Rudy Giuliani spoke in 2002 , '' Shaffer said , referring to the former New York City mayor . ''
Rudy Giuliani /people/person/place_lived New York City
NNP NNP VBD IN CD , '' NNP VBD , VBG TO DT JJ NNP NNP NNP NN . ''
Rudy Giuliani
PERSON
New York City
LOCATION
/people/person/place_lived