 Not to be outdone, as hosts of the party, the Batavia Street Gang robbed Segal's Jewelry Store on New Chambers Street of 44 gold rings.The following morning however, shortly after selling the rings at a local pawn shop, over a dozen gang members were arrested by police while being fitted for suits at a tailors shop on Division Street spending that night in The Tombs while the Cherry Hill Gang and others attended the party.By the early 20th century the Cherry Hill Gang was regarded as the most vicious gang in the city.