 In 2012, Cuthbert was host of the American Music Awards.In October 2012, she appeared in The Gaslight Anthem's music video "Here Comes My Man", playing the girlfriend of a man who mistreats her, until she imagines a romantic relationship with a character in a film and chooses to end her real relationship.In 2013, she made the cover of "Maxim", who named her TV's Most Beautiful Woman.