 Judge Senter dismissed Renfroe, finding that there was no basis for the McIntoshes’ claim of fraud against State Farm and Renfroe, and since there was no basis for a claim of fraud, Renfroe could not have “aided and abetted” State Farm in a “fraud that did not occur.”

Thomas and Pamela McIntosh settle their lawsuit against State Farm for $250,000.Renfroe had already been dismissed from that lawsuit.The finding of contempt by the District Court overruled in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the eleventh circuit.