 An English work from that period is a small oval portrait miniature on ivory from 1847, picturing Eliza, first wife of the late Edward Grove, which appeared at auction in Malvern, Worcestershire in 2015.By 1851, Pauling had returned to New York with his wife and 3-year-old daughter and was exhibiting again at the National Academy of Design.In that year, he was living at 609 Broadway, and he showed a Portrait of a Gentleman [T.M.