But in Washington , Senator Charles E. Schumer of New York is backing what some view as a rival project , a commuter rail tunnel that would connect west-of-Hudson commuters to Manhattan through New Jersey .
New York /location/location/contains Manhattan
CC IN NNP , NNP NNP NNP NNP IN NNP NNP VBZ VBG WP DT NN IN DT JJ NN , DT NN NN NN WDT MD VB JJ NNS TO NNP IN NNP NNP .
New York
LOCATION
Manhattan
LOCATION
/location/location/contains