 Avi-Yonah, however, considered that to be a different Gath, usually now called Gath-Gittaim.This view is also supported by other scholars, those holding that there was, both, a Gath (today's "Tell es-Safi") and Gath-Rimmon (in or near Ramla).The 19th-century scholar Edward Robinson proposed that Gath be identified with Tell es-Safi, and this identification was generally accepted until the early 20th century.