 A. O. Scott wrote in "The New York Times" that in "Rogue One", "Jyn's idealistic Jedi-ish tendencies are at first checked by a hint of Bogart-esque cynicism.She's suspicious of the rebels and contemptuous of the Empire, and has complicated feelings about Saw Gerrera".Peter Travers of "Rolling Stone" called Jyn "a born rebel", and Richard Brody of "The New Yorker" noted that "though Jyn had never exhibited any spirit of revolt", coming together with Gerrera and the rebels results in "Jyn's transition from an apolitical survivor to an active rebel".