 Witte coached a total of nine seasons in Laramie and compiled a 134–51 record.After Witte stepped down in 1939, Everett Shelton took over the team and went on to become the winningest coach in Wyoming history in his 19 years in Laramie.Although Shelton went just 6–10 in his first season, his teams would win 20 or more games seven times during his career.