 When Starr gave birth on November 6, 2008, Todd had intended to kidnap the child and raise it in secret but changed his mind at the last minute.Meanwhile, after losing her own baby in childbirth on the same day, Starr's cousin Jessica Brennan — during an episode of her recurring dissociative identity disorder — switched Starr's living daughter with her own deceased baby girl, causing everyone to believe that Starr's child, Hope, had died.Seven months later, the truth about the baby switch came out and Hope was returned on June 5, 2009; Michael and Marcie finally assumed a few days later.