no plans to release the video," suggesting that video was created previously when the video was set to premier in 2010 but only just surfaced in May 2011. During an interview with Essence magazine in September 2012, Keys spoke about the video's cancellation, saying: Sometimes with creative things [it] all comes together [...] and sometimes things almost come together and it's better to just leave it. So we love that song. We had a ball shooting the video. It just so happens that the whole thing, for some reason or another, didn't quite come together so we just decided to leave it. And that's what happened. In a September 2020 interview for Stereogum, Keys stated she is trying to find where the video is, aiming to release it as a treat to the fans as she feels "at this point in our lives, since we've been able to do our thing and we all get that was a cool moment between us, we might both be at the place where we can say, 'Let's just throw it out there for fun'". Live performances Knowles joined Keys to perform the song live for the first time on March 17, 2010, at New York City's Madison Square Garden whilst Keys was playing a date from The Freedom Tour. The song was part of the set list only for the North American leg of the tour, sung only on selected dates. Charts Weekly charts Year-end charts Certifications and sales Release history References 2009 songs 2010 singles Alicia Keys songs Beyoncé songs Female vocal duets J Records singles Music videos directed by Melina Matsoukas Song recordings produced by Alicia Keys Song recordings produced by Swizz Beatz Songs written by Alicia Keys Songs written by Swizz Beatz Torch songs