 He was a team co-captain and league All-Star at linebacker in both 1963 and 1964.In his final season (1964), he received the Johnny Copp Trophy as the team's Most Valuable Player.Watters also was a member of the Wrestling Blues for three seasons (1961–62, 62–63, 63–64) and practiced regularly with the Varsity Blues men's ice hockey team, although he saw limited action in league play.