 "No Mistakes" was viewed alongside fellow album track "Yikes" by Andrew Barker of "Variety" as "West operating in vintage mode," with him directing praise towards the sampling.In "The Observer", Kitty Empire noted the track for featuring a "buttery first verse and chorus," which "curdles into a series of self-righteous outbursts" from West.One of the "moments of true, transporting beauty on "Ye"" was listed by Tom Breihan of "Stereogum" as being "Wilson's voice surging skyward on [the track], soaring above those pianos like a phoenix in flight."