 Cicciarelli made his debut with the club on March 30, appearing as a substitute in a match against LA Galaxy II.Three days later, again entering as a substitute during a match against the Orange County Blues, he registered his first professional goals, scoring twice in the second half; he was named the USL Player of the Week for his performance, becoming the first Saint Louis FC player to win the award.The following week, Cicciarelli scored in a 2–2 draw against Oklahoma City Energy, and was again named to the USL Team of the Week.