through the lives of amateur artist Ethan, programmer Lucas and professional gamer Lilah". In 2005, William Kulesa of the Jersey Journal called Penny Arcade and Ctrl+Alt+Del two of the best webcomics, but he felt that the latter was the best overall. He felt that the characters were well-developed, and both had "a sense of fullness often lacked by those found within daily strips. It never fails to draw a chuckle from this reader. Anyone with even a passing familiarity with the land of the nerd will enjoy the strip." He compared the webcomic to Penny Arcade, which he believed required that the reader be more familiar with "nerdy" topics, especially video gaming. Also in 2005, Mariam Asad wrote a piece for the Chronicle Herald showcasing Ctrl+Alt+Del as one of the better webcomics then available, listing several points that the webcomic had that interested her, including its characters, "colourful commentary on recently released games", and storylines that spanned several strips. Criticism Video game journalist Ben "Yahtzee" Croshaw of Zero Punctuation has criticized Ctrl+Alt+Del on several occasions for excessive use of dialogue and slow comic pacing, among other reasons. In 2008 Buckley published the critically-panned strip "Loss", the culmination of a storyline in which Ethan and Lilah were expecting their first child. In the strip Ethan discovers that Lilah's pregnancy had ended in a miscarriage, a significant tonal shift in a comic typically known for humorous situations. In an interview with Joystiq on August 29, 2008, when asked about the comic, Jerry Holkins of Penny Arcade said that "Tim Buckley is the antichrist, and I think [that] storyline was the first horseman of the Apocalypse", while Mike Krahulik stated "I think he's an art criminal." "Loss" later became an internet meme in its own right, with Aryehi Bhushan of Varsity referring to it in 2017 as "infamous" and "the internet's largest meme juggernaut". In April 2010, a new character called Abby was introduced as an antagonist to Ethan. A month later the character's design was found to be copy of a Hector Moran sketch. Buckley issued an apology in light of this and redid the clothing of the Abby character. Popular culture Ubisoft celebrated Winter-een-mas 2011 by offering discounts on purchases of digital download games from their web store. On January 28, 2011, the creators of Ctrl+Alt+Del collaborated with the creators of AdventureQuest Worlds to do a live event. On October 27,