 More Lemmings" received generally positive reviews.Dan Slingsby of "CU Amiga" found the game addictive, calling the puzzles "ingenious", and Peter Lee of "Amiga Action" praised the quality and difficulty of the levels; Stuart Campbell of "Amiga Power" was disappointed by the lack of fixes from the original game, and Ed Ricketts of "ST Format" criticised the difficulty gradient of the levels and the price of the expansion, but both ultimately gave positive reviews nonetheless.