Although 9 of the last 10 mayors have been mustache-free , David N. Dinkins , the first black mayor , Robert Van Wyck , the first mayor after the consolidation of New York City , and William Russell Grace , first Catholic mayor , have had them .
William Russell Grace /people/person/place_lived New York City
William Russell Grace /people/deceased_person/place_of_death New York City
IN CD IN DT JJ CD NNS VBP VBN JJ , NNP NNP NNP , DT JJ JJ NN , NNP NNP NNP , DT JJ NN IN DT NN IN NNP NNP NNP , CC NNP NNP NNP , JJ JJ NN , VBP VBD PRP .
William Russell Grace
PERSON
New York City
LOCATION
/people/person/place_lived
William Russell Grace
PERSON
New York City
LOCATION
/people/deceased_person/place_of_death