 In 1971, the Tornado won the NASL championship over the Atlanta Chiefs.Renshaw scored the winning goal in the third, and deciding, game of the series, the only outdoor professional championship ever won by a Dallas soccer team.In 1975, he was in the starting line-up for the Dallas Tornado against the New York Cosmo in Peles' first game for New York (a 2–2 tie) later that season he scored against Peles' Cosmos in a 3–2 Tornado win at Texas Stadium.