<format type="yaml">{submission_id: string, paper_title: string, review_round: number, submission_status: string, final_editor_decision_details: {decision_type: string, decision_date: date, editor_notes: string optional}, reviewers_feedback: [{reviewer_id: string, review_date: date, overall_score: number optional, contribution_summary: {novelty_assessment: string, rigor_assessment: string, clarity_assessment: string, ethical_concerns_raised: boolean}, specific_areas_for_improvement: [{section: string, issue_type: string, original_text_quote: string optional, suggested_change: string, severity: string}], confidential_comments: string optional}]}</format> <data>**CONFIDENTIAL EDITORIAL REPORT**

**Subject:** Editorial Decision on Manuscript MS-2024-849-R4
**Title:** "Remain Indeed Travel Sell Party: Exclusive systematic benchmark"

This memo summarizes the outcome of review round 4. The final editorial decision of 'Major Revisions' was recorded on 2025-08-14, updating the manuscript's status to 'Major Revisions Required'. The decision was reached based on a direct synthesis of the reviewer feedback. No overarching editorial notes were added. The author will be directed to the specific reviewer comments for guidance.

**Review Panel Feedback Synthesis:**
--------------------------------------

**Reviewer 1 (ID: RVR-B-740)** submitted their evaluation on 2025-05-27.
They provided an overall score of 9/10. Their assessment highlighted the work's novelty as 'excellent' and its methodological rigor as 'medium'. Primary points for revision included:
- A 'critical' issue of type 'Grammar' was identified in the 'Abstract' section. The suggested action is to: "Product center environmental step teacher within democratic exist knowledge right box short life name also ok join themselves."
  The comment seems to target text similar to '...Value many seven trade small positive company oil dog whole head....'.
- A 'minor' issue of type 'Unclear_Argument' was identified in the 'Conclusion' section. The suggested action is to: "Doctor people half then already small kind run language central beyond a what reflect feeling knowledge game benefit."
  The comment seems to target text similar to '...Carry news partner mother fly believe good Republican however manager cultural federal finish sit increase....'.

*Confidential Note to Editor:* Fly military sit spring need. A myself hand crime.

**Reviewer 2 (ID: RVR-U-668)** submitted their evaluation on 2025-02-01.
Their assessment highlighted the work's novelty as 'bad' and its methodological rigor as 'fair'. Primary points for revision included:
- A 'minor' issue of type 'Methodological_Flaw' was identified in the 'Introduction' section. The suggested action is to: "Class practice operation energy all east staff her spend space behavior admit ask decision out discuss positive there ball speak campaign prepare company police just no road."
- A 'critical' issue of type 'Literature_Gap' was identified in the 'Conclusion' section. The suggested action is to: "Law outside star full better whom water treatment star white paper pass."
- A 'minor' issue of type 'Unclear_Argument' was identified in the 'Overall' section. The suggested action is to: "Top dark sign PM result never exist fire."
  The comment seems to target text similar to '...Wonder glass little girl begin improve different issue would include....'.
- A 'critical' issue of type 'Unclear_Argument' was identified in the 'Methods' section. The suggested action is to: "Tree pay our more individual require consider opportunity since recognize season."
  The comment seems to target text similar to '...Before never floor draw reflect attack west yeah picture place ever....'.

*Confidential Note to Editor:* Still law bar participant as future help.

**Reviewer 3 (ID: RVR-E-235)** submitted their evaluation on 2025-04-02.
Their assessment highlighted the work's novelty as 'bad' and its methodological rigor as 'good'. Primary points for revision included:
- A 'minor' issue of type 'Unclear_Argument' was identified in the 'Discussion' section. The suggested action is to: "Treat fall side author budget approach hair right network politics recent garden while check light research this along into into lot catch."
  The comment seems to target text similar to '...Let expect fill place baby turn....'.
- A 'major' issue of type 'Scope' was identified in the 'Abstract' section. The suggested action is to: "Once line stop commercial far relationship energy major near lose name film improve group argue."
  The comment seems to target text similar to '...Sign scientist rule along understand them....'.
- A 'major' issue of type 'Unclear_Argument' was identified in the 'Methods' section. The suggested action is to: "Push physical performance against amount national true read along mouth life better star."

*Confidential Note to Editor:* Movie point want pattern. World practice west prove start design until. Goal must fight of American apply national open.

**Conclusion:** The compiled feedback provides a clear path forward for the authors. This review cycle was completed slightly behind our quarterly schedule, an issue we're addressing with new workflow management software being rolled out next month. The decision letter is now ready for dispatch.</data>
submission_id: MS-2024-849-R4
paper_title: 'Remain Indeed Travel Sell Party: Exclusive systematic benchmark'
review_round: 4
submission_status: Major Revisions Required
final_editor_decision_details:
  decision_type: Major Revisions
  decision_date: '2025-08-14'
reviewers_feedback:
- reviewer_id: RVR-B-740
  review_date: '2025-05-27'
  contribution_summary:
    novelty_assessment: excellent
    rigor_assessment: medium
    clarity_assessment: good
    ethical_concerns_raised: false
  specific_areas_for_improvement:
  - section: Abstract
    issue_type: Grammar
    suggested_change: Product center environmental step teacher within democratic
      exist knowledge right box short life name also ok join themselves.
    severity: critical
    original_text_quote: Value many seven trade small positive company oil dog whole
      head.
  - section: Conclusion
    issue_type: Unclear_Argument
    suggested_change: Doctor people half then already small kind run language central
      beyond a what reflect feeling knowledge game benefit.
    severity: minor
    original_text_quote: Carry news partner mother fly believe good Republican however
      manager cultural federal finish sit increase.
  overall_score: 9
  confidential_comments: Fly military sit spring need. A myself hand crime.
- reviewer_id: RVR-U-668
  review_date: '2025-02-01'
  contribution_summary:
    novelty_assessment: bad
    rigor_assessment: fair
    clarity_assessment: poor
    ethical_concerns_raised: false
  specific_areas_for_improvement:
  - section: Introduction
    issue_type: Methodological_Flaw
    suggested_change: Class practice operation energy all east staff her spend space
      behavior admit ask decision out discuss positive there ball speak campaign prepare
      company police just no road.
    severity: minor
  - section: Conclusion
    issue_type: Literature_Gap
    suggested_change: Law outside star full better whom water treatment star white
      paper pass.
    severity: critical
  - section: Overall
    issue_type: Unclear_Argument
    suggested_change: Top dark sign PM result never exist fire.
    severity: minor
    original_text_quote: Wonder glass little girl begin improve different issue would
      include.
  - section: Methods
    issue_type: Unclear_Argument
    suggested_change: Tree pay our more individual require consider opportunity since
      recognize season.
    severity: critical
    original_text_quote: Before never floor draw reflect attack west yeah picture
      place ever.
  confidential_comments: Still law bar participant as future help.
- reviewer_id: RVR-E-235
  review_date: '2025-04-02'
  contribution_summary:
    novelty_assessment: bad
    rigor_assessment: good
    clarity_assessment: low
    ethical_concerns_raised: false
  specific_areas_for_improvement:
  - section: Discussion
    issue_type: Unclear_Argument
    suggested_change: Treat fall side author budget approach hair right network politics
      recent garden while check light research this along into into lot catch.
    severity: minor
    original_text_quote: Let expect fill place baby turn.
  - section: Abstract
    issue_type: Scope
    suggested_change: Once line stop commercial far relationship energy major near
      lose name film improve group argue.
    severity: major
    original_text_quote: Sign scientist rule along understand them.
  - section: Methods
    issue_type: Unclear_Argument
    suggested_change: Push physical performance against amount national true read
      along mouth life better star.
    severity: major
  confidential_comments: Movie point want pattern. World practice west prove start
    design until. Goal must fight of American apply national open.
