 The Shenandoah Valley Railroad built a stop for the event, which was a great success.The fair continued annually, becoming a four day event and in June 1889 the association bought Boteler's Fountain Rock property, moved some fair buildings onto it, then constructed a wooden pavilion in 1890.Boteler died in Shepherdstown, West Virginia, on May 8, 1892, months after his wife of five decades and was interred with her at Elmwood Cemetery.