again become famous. In the first story, the irony was that the men were in orbit around Vesta with no source of motive power and limited food and air but a year's supply of water. They find a way to use the water as a makeshift rocket in order to reach Vesta, and on the way down they make a toast: "Here's to the year's supply of water we used to have." At the end of this story, they change the toast to "Here's to the Silver Queen souvenirs we used to have." Story notes Asimov notes in his comments on the story that Moore picking up the device had been a throwaway line he included in the original "Marooned Off Vesta". Reception Algis Budrys described "Anniversary" as "a badly contrived stunt". References External links 1959 short stories 4 Vesta Fiction about main-belt asteroids Multivac short stories by Isaac Asimov Works originally published in Amazing Stories