a real estate agent for the Women's Investment Company in San Francisco, that would became Carmel's first real estate development group. Goldsmith completed his voter registration on October 16, 1888 in at 355 First Street in San Francisco. Carmel City In early 1888, Santiago J. Duckworth wanted to establish a Catholic retreat near the Carmel Mission, on homestead property, which then belonged to the US federal government. Duckworth would call it "Carmel City." Duckworth hired Abbie Hunter as a sales agent for Carmel City. In July 1888, Duckworth began selling lots. Goldsmith, Hunter, and her son Wesley R. Hunter (1876-1966), came to Carmel City in late 1888, where they started buying lots and building their first homes. Goldsmith became the first builder in Carmel. Early Carmel City homes In 1888, Goldsmith built a one-story vernacular side-gabled redwood residence for Duckworth, now known as the Santiago Duckworth House. The house is located on Carpenter Street SW of Second Avenue. Surveyor Davenport Bromfield built one of the oldest houses in Carmel City near this house. Bromfield also helped map out the streets of Carmel City. In 1888, Goldsmith and Hunter carried water from the Carmel River until a well was made. In December 1889, Abbie Hunter bought seven lots in Carmel City from Duckworth. Goldsmith purchased five lots in March 1890. Over time, they each acquired more property. Hotel Carmelo In 1889, Duckworth set aside 5 lots on Broadway Avenue (now Junipero), between 6th Avenue and Ocean Avenue, for Carmel City's first two-story Craftsman-style 18-room Hotel Carmelo (now the present Pine Inn). Goldsmith built the hotel with the help of Hunter and her son, Wesley Hunter. The hotel had 8 bedrooms, a front and back parlor with an open fireplace, a dining room, and a front porch. Visitors would take a horse-drawn carriage called the "Carmel Bus," from the Monterey station to the town. They who came to buy lots and stayed at the hotel. On July 4, 1891, a dance party was the first community event held at the hotel. In 1890, Duckworth printed a subdivision map, showing the hotel, cottages, and lots for sale. Carmel bathhouse In 1888-1889, Hunter and Goldsmith built the first community bathhouse at the end of Ocean Avenue at the Carmel beach, with the help of her son, Wesley Hunter. There was a boardwalk running from the main door to the beach. The bathhouse was built