called it a "sweet-toned swoon". Joe Vogel of The Huffington Post stated that the song was a "great new production by Neff-U", and "the new version retains all of the charm of the original while injecting some fresh elements, including new piano, bass, strings, and vocal effects." Jason Lipshutz, Gail Mitchell and Gary Graff from Billboard thought the song is "the simple sketch eventually led to this blissful love song with its layered vocals and gentle percussion". Michael Roffman of Consequence of Sound praised the track's "incredibly rich instrumentation" and called it "probably the greatest highlight of the album" and "one that felt the most natural, too." Kitty Empire in The Observer said this song was "a breezy bit of froth on which Jackson sounds genuinely carefree". Joe Pareles of the New York Times noted that the new instrumentation compared to the 2004 mix made the "creamy vocal harmonies even more reminiscent of the Beach Boys." Pareles also questioned whether the ending vocals of the song were digitally altered from the original chorus but stated that he preferred the new version, describing it as more "transparent and uncluttered, a little more lighthearted." Negative review came from Dan Martin of NME, he said this song "covers boring mid-tempo R&B territory". Chart performance The song was released as the fourth single from the album, Michael. It debuted on the Italian Airplay Chart on July 17, 2011 at number 86. It has not charted in any other major music charts. Track listing Personnel Written, composed, lead vocal, background vocals and beatbox by Michael Jackson Produced by Theron "Neff-U" Feemster and Michael Jackson Arrangement by Theron "Neff-U" Feemster Piano by Will Champlin Background vocals by Michael Durham Prince Engineered by Michael Prince, James Murray, Charlie Hanes and Tim Roberts Mixed by Serban Ghenea Guitar by Erick Donell Walls Bass by Thomas Drayton Drums by Joe Corcoran and James Porte Percussion by Paulinho da Costa Rhythm by Paulinho da Costa Programming and Finished by Theron "Neff-U" Feemster Release history See also List of unreleased Michael Jackson material Death of Michael Jackson List of works published posthumously References 2011 singles Michael Jackson songs Songs written by Michael Jackson Song recordings produced by Michael Jackson Song recordings produced by Theron Feemster Songs released posthumously Pop ballads Contemporary R&B ballads 2004 songs