburg pointed to the spot but Mignolet dived low to his right to save the Spain striker's spot-kick.
Arsenal 1-2 Watford: Arsenal's Premier League title hopes suffered a huge blow with a shock home defeat as Watford secured their first top-flight win over the Gunners since 1988.
Bournemouth 0-2 Crystal Palace: Crystal Palace finally earned a Premier League victory under Sam Allardyce as goals by Scott Dann and Christian Benteke secured the points against Bournemouth away at a rain-swept Vitality Stadium.
Burnley 1-0 Leicester City: Burnley secured their fifth home Premier League win in a row with victory over Leicester at Turf Moor, thanks to Sam Vokes' late goal.
Middlesbrough 1-1 West Bromwich Albion: Middlesbrough came back from a goal down but were left frustrated as a hard-working West Brom claimed a point at the Riverside Stadium.
Swansea City 2-1 Southampton: Swansea boosted their Premier League survival hopes and secured back-to-back wins for the first time this season with a spirited victory over Southampton.
Sunderland 0-0 Tottenham: Title-chasing Tottenham had to settle for a point at the Stadium of Light as Sunderland climbed off the bottom of the table with a hard-fought draw.


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: Jordan Spieth shot a six-under-par 64 to sit one behind joint first-round leaders Danny Lee, Sergio Garcia and Johnson Wagner at the Byron Nelson.

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary:

Dustin Johnson, Freddie Jacobson and Tom Hoge are also tied for second at the four-round event in Texas.
England's Greg Owens and Ian Poulter are joint 28th on three under par.
Spieth dropped six shots in three holes as Danny Willett won the Masters in April, missing the cut at the Players Championship in his next outing.
The 22-year-old Texan, who won the US Open and the Masters last year, said: "I lost a little control with my iron play on some pretty easy shots that I will look to improve on but other than that I'm pretty pleased."
Spieth made his PGA Tour debut at the 2010 Byron Nelson, finishing tied for 16th aged 16.
We're launching a new BBC Sport newsletter before the Euros and Olympics, bringing all the best stories, features and video right to your inbox. You can sign up here.

Former US Open champion McDowell, 36, is tied ninth after a four-under 67.
Leonard, 43, is in a four-way tie for the lead on six under with fellow Americans Derek Fathauer and Shawn Stefani and Australia's Aaron Baddeley.
Russell Knox, who won in Shanghai last week, and fellow Scot Martin Laird are both five shots off the lead.


Question: represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: All pictures are copyrighted.

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article!

A selection of your pictures of Scotland sent in between 7 and 14 April. Send your photos to scotlandpictures@bbc.co.uk or our Instagram at #bbcscotlandpics


Question: represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Former BNP voters who feel "swamped" by immigrants are turning to UKIP as a "decent" and "non-racist" alternative, UKIP's deputy chairman has said.

Former Tory MP Neil Hamilton said "quite a few" people who voted BNP in the 2009 European elections had switched sides.
BNP leader Nick Griffin accused Nigel Farage's party of stealing its slogans and rhetoric.
UKIP is on course to top the poll in May's Euro elections, says a survey.
UKIP recorded 31% support in the YouGov research for the Sunday Times, three points ahead of Labour, with the Conservatives in third on 19%.
It put the Liberal Democrats on 9%, the Green Party on 8% and the BNP, which gained 6.2% of the vote in the 2009 European elections, on 0%.
It is the first time YouGov has given UKIP, which campaigns for Britain's exit from the EU, the lead in the race to top the poll at the European elections on 22 May. Most previous polls have given the advantage to Labour by a few percentage points.
Earlier in the week when YouGov showed people pictures of UKIP campaign adverts, branded "racist" by some critics, the majority disagreed they were racist, and 57% agreed with Mr Farage's claim the adverts were a "hard-hitting reflection of reality".
BNP leader Nick Griffin, who is standing for re-election to the European Parliament in the North-West of England, blamed what he claimed was biased reporting by the BBC for the collapse in support for his party, as well as the rise in support for UKIP.
"They (UKIP) are using all of our rhetoric, they are using our slogans, they are recycling our posters and people like it," he told BBC Radio 5 Live's Pienaar's Politics.
"The only difference is that UKIP won't deliver."
He said that unlike UKIP, which favours a reduction in immigration, the BNP's policy was to "shut the door - we don't want anyone, black brown, green or white".
UKIP came under fire earlier this year over its European election slogan "Love Britain, Vote UKIP", which is similar to a BNP slogan - Nigel Farage responded by saying it was "our slogan now".
The party has also faced a storm of criticism over a local council candidate, William Henwood, who suggested on Twitter that actor and comedian Lenny Henry should emigrate to a "black country".
Mr Henwood, who is standing in a council election, made the comment on Twitter in response to a speech by Henry in which he said ethnic minorities were under-represented on British television.
But Neil Hamilton, who has been a senior figure in UKIP for some years and is standing as a local council candidate, said all parties had activists "who may have said something unpleasant on social media".
He claimed Mr Griffin's comments "demonstrated that the BNP is a racist party and UKIP isn't".
But he agreed that UKIP was taking votes off the BNP, claiming "a lot of decent people" who were not racists had voted BNP in the past "out of desperation".
"They feel their communities are being swamped by immigrants from outside, whether they are from Eastern Europe or from other parts of the world.
"Now those people, the decent supporters of the BNP, from the last election, who weren't true BNP supporters at all, I am sure that quite a few of them are voting for a respectable alternative, which is UKIP."
Nigel Farage told The Guardian on Saturday that his party had taken all the votes it was likely to gain from Conservative supporters in the South of England and was now targeting Labour voters in the north, with the aim of pushing Ed Miliband into promising a referendum on Britain's membership of the EU.
But former Labour cabinet minister Peter Hain said: "I don't think Farage's success, which it's likely to be in a few weeks time, is going to affect Labour on the referendum at all."
He told the BBC's Andrew Marr show UKIP's rise had been "mainly at the expense of the Tories" but they were also "hoovering up" support from voters who were "fed up" with conventional politicians.
Green Party leader Natalie Bennett said her party was fighting the European elections as the anti-UKIP party.
"UKIP is the party of fear, saying be fearful - vote for us.
"We're saying hope for a better society, a society that works for the common good - so vote Green for that."
Lib Dem peer Dame Olly Grender said UKIP needed to be put under more scrutiny by the other parties, who she claimed were not taking the European elections seriously enough.
"I think what it (the European election) says about us as a nation is critically important and I think that UKIP are getting away with absolute murder," she told Pienaar's politics.

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article.

Anne Marie Waters, a former Labour activist and founder of the Sharia Watch pressure group, has previously called Islam "evil".
Her leadership bid has split the party, with some MEPs threatening to quit if she was allowed into the race.
But the UKIP National Executive Committee, which vets all would-be candidates, has allowed her to stand.
The other candidates to replace Paul Nuttall - who stood down after UKIP's poor performance in June's general election - are:
Voting papers will be sent to party members over the next few weeks and the new leader will be announced at the party's annual conference in Torquay on the 29th and 30th of September.
Ms Waters's leadership bid was backed by former English Defence League leader Tommy Robinson and she has previously been blocked from standing as a UKIP election candidate.
James Carver, UKIP West Midlands MEP, said he "sincerely hoped" Ms Waters did not win - but added that she should be allowed to stand.
He said: "Her train of thought, I think is going about it the wrong way... there are many British Muslims in this country and that is a good thing."
The party's former leader, Paul Nuttall, has previously said her views made him "uncomfortable".
Ms Waters believes her anti-Islam message, including a proposed ban on the burka, the closure of all sharia councils and a temporary freeze on all immigration, will strike a chord with many voters.
She has argued that UKIP could regain support if it had the "guts" to be "honest about Islam" and challenge the view that it had "nothing to do" with jihadist violence.
Last month, former leader Nigel Farage told BBC's Sunday Politics that "if UKIP goes down the route of being a party that is anti the religion of Islam, then frankly it's finished".


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Geraint Thomas is vowing to battle on in the Tour de France after riding through a second consecutive stage with a fractured pelvis.

Represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary.

The double Olympic gold medallist suffered the injury in a crash in the opening stage on Saturday.
The Team Sky rider is lying in 194th place after Monday's third stage, nearly 27 minutes behind leader Jan Bakelants.
"I've been better," Thomas admitted after completing the stage in Calvi.
"Simon Gerrans did a great job to get the stage win. It was Daryl Impey who led him out and they got it absolutely perfect. The sprint was so close. Without that team support Gerrans would not have won.
"Mark Cavendish was not around to contest the finish and he did not take the intermediate sprint that seriously earlier in the day. He has expressed an interest in the green jersey but Peter Sagan and Marcel Kittel have got a big buffer on him now in the points category which is going to take some overhauling.
"At the back of the race, Geraint Thomas rode very bravely with a fractured pelvis. Team Sky's head of business operations Fran Millar says they are going to stop telling people to 'man up' and tell them to 'gee up' instead. It's a nice little phrase and very apt.
"I'm no doctor but I don't imagine any pain can be coming from the fracture itself because, if so, you just could not ride a bike. The pain is probably coming from all the tissue around it. So with any luck, after three or four days he might start to feel better and be able to get through this race."
Listen to BBC Radio 5 live's stage three podcast
The fracture was revealed by an MRI scan on Sunday after initial X-rays had shown no injury.
"It explains a lot, because yesterday was one of the worst days I've had on bikes," said Thomas.
"But I've done so much to lose weight and get fit for this and I'm not just going to give up straight away.
"The experts said it's not going to get any worse, so we'll give it a few days to see if the pain goes down, then we'll see.
"I'm definitely going to give it a good go.
"My mum doesn't want me to, but it's the Tour, it's not your average race, and I'm definitely going to keep fighting."
Thomas started stage three in last place and finished nine minutes 15 seconds behind stage winner Simon Gerrans - a result that lifted the Welshman two places in the general classification.
However, he is unlikely to be of help to Team Sky in the team time trial in Nice on Tuesday.
But team principal David Brailsford was full of praise for Thomas's efforts.
"We all have different tolerances to pain but the determination and level of suffering required to ride on a course like this, with its twists and turns where you can never get into any kind of rhythm, was really considerable," he said.
"He suffered an awful, awful lot - he deserves every bit of recognition and support for his suffering."
Thomas himself summed up his day in a matter of fact manner: "It felt a lot better today than yesterday and it felt a lot better than it did at the start," he said.
"I can feel it slowly getting better, but I've got a crack in the bone [so] I guess it's always going to hurt a bit isn't it?"

He is just the eighth rider to win the race at least three times and is just two behind joint record holders Jacques Anquetil and Bernard Hinault of France, Belgium's Eddy Merckx and Miguel Indurain of Spain.
The 2013 and 2015 champion took the race lead with a victory on stage eight and held on to it for the next 13 stages to win in Paris.
This is how the race unfolded.
Report: Cavendish wins to wear yellow for first time
Mark Cavendish produced a sensational sprint to claim his 27th Tour de France stage win and put himself in the yellow jersey for the first time. Coastal cross-winds did not create too much havoc on a day when one of the race favourites, Alberto Contador, crashed heavily but escaped with bruises. Defending champion Chris Froome was anonymous for much of the day, which is just how he would have wanted it.
Report: Sagan claims first yellow jersey with stage win
A solo break by Jasper Stuyven came within 500m of producing an upset but he was caught with the finish line in sight. Peter Sagan battled with Julian Alaphilippe on the run-in and the Slovak world champion emerged victorious, although he did not initially realise he had won the stage. Chris Froome and Nairo Quintana finish together but Alberto Contador and Richie Porte lose time.
Report: Cavendish edges out Greipel to draw level with Hinault
A photo finish was needed to split Mark Cavendish and Andre Greipel in Angers. The German looked to have won the stage but a late lunge from the Manx Missile saw him nick it by millimetres on the line. The victory was Cavendish's 28th Tour stage win, pulling him level with French legend Bernard Hinault and joint second on the all-time list behind Eddy Merckx on 34. Peter Sagan retained the race lead as the favourites for the overall win all finished together.
Report: Cavendish misses out as Kittel wins thrilling finish
For the second stage running, a photo finish was needed to decide the winner, and this time it was German Marcel Kittel holding off Frenchman Bryan Coquard by millimetres on the line. Peter Sagan retained the yellow jersey by finishing third and Mark Cavendish remained on 28 stage wins as he came eighth. Chris Froome and his overall rivals finished safely with the same time as the winner.
Report: Van Avermaet takes five-minute Tour lead
Belgian Greg van Avermaet was the sole survivor of an early breakaway as he conquered the first mountain stage of this year's Tour to take the yellow jersey. Defending champion Chris Froome dropped more than five minutes behind Van Avermaet, but remains level with his main rivals for the title.
Report: Cavendish secures 29th Tour stage win
Mark Cavendish earned a 29th career stage win, taking him above Bernaud Hinault to second outright in the overall Tour standings, after a thrilling sprint finish. The Manxman rode on the back of Marcel Kittel's wheel to beat the German to the line, also picking up the green jersey. Britain's Daniel McLay finished third, with Belgian Greg van Avermaet remaining in yellow.
Report: Cummings takes brilliant second Tour win
Steve Cummings formed part of a breakaway on the first stage in the Pyrenees to earn a brilliant solo victory and a fourth win for British riders in this year's Tour and for the Dimension Data team. Britain's Adam Yates fell foul of a collapsed inflatable marking the 1km to go point, while Greg van Avermaet produced a solid display to stay in yellow.
Report: Froome launches surprise attack to win stage and take yellow
After a quiet start to the Tour, defending champion Chris Froome exploded into this year's race by launching an unexpected attack on the descent into the finish at Bagneres de Luchon. Team Sky set up the win with a grinding surge up the Col de Peyresourde but Froome surprised his rivals by sprinting down the other side, edging fellow Briton Adam Yates into second place in the overall standings.
Report: Dumoulin breaks clear to take stage win as Froome retains yellow
On a day of contrasting weather, Dutch rider Tom Dumoulin was one of a big group to break free of the peloton in scorching temperatures. He attacked on the final descent of the first mountain-top finish of the Tour in pouring rain to earn his first Tour de France win. Chris Froome withstood several late attacks from his yellow jersey rivals to come through the day unscathed. Adam Yates stayed second in the general classification.
Report: Matthews sprints to victory as Froome enjoys easy day in yellow
Australia's Michael Matthews achieved a first Tour win thanks to a breakaway masterclass from his Orica-BikeExchange team-mates.  Matthews beat the more isolated Peter Sagan to the line, although the Tinkoff rider took over in the green points jersey from Mark Cavendish. Chris Froome enjoyed an easy day in yellow as the main contenders gained no advantage.
Report: Sagan wins after unlikely break with Froome
The expected bunch sprint in Montpellier failed to materialise after Peter Sagan and Chris Froome took advantage of cross winds to break clear in the final 15km and take a one-two on the stage. Both riders benefited with Froome extending his lead over Adam Yates and Nairo Quintana by 12 seconds, while Sagan moved 90 points clear in the green jersey classification.
Report: Froome gets running after chaotic finish
It was one of the most remarkable days the Tour de France had seen in its 113-year history.
With the stage reaching the final moments, Richie Porte crashed into a motorbike, bringing Chris Froome and Bauke Mollema down with him, after the trio had escaped their yellow jersey rivals. Froome, with his bike unusable, started to jog towards the finish line, before being given a replacement bike, but could not get his cycling shoes into the pedals. The defending champion finally received a new bike, but finished down on his rivals. The times were eventually neutralised, meaning Froome kept hold of the yellow jersey. Thomas de Gendt won the stage having been part of an early 13-man breakaway.
Report: Froome increases lead as Tour pays tribute to Nice victims
Tour de France organisers had considered cancelling the stage after Thursday's attack in Nice that killed at least 84 people. But racing continued, with heightened security and in a sombre atmosphere, as a minute's silence was held before and after the stage.
On the road, Chris Froome extended his lead in the yellow jersey to one minute and 47 seconds, after finishing second in the time trial behind Dutchman Tom Dumoulin.
Report: Cavendish wins 30th career Tour stage
Mark Cavendish's excellent Tour continued as he won his fourth stage his year - taking his career tally to 30, just four short of Eddy Merckx's record. Cavendish upset rival Marcel Kittel, who believed he was cut up by the Manxman on the way to the finish line, but the result stood.
It was a more relaxing day for the general classification contenders, with Chris Froome finishing in the peloton and maintaining his lead of one minute 47 seconds in the yellow jersey.
Report: Froome maintains lead as Pantano wins
At the end of a stage considered one of the Tour's most difficult, overall leader Chris Froome went surprisingly unchallenged across the Jura Mountains and maintained his lead of one minute 47 seconds ahead of his closest rival, Dutchman Bauke Mollema. Briton Froome knows it will now take something special to prevent him winning a third Tour title.
Colombia celebrated its first stage win of the 2016 Tour, with Jarlinson Pantano (IAM Cycling) outsprinting Poland's Rafal Majka to claim his maiden Grand Tour stage win.
Report: Sagan claims third win as Froome stays in yellow
Peter Sagan beat Alexander Kritstoff in the third photo finish of this year's race to earn a third stage win. The victory also ensured that if the Slovak can make it to the finish in Paris, he will hold onto the green jersey for a fifth consecutive year. Chris Froome finished safely after what he called a "sketchy" end to the stage and admitted he was looking forward to a rest day before the final push in the Alps.
Report:Froome tightens grip on Tour as Zakarin wins stage
Any faint hopes that Chris Froome's rivals had of chasing down the 2013 and 2015 champion seemed to evaporate, as Bauke Mollema and Nairo Quintana were both dropped on the steep ascent to finish line at Finhaut-Emosson. Froome's fellow Briton Adam Yates continued his wonderful Tour, though, and Ilnur Zakarin had the legs to hold off Jarlinson Pantano to win the gruelling stage, which was held entirely in Switzerland.
Report: Froome close to third Tour title after time trial win
Britain's Chris Froome timed his race to perfection to beat Tom Dumoulin and win a second stage on this year's race and extend his lead over the field to move almost four minutes clear of Bauke Mollema in second. Fellow Briton Adam Yates retained third overall just 21 seconds clear of Nairo Quintana in fourth in the race for the podium places.
Report: Bardet wins stage as Froome suffers crash
In another dramatic stage, Romain Bardet attacked up the last climb of the day to earn a first French win on this year's Tour after several riders crashed in wet conditions, including yellow jersey holder Chris Froome. The Team Sky rider, who also ran up Mont Ventoux after crashing into a motorbike, is forced to borrow the bike of team-mate Geraint Thomas, but extended his lead as second-placed Bauke Mollema tumbled down the general classification.
Report: Froome set to retain Tour title
After all the drama of this year's Tour, the final day of general classification racing ended up being straightforward for Chris Froome. And he will have been relieved. The wet conditions and the steep, downhill finish could have made it difficult for team Sky to protect their man, but Froome was barely troubled and will go into Sunday's largely processional stage to Paris knowing he jut needs to finish to become the first Briton to win three Tour de France titles and be the first to successfully defend it since Miguel Indurain in the 1990s.
Movistar's Jon Izaguirre won his first grand Tour stage by outpacing Vincenzo Nibali and Jarlinson Pantano on the final descent.
Report:Froome wins third title as Greipel wins in Paris
Chris Froome sipped beer and champagne on the ride to Paris before crossing the finish line arm-in-arm with the eight Team Sky riders who helped him become the first Briton to win three Tour titles. Germany's Andre Greipel continued his record of winning at least one stage in each Grand Tour he has competed in with a second career victory on the Champs-Elysees.
Fellow Briton Adam Yates finished fourth to win the white jersey as best young rider, while world champion Peter Sagan claimed the points classification and Rafal Majka took the polka dot king of the mountains top.
Find out how to get into cycling with our special guide.
Geraint Thomas was talking to BBC Sport's Peter Scrivener.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: Harold Wilson's resignation honours were far "more notorious" than anything reportedly proposed by David Cameron, his former press secretary has said.

this is part of a news article. represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article.

Mr Cameron has been criticised for reportedly nominating 48 of his former aides and party donors for awards.
But Joe Haines said the former Labour PM's so-called Lavender List of honours in 1976 "trumped it in notoriety".
In a letter to the Times, he said some of those honoured were investigated for fraud and one went to prison.
There have been calls for Mr Cameron's successor, Theresa May, to intervene after the Sunday Times published leaked details of people it said were being proposed for honours by the outgoing PM.
Opposition parties criticised the alleged list, said to include ex-Downing Street staffers and EU Remain campaigners, saying it smacked of "cronyism".
Downing Street has said any interference on its part in the process would set a "bad precedent".
It has said the normal procedures will be followed, with individuals recommended for awards vetted by a committee made up of former civil servants and parliamentarians and proposed peers scrutinised by the House of Lords Appointments Commission.
Controversy has surrounded the honours system since its infancy, with Mr Wilson among leaders accused of using it to reward friends for political and financial favours.
Mr Wilson's resignation honours list in 1976 caused a scandal after it rewarded some businessmen who were felt to be against the Labour Party.
Mr Haines, one of Mr Wilson's closest aides when he was in power, refused a peerage after Mr Wilson's unexpected exit from Downing Street.
In a letter to the Times written in response to the outcry over Mr Cameron's alleged list, the former journalist said the reason he had given at the time was that he wanted to abolish the House of Lords.
But he said the truth was that he did not want to sit alongside some of those proposed for ennoblement by Mr Wilson, in what was dubbed the lavender list because of the colour of the paper an initial draft was reportedly written on.
"It has been suggested that David Cameron's resignation honours list was even worse than Harold Wilson's famous, or infamous, lavender list," he wrote.
"Mr Cameron's list is more extensive but I think the Wilson list trumped it in notoriety.
"After all, one of the recipients, Sir Eric Miller, committed suicide as the Fraud Squad moved in on him, another, Lord Kagan - into whom I had warned Wilson the Inland Revenue were inquiring â€” went to prison."
Mr Haines went on to question Mr Wilson's overall track record for awarding peerages.
He claimed Rudy Sternberg an Austrian-born industrialist who became a life peer in 1975 was "probably a Russian spy" while it was said Lord Brayley - a businessman who briefly became a defence minister before resigning amid questions about his share dealings - "not only could not write a speech but could not even read those written for him".
He concluded: "So I think Wilson's list wins this particular contest. Of course, we don't know what the future holds for Mr Cameron's nominees."
It is unclear when Mr Cameron's official resignation honours list will be published or how many people on it will be recommended for peerages.
A former adviser to Mr Cameron who has himself turned down an honour said he would like to see more people recognised for entrepreneurialism rather than having served in government.
"I was offered mine for working in Downing Street... I'd like to get one for running a company one day," Rohan Silva told Radio 4's Today programme.
Only 1% of awards in recent years, he said, had gone to entrepreneurs and while there were three committees looking at awards for public service and politics there was only one devoted to the economy.
"I think the honours system matters and the fight that is happening over this honours list shows how much it matters to people who gets an honour and who does not," he added.
"I think the real scandal about our honours system over the last years and decades is how few entrepreneurs - people who take risks and build companies - get honours."

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article!

The former chancellor has been made a Companion of Honour, while Tory MPs Oliver Letwin and Patrick McLoughlin are among those who have been knighted.
Mr Cameron's ex-spin doctor Craig Oliver and Samantha Cameron's adviser Isabel Spearman are also on the list.
The SNP called the list "a form of personal patronage"; Lib Dem leader Tim Farron said it was "full of cronies".
A row broke out after details of the list were leaked to the Sunday Times, including rewards for No 10 staff, party donors and Remain campaigners.
Guide to the Honours
Thirteen new Conservative peers have also been created, alongside two crossbench peers and there is one Labour nomination for Shami Chakrabarti, former director of civil liberties group Liberty.
Ms Chakrabarti, who recently concluded an inquiry into anti-Semitism in the Labour Party, said she was "honoured to accept [Labour leader] Jeremy Corbyn's challenge and opportunity to help hold the government to account".
But the appointment was criticised by Marie van der Zyl, of the Board of Deputies of British Jews, who said it was "beyond disappointing" she had been offered a peerage by Labour "following her so-called independent inquiry". "The report, which was weak in several areas, now seems to have been rewarded with an honour," Ms van del Zyl said.
Opposition MPs called for reform of the honours system after the list was leaked but Prime Minister Theresa May has said she will not intervene in the resignation honours because that would "set a very bad precedent".
The full list of Mr Cameron's resignation honours was published after mounting criticism that the former prime minister was to reward his political allies.
Mr Osborne, chancellor of the exchequer from 2010 to July 2016, has been admitted to the Order of the Companions of Honour - a distinction which is given for service of conspicuous national importance and is limited to 65 people.
Recipients may write the initials CH after their name.
Tory party chairman Mr McLoughlin, who was formerly transport secretary, ex-cabinet minister Oliver Letwin, Defence Secretary Michael Fallon and Craig Oliver, Mr Cameron's former communications director, are knighted. Former environment secretary Caroline Spelman becomes a Dame.
Isabel Spearman, who was employed as a special adviser to Mrs Cameron, has been made an OBE. Thea Rogers, a special adviser to Mr Osborne, has received the same award.
Meanwhile, Will Straw, executive director of the Britain Stronger in Europe group which led the failed EU Remain campaign, becomes a CBE for political and public service.
Others to have received honours on the 46-strong list include:
The new Conservative peerages include Mr Cameron's chief of staff Ed Llewellyn and the head of his Policy Unit, Camilla Cavendish.
The list was criticised by opposition parties. Tim Farron, leader of the Liberal Democrats, said: "David Cameron's resignation honours list is so full of cronies it would embarrass a medieval court. He is not the first prime minister to leave office having rewarded quite so many friends, but he should be the last.
"For the reputation of future leaders, such appointments should be handed over to an independent panel."
The SNP's Tommy Sheppard MP said the list showed Westminster's honours system was "rotten to the core" and there should be a "civil honours procedure that recognises service to the community and outstanding performance in a particular field - neither of which applies to this list".
And Katie Ghose, head of the Electoral Reform Society, said Mr Cameron had "followed the well-trodden route of every other PM and packed the second chamber with former politicians, donors and party hacks. These unelected peers will cost the taxpayer millions over the long term - hardly a fitting goodbye".
Earlier, Mr Cameron's former director of strategy, Steve Hilton, criticised the former prime minister over his resignation honours list.
He said it was "not OK" for politicians to appoint people to the legislature, and that big donors "shouldn't have undue influence over political and policy decisions".


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: Derby County's Jacob Butterfield says there were signs they were getting back to their best at Burnley and described the 4-1 loss as a "crazy night".

The Rams conceded three goals in 12 second-half minutes at Turf Moor and are now winless in five league games.
Butterfield, whose volley levelled the scores at 1-1, told BBC Radio Derby: "In the first half we were the better team and played some brilliant stuff.
"Before we knew it, we were 3-1 down in a game we have dominated."
The Rams have slipped to fifth in the Championship table and are now six points adrift of the automatic promotion spots, having played a game more than second-placed Middlesbrough.
Midfielder Butterfield, who has scored seven goals for the Rams this season, added: "It was one of those crazy nights. We will have to get it out of our system and move on.
"We were unlucky to go in at 1-1, we should have been 2-1 or 3-1 up. It looked like it was going to be a good night. It's hard to explain.
Media playback is not supported on this device
"But when you are in a bit of bad form these things happen. You can't legislate for individual mistakes. They always happen and unfortunately we have had a couple and it has cost us.
"That will not happen every game - it's a one off. We have had a bad night but we will try to be positive about it."
Derby are in FA Cup action on Friday, 29 January when Premier League side Manchester United visit the iPro Stadium.
The next league fixture is also at home, against Preston North End on Tuesday, 2 January.
"It was only a few weeks ago we were four points clear," said the 25-year-old. "All the top teams have to still play each other.
"I still believe it is in our hands. We showed signs we can put it right. We still have time on our side and we are confident we can win a lot of matches and get right up there again."

The Rams had not scored in four matches but led when Bryson bundled a shot in after a scramble.
He doubled the lead when he finished from Chris Martin's lay-off before Jeff Hendrick finished a counter-attack to make it three.
Derby legend Steve Bloomer scored a hat-trick in his team's 5-0 win over Forest in 1898. There is a statue of the England striker, who died at the age of 64 in 1938, by the dug-outs at the iPro Stadium.
Johnny Russell drove in a fourth before Bryson scored a penalty.
Bryson's hat-trick was a first for a Derby player in this fixture since Steve Bloomer's treble in a victory by the same scoreline in 1898.
While the Rams have not given up hope of catching second-placed Burnley, the play-off hopes of Billy Davies' Nottingham Forest have been hit by a miserable run that has now seen them fail to win in seven league matches.
Steve McClaren's Derby had fallen away from the top two by failing to score in a winless run of four games but they took the lead after five minutes when Bryson's shot flew in off Danny Collins.
Radoslaw Majewski had a curling shot held by Derby goalkeeper Lee Grant as the visitors began to control possession but they found themselves two behind when Bryson finished from Martin's pass.
Media playback is not supported on this device
Eight minutes before the break, the Rams made it three when they broke quickly from a Forest corner and Patrick Bamford played through for Hendrick to shoot under goalkeeper Karl Darlow.
Substitute Russell thumped in the fourth from just outside the area after a heavy spell of pressure.
Darlow pushed away a flick from Martin but then gave away a penalty for a clip on Bamford to allow midfielder Bryson to convert from the spot for his 15th league goal of the season.
Derby head coach Steve McClaren:
"We knew if we kept doing the right things the end product would come and there's no better day to do it than today in front of 33,000 fans.
"I think this win is for the Derby fans.
"We got Nottingham Forest at a good time with all the injuries but I think this is the best win and probably the most satisfying purely because we kind of controlled the whole game."
Nottingham Forest assistant manager David Kelly:
"Huge credit to Steve and his group, they thoroughly deserved the victory but we were disappointed in how we defended.
"It was a disappointing catalogue of goals we gave away and what we were working on during the week was disappointing in how it was executed on the day.
"It's a huge, huge game in the season and we're disappointed we've let the fans down. We only had a fit group of 18 we brought today but that's not an excuse, it's just the facts of what's going on."


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: Five people have been taken to hospital, with at least one of them seriously injured, after two vehicles collided in County Antrim.

represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

The crash happened on the Old Carrick Road in Newtownabbey at about 18:35 GMT on Saturday.
Ambulance crews took two of those injured in the crash to Belfast's Royal Victoria Hospital and two to the Royal Belfast Hospital for Sick Children.
Another person was taken to Antrim Area Hospital.
Police have sealed off the road and it is likely to remain closed overnight.
Diversions are in place on the Doagh Road and the Monkstown Road.

The boy, who has not been identified, was travelling in the van with the driver and an eight-year-old girl when it left the road on Main Street in Hayton, police said.
The 44-year-old man and the girl were taken to hospital with non-life threatening injuries.
The road was closed following the accident but has since reopened.


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: Anonymous messaging service Secret, at one stage thought to be valued at more than $100m (Â£66.5m), is shutting down.

represent the news article to find a single sentence that could be used as a summary

Founder David Byttow said: "Secret does not represent the vision I had when starting the company" and that he believed in "failing fast".
The app was created, in part, to promote free speech but was criticised for promoting cyber-bullying.
User numbers have dwindled in recent months. Secret said it would return some of its $35m funding to investors.
It is a big turnaround for the company that was the talk of Silicon Valley, both among investors and users of the app, just a year ago.
Founded in 2013 by two former Google employees, the company was backed by some big names including actor Ashton Kutcher, Alexis Ohanian - a founder of Reddit, and Google Ventures.
The anonymous nature of messaging on the app led to its early adoption by technology sector workers, who used it to post rumours of forthcoming products or company mergers.
It was also used for political discussion in Russia and in Israel.
But the service was criticised for allowing people to defame others while remaining anonymous. It was banned in Brazil for promoting cyber-bullying.
A redesign of the app last year prompted users to "think before they post" and made it easier for users to flag up abusive content.
But user numbers have been falling in recent months, with some of those remaining complaining of an increase in the number of posts of a sexual nature and that public chat had become dominated by users from Indonesia.
In his blog post on Medium, Mr Byttow said: "I believe in honest, open communication and creative expression, and anonymity is a great device to achieve it.
"But it's also the ultimate double-edged sword, which must be wielded with great respect and care.
"I look forward to seeing what others in this space do over time."
Secret is not the first app to attract millions of dollars in funding only to flop shortly afterwards.
In 2012, photo and video-sharing app Color closed just 12 months after its launch having raised $41m from investors.
In June that year, Napster founders, Shawn Fanning and Shaun Parker launched their video-chat site Airtime, attracting $33m in funding.
It had very limited success, with Fortune magazine reporting that it had had to be quietly relaunched two years later.
"The truth is that there is fierce competition right now to get in early on any start-up that looks buzzy - who wants to be the guy that turned down WhatsApp in 2009 or Snapchat in 2012?
And if that means throwing a few million dollars at companies which appear to have no moral or business compass, then so be it."
Read Rory's blog
In closing Secret just 16 months after its launch, Mr Byttow said: "This has been the hardest decision of my life and one that saddens me deeply."
"Unfortunately Secret does not represent the vision I had when starting the company."

The musician, from Dumfries, earned $63m (Â£51.18m) last year.
Chef Gordon Ramsay is ranked 34th on the Forbes celebrity rich list, with earnings of $54m (Â£43.87m) in 2016.
The list is topped by pop star Taylor Swift who earns $170m (Â£138.17m).


Question: this is the first sentence of a news article. represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: All pictures are copyrighted.

A selection of your pictures of Scotland sent in between 10 - 17 February. Send your photos to scotlandpictures@bbc.co.uk or our Instagram at #bbcscotlandpics


Question: represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: A section of the M74 in Dumfries and Galloway has been closed due to a serious road accident.

Represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence

Police Scotland said it happened at about 17:05. It is understood two vehicles were involved.
The motorway was shut in both directions between J15 Moffat and J14 Elvanfoot, with a diversion via the B7076.
Traffic Scotland warned of queues in the area.

Friday morning's incident near the A465 Heads of the Valleys road involved three vehicles.
A separate collision happened on the A470 northbound near Brecon.
Elsewhere, there were also reports of accidents on the A55 in Flintshire, while ice briefly shut the exit at J32 at Halkyn.
In Pembrokeshire, the A4075 between the Yerbeston and and Canaston Bridge roundabout was shut after a car overturned but it has since re-opened.
And on the M4 in Bridgend, a car driving the wrong way was believed to have been involved in two crashes.
All roads have now reopened.


Question: This is the first sentence of a news article. Represent it to easily retrieve the remaining few sentences of the article

Question: Scotland's Commonwealth Games gold medallist Libby Clegg has been forced to pull out of the rest of the IPC Athletics World Championships in Doha.

represent the news to retrieve its missing first sentence.

The 25-year-old visually-impaired sprinter withdrew from Sunday's T12 200m semi-finals after injuring her foot in the warm-up.
She and guide Mikail Huggins are unable to compete in Monday's 100m heats.
Illness forced Clegg out of last year's European Championships in Swansea and her 2015 season has been hit by injury.

This is part of a news article. Represent it to retrieve the first (missing) sentence of the article

The 25-year-old German, who is based in Oklahoma, was competing at the IPC Athletics Grand Prix event in Arizona, which she won with a 4.65m jump.
She tweeted: "My running legs got stolen today. Please help me find/replace them!"
Low is scheduled to compete in this summer's Paralympics in Rio.
She jumped a world record 4.79 metres to claim gold at the 2015 World Championships in Doha.


Question: Represent the summary to retrieve the rest of the news story with more details

Question: The latest film in the Bourne series has topped the US box office after taking $60m (£45.3m) on its opening weekend.

Jason Bourne, which sees Matt Damon return to the lead role, is the fifth instalment of the franchise.
Last week's number one - Star Trek Beyond - dropped a place after taking a further $24m (£18.1m) over the weekend.
Bad Moms, a comedy starring Mila Kunis and Kristen Bell, took $23.4m (£17.7m) to debut at number three.
The Secret Life of Pets dropped to number four with takings of $18.2m (£13.8m).
Horror film Lights Out rounded off the top five with $10.8m (£8.1m).
Elsewhere in this week's top 10, thriller Nerve - starring Emma Roberts and Dave Franco - landed in eighth place with takings of $9m (£6.8m) on its first weekend of release.
Jason Bourne marks Damon's first appearance as the character since 2007 - when he starred in The Bourne Ultimatum, the third film in the series.
Jeremy Renner starred in the fourth, The Bourne Legacy, which was released in 2012.
Damon is also set to appear in forthcoming movie The Great Wall - reportedly the most expensive Chinese film in history.
But his casting has caused controversy, with some fans questioning why an Asian actor was not chosen for his role.
Follow us on Twitter @BBCNewsEnts, on Instagram, or email entertainment.news@bbc.co.uk.

Ant-Man, which stars Paul Rudd as a thief who is recruited to become a shrinking action hero, bumped Minions off the top of the box office chart.
Ant-Man's first weekend takings were lower than for other major Marvel films like Captain America and Iron Man.
But its $130m (£83m) budget was also smaller than most Marvel blockbusters.
Minions made $50.2m (£32m) between Friday and Sunday, putting it in second place, according to studio estimates.
Romantic comedy Trainwreck, written by and starring Amy Schumer, exceeded expectations to earn $30.2m (£19m) and third place.
Pixar's Inside Out was fourth with $11.6m (£7.4m), closely followed by Jurassic World, with $11.4m.
That made the dinosaur thriller only the fourth film in history to have made more than $600m (£385m) at North American box offices, behind Avatar, Titanic and Avengers Assemble.


Question: Represent the text to find a corresponding news article that continues the story

Question: Doosan Babcock is to create 266 jobs at a new process engineering centre in Renfrewshire.

The firm, which provides services to the energy and pharmaceutical sectors, also plans to create 114 additional jobs at sites around the UK.
Doosan said it was investing Â£4.5m in the Renfrew facility, which is being backed with Â£1.5m Regional Selective Assistance from Scottish Enterprise.
The new jobs are expected to be phased in around the UK sites by 2018.
Doosan Babcock chief executive Andy Hunt said: "The opening of this centre is fantastic news for Scotland and for Doosan Babcock as we seek to grow our process business, creating new roles for British engineers.
"The process sector can be a highly complex area to operate in but, thanks to this investment, Doosan Babcock will have the skillset and specialist knowledge to offer customers an integrated engineering and construction service that is unparalleled."
Doosan said the opening of the centre was the first step in a plan to almost triple the size of its process business over the next five years.
The new department will aim to deliver a "complete service" to companies operating in process industries such as oil and gas, refining, petrochemicals, chemicals and pharmaceuticals.
This service will range from concept design through to the construction and handover of new production facilities, as well as the repair, overhaul and upgrade of existing plants.
The company aims to engage UK customers and then target international growth opportunities, particularly in regions such as the Middle East.
Scottish Enterprise chief executive Lena Wilson said: "Doosan has ambitious plans for expanding its process business on the world stage and it is testament to our key capabilities and skills that Scotland has been selected as the location for such a pivotal part of the company's global growth plans.
"The company's decision to locate this new service here is an excellent example of how the support that we and our partners can offer is helping bring new investment into Scotland."
Finance Secretary John Swinney added: "This is another sign of confidence in Scotland as a great place to do business and a great place to invest."

Siemens plans to relocate its gas turbine plant from Freeman Road to a new 7,000 sq m (75,347 sq ft) building at Teal Park, creating new jobs.
It expects construction to be completed by January 2018 with all of the Freeman Road employees moved in by spring.
Labour council leader Ric Metcalfe said it was "tremendous news" and a "very big vote of confidence" in the city.
More stories from across Lincolnshire
As part of the investment, the German firm is also buying 11 acres of land on the Teal Park estate.
The new building would be located next to Siemens' manufacturing and research facility at the site.
Neil Corner, managing director of Siemens in Lincoln, said: "The new Global Service Operations Centre will help to improve efficiency by having everything in close proximity such as spare parts, turbine engine units, tooling and safety equipment.
"Hopefully that will bring some jobs as we need them and as we create them."
Mr Metcalfe said: "Siemens are a hugely important presence in the local economy... and Lincoln's got a very skilled workforce."
About 1,500 people are employed at Siemens in Lincoln making it the city's largest engineering employer.