 He starred until 2008 in the original cast production of "Jersey Boys" which opened at the August Wilson theater on Broadway in 2005.His dynamic portrayal of Tommy DeVito, one of the founding members of Four Seasons musical group, won him the "Best Featured Actor in a Musical" Tony award in 2006.He was scheduled to return to Broadway in the Roundabout Theatre's 2008 production of "Pal Joey" in the title role; however due to an injury he was forced to leave the production.