| Song of the Year || |- | Best Female R&B Vocal Performance || |- | Best R&B Song || |- | India Arie || Best New Artist || |- | rowspan="4" | 2003 || "The Christmas Song" || Best Pop Collaboration with Vocals || |- | "Little Things" || Best Urban/Alternative Performance || |- | "Good Man" || Best R&B Song || |- | Voyage to India || Best R&B Album || |- | 2006 || "A Time to Love" || Best Pop Collaboration with Vocals || |- | rowspan="3" | 2007 || rowspan="2" | "I Am Not My Hair" || Best Female R&B Vocal Performance || |- | Best R&B Song || |- | Testimony: Vol. 1, Life & Relationships || Best R&B Album || |- | 2008 || "Beautiful Flower" || Best R&B Song || |- | 2009 || "Words" || Best R&B Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocals || |- | rowspan="3" | 2010 || "Chocolate High" || Best R&B Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocals || |- | Testimony Vol. 2, Love & Politics || Best R&B Album || |- | "Pearls" || Best Urban/Alternative Performance || |- | 2011 || "Imagine" || Best Pop Collaboration with Vocals || |- | 2018 || "SongVersation: Medicine" || Best New Age Album || |- | 2020 || "Steady Love" || Best Traditional R&B Performance || |- BET Awards |- | 2001 || India Arie || Best New Artist || |- | 2002 || India Arie || Best Female R&B Artist || |- | 2003 || India Arie || Best Female R&B Artist || |- | 2006 || India Arie || Best Female R&B Artist || |- Soul Train Music Awards |- | rowspan="3" | 2002 || India Arie || Best New Artist || |- | Acoustic Soul || Best R&B/Soul Album – Female || |- | "Video" || Best R&B/Soul Single – Female || |- | 2003 || "Little Things" || Best R&B/Soul Single – Female || |- | 2007 || Testimony: Vol. 1, Life & Relationships || Best R&B/Soul Album – Female || |- NAACP Image Award |- | rowspan="3" | 2002 || rowspan="2" | India Arie || Outstanding New Artist || |- | Outstanding Female Artist || |- | Acoustic Soul || Outstanding Album || |- | rowspan="5" | 2003 || India Arie & Stevie Wonder || Outstanding Duo or Group