– "Professional Phone Answerer" (2006–2008) Emily Dunning – intern (Summer 2008) Josh – producer (2006) Recurring segments Notable guests Although Rulli often states he does not like having guests on the show, The Catholic Guy has featured many notable guests throughout its existence: John L. Allen Jr. – journalist Coffey Anderson – singer Kurt Angle – professional wrestler Jay Bakker – televangelist Kelvin Beachum – football player Jim Breuer – comedian Sam Brownback – U.S. Representative, Kansas Mark Burnett – television producer Tia Carrere – actress/model/singer Jim Caviezel – actor Charles J. Chaput – Archbishop of Denver Harry Connick Jr. – singer/actor Tom Cotter – comedian Tom Coughlin – football coach Leah Darrow – model/speaker Robert Davi – actor/singer Gary Dell'Abate – The Howard Stern Show producer Goo Goo Dolls – band Timothy M. Dolan – Cardinal, Archbishop of New York Roma Downey – actress/producer/singer Edward Egan – Cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of New York Emilio Estevez – actor/director/author Jars of Clay – band Joe Eszterhas – screenwriter Jim Florentine – comedian/actor Nick Foles – football player, Super Bowl MVP John Patrick Foley – Cardinal, Grand Master of the Order of the Holy Sepulchre Rob Ford – former Mayor of Toronto Stan Fortuna – priest/musician Kirk Franklin – singer/author Andy García – actor Newt Gingrich – former Speaker of the House Mark-Paul Gosselaar – actor Bear Grylls – television presenter/author Vinny Guadagnino – television personality/actor Pete Holmes – comedian Matt Hughes – mixed martial artist Oscar Isaac – actor Derek Jeter – baseball player Renaldo Lapuz – singer Sugar Ray Leonard – professional boxer Ray Liotta – actor Matt Maher – singer Sebastian Maniscalco – comedian Cheech Marin – comedian/actor/writer Denis McDonough – former White House Chief of Staff Ed McMahon – comedian Chazz Palminteri – actor/author Vincent Pastore – actor Joseph A. Pepe – Bishop of Las Vegas Troy Polamalu – football player Dennis Quaid – actor Al Roker – weatherman/actor/author Mike Rowe – reality television host John Schneider – actor/singer Paul Shaffer – musician/actor Martin Sheen – actor/political activist Joseph Simmons – rapper/reverend Tom Sizemore – actor/producer Luis Antonio Tagle – Cardinal, Archbishop of Manila Tim Tebow – football player Mark Wahlberg – actor Nik Wallenda – daredevil George Wendt – actor Christopher West – author/speaker Lisa Whelchel – actress/speaker Special editions of The Catholic Guy The Catholic Guy broadcast many shows from various locations throughout its incarnation. Prior