 However, the British weekly magazine "Punch" immediately disparaged Mackenzie's efforts, noting in August 1891 that the title of the song actually was "Jim Collins" and that Mackenzie otherwise inaccurately quoted and characterized the song.The earliest publication of any Collins as well as any Fizz recipe, are both located in the same book, Harry Johnson’s 1882 book, "New and Improved Bartender’s Manual or How to Mix Drinks of the Present Style".In this book, you can find a Tom Collins calling for Old Tom gin and a John Collins calling for Holland Gin, most likely what is known as Genièvre.