claim: says under the senate immigration bill, newly legalized immigrants will "pay every tax possible, but you don’t get a single benefit" for 10 years.
author: luis gutierrez
evidence_1: aug 31, 2016 ... npr's politics team annotated trump's speech on immigration, which comes after  a week of seeming to change direction on the issue. ... you know this, you know  this, this is what they talk about — facing american society today is that there are  11 million illegal immigrants who don't have legal status.
evidence_2: jun 22, 2017 ... including some legal immigrants. ... counterpart in the house, the american  health care act, the senate bill keeps those immigrants from being able to get  tax subsidies to offset the cost of purchasing insurance. ... immigrants who are  lawfully present, but not “qualified” under the 1996 law, would be cut out.
evidence_3: mar 1, 2016 ... immigrants illegally in the u.s. collectively contribute nearly $12 billion each year  to state and local tax coffers, according to a new report that ... nature of  immigration reform, the data show undocumented immigrants greatly contribute  to our nation's economy, not just in labor but also with tax dollars," meg ...
evidence_4: sep 6, 2017 ... as a result, young undocumented immigrants have since been called dreamers.  over the last 16 years, numerous versions of the dream act have been  introduced, all of which would have provided a pathway to legal status for  undocumented youth who came to this country as children. some versions have  ...
evidence_5: sep 12, 2016 ... they're contributing billions of dollars a year to social security, but may never  reap any retirement benefits from it. ... and in the past 20 years, the internal  revenue service has made it easier for workers to pay taxes if they don't have a  social security number (or a fake one, for that matter). workers who are ...