 Already the confirmation charter of 1136 shows a shift in emphasis towards the permanent members, and the difference in rank between permanent and temporary members of the Templars shows, Lourie argues, that the one is further from any Islamic source and closer to Christian monastic tradition.Belchite is a "half-way house" between municipal fraternities, the monastic orders and the "ribāṭ".She goes on to quote the objection of O'Callaghan why "[i]f the "ribāṭ" with its complement of warrior-ascetics existed in Spain for centuries ... the first Spanish military order [the Order of Calatrava] was not founded before 1158?"