 Club" gave the episode of B+, liking the deconstruction of the creepiness of the love potion trope.Joe Matar of the website Den of Geek liked the episode, saying that while it wasn't as funny as the previous episode, it had a wonderfully dark ending, and that he enjoyed Jerry's action hero subplot.David Roa of Dead Screen loved the ending, saying that "while it was very Deus ex machina, it was still satisfying."