 Writing for Polygon, Janine Hawkins wrote that ""Frog Fractions 2" feels more concerned with its own irreverence than with being outright surprising"; Jeffrey Matulef for Eurogamer wrote that the "game is stretched too thin with a more predictable format that robs it of its predecessor's more purposeful pace".Darren Nakamura of Destructoid noted that "without the element of surprise, "Frog Fractions 2" is just a collection of mostly bad minigames.