with guitarist David Kennedy before his departure in 2014 and his subsequent return in 2018. Reception The album got a mixed score of 56 out of 100 on Metacritic, and Rolling Stone gave the album a one-and-a-half star review, stating that the album "[soared] ever closer to the sun, with defiant nonsense" and continued to state that although the album sounded exultant, "There's nothing here to be triumphant about". Music website Alter the Press! awarded the album four stars out of five, heralding it as a "welcome addition to the Angels and Airwaves discography" and going on to say it's a "solid, catchy and innovative rock record." According to MTV, the album entered the Billboard 200 charts at number 30 with an estimated 16,000 sales. "Surrender" reached number 35 on the US Alternative Songs chart. Track listing Personnel Band Tom DeLonge – lead vocals, rhythm guitar, keyboards David Kennedy – lead guitar, keyboards, synthesizers, backing vocals on track 10 Matt Wachter – bass guitar, synthesizers, backing vocals Atom Willard – drums, percussion Charts References 2011 albums Angels & Airwaves albums Concept albums Geffen Records albums Albums produced by Tom DeLonge Sequel albums