 Carter had also dated Lindsay Lohan along with his girlfriend Hilary Duff at the same time (leading to a feud between the two), but he broke up with Lohan in April 2003, and resumed dating Duff.Later, that same year, he and Duff ended their on-and-off relationship after two years.Carter's "Most Requested Hits", a collection including tracks from his last three albums as well as a new single, "One Better", was released on November 3, 2003.