"How To" - Lillian, Mary "Prom" - The Christian Jewels, Company "Corithius" - Company Original cast Celia Keenan-Bolger - Mary Mary Faber - Hilary Faye Curtis Holbrook - Roland Van Hughes - Patrick Emily Walton - Tia Morgan Weed - Cassandra Aaron Tveit - Dean Juliana Ashley Hansen - Lana John Dossett - Pastor Skip Julia Murney - Lillian Josh Brekenridge - Shane Jason Michael Snow - Zac Awards and nominations Lucille Lortel Award Outstanding Musical (nomination) Outstanding Choreographer (nomination) References External links Internet Off-Broadway listing Curtain Up review, Elyse Sommer, May 31, 2008 2008 musicals Evangelicalism in popular culture Off-Broadway musicals Musicals based on films Plays by Michael Friedman LGBT-related musicals Musicals based on religious traditions