 The Stags also narrowly missed out on promotion to the Uttoxeter & District first division in 2012 after finishing third, although improving their position the previous year (4th).The Stags were finally promoted to division 1 the following year and completed the double by winning the subsidiary cup after beating The Three Tuns FC in the final 4-1 in a match played at the Oldfield sports ground, Uttoxeter.The subsidiary cup win was repeated in 2017 after a 6-2 victory against Stone Town FC at Abbots Bromley School that saw Will Ferneyhough hit 5.