Galleries,' International Studio, Volume 66, Number 264, February, 1919, page cxxvii, John Lane, Company, London (Brief review of Macbeth exhibition with Charles H. Davis) McCormick, William B., 'Paul Dougherty: Rebel to Classification,' Arts and Decoration 8, Pages 251-254, April 1918 (Feature Article) 'Founder's Day Exhibition at the Carnegie Institute' in Notes, American Magazine of Art, July, 1918, American Federation of the Arts, Washington, D.C. (Exhibition of Stimmel Collection, purchased from annual exhibitions including Dougherty) Catalog of Contemporary American Paintings and the Permanent Collection, Memorial Art Gallery, Rochester, New York, Pg. 10, July–September, 1917 (Dougherty's 'Coast of Cornwall' recorded at #4 of Permanent Collection) 'Landscapes and Ocean Scenes by Paul Dougherty' Art Notes, New York Times, December 13, 1916, New York, New York (Review of Dougherty's solo watercolors at exhibition at Macbeth Galleries) 'Exhibition at Mystic,' in Notes, American Magazine of Art, November, 1916, American Federation of the Arts, Washington, D.C. (Notes that Dougherty is among exhibitors in 3rd Annual Exhibition) Brinton, Christian, 'Impressions of Art' at the Panama-Pacific Exposition, John Lane, Company, 1916 (Review of World's Fair Art Exhibition by prominent art writer) 29th Annual Exhibition of American Oil Paintings and Sculpture, The Art Institute of Chicago, Exhibition Catalog, AIC, Chicago, Illinois, 1916 (Dougherty has 'October Morning' in catalog) 'Art in Toledo: American Artists in Toledo,' American Magazine of Art, Vol. 7, Pg 250-1, April, 1916 (Exhibition of American artists including Dougherty) Ward, Felicia, 'Hyblas Bees: An Art Colony in the Catskills,' American Magazine of Art, Volume 7, Pg. 324-7, June 1916, American Federation of the Arts, Washington, D.C. (Article on Catskill colony mentions Dougherty, Carson, Murphy) 'New Items, City Art Museum St. Louis,' American Magazine of Art, Volume 7, Pg. 342, June 1916, American Federation of the Arts, Washington, D.C. ("After the Gale" added to St. Louis permanent collection) 'Art in Youngstown, Loan Exhibition at Mahoning Institute,' American Magazine of Art, Volume 7, Pg. 208, 1916, American Federation of the Arts, Washington, D.C. (Loan exhibition including Dougherty) 'American Paintings Now on Exhibit,' The New York Times, January 16, 1916 (Review of Exhibition of Painter Members of the National Arts Club, including painting by Dougherty) Permanent Collection, 'Bulletin of the Detroit Museum of Art,' Pg. 3,Volume X, No. 5, January, 1916, Detroit Museum of Art, Detroit, Michigan (He is mentioned as an artist they would like to have in permanent collection) 'Landscapes and Ocean Scenes by Paul Dougherty,' New York