 "The Arcadians", produced by Robert Courtneidge, was possibly Monckton's best score and is considered the classic musical of the Edwardian period.Like "The Geisha", "A Country Girl" and "Our Miss Gibbs", it became popular in America and elsewhere and included songs such as "The Pipes of Pan", "The Girl with the Brogue", and "All Down Piccadilly", which "held their own with the melodies of the now fashionable Viennese operetta as the song hits of the period.