 In April 2011, Benedictine announced that it was selling the school's historic campus on Sheppard Street in Richmond's Museum District to the Catholic Diocese of Richmond, and planned to move forward with plans to move the school to Goochland, Virginia.The sale included a buy-back option for the school in case the plans to move the school fell through.In the fall of the 2013-2014 semester, Benedictine College Preparatory moved to the Mary Mother of the Church Abbey location and the sale of the Sheppard Street campus was finalized.