 The day that Chad decides to tell Gabi this, Deimos kidnaps Abigail and Gabi and poisons them both and gives Chad only enough antidote to save one of the women, forcing him to choose which woman would live and which would die.Chad, however, gives half of the antidote to each one, saving both of their lives, however, Gabi remains in a coma.Abby later realizes that Chad and Gabi used to play baseball together, and believes that Chad only saved her first because he knew that Gabi would catch the vial.