 In her opinion, the "Ima Torikaebaya" is the far superior of the two works.The earlier version of the tale has "disagreeable" scenes, including a scene discussing the Chūnagon's menstruation, and a scene where the former Chūnagon gives birth while still partially dressed as a man, which scandalised the author of the "Mumyōzōshi".Another scene not present in the later version is a scene where the male characters discuss "monogatari" on a "day of abstinence", which is considered similar to scenes from "The Tale of Genji", but not as good by the author of the "Mumyōzōshi", as it is an imitation.