He went on to only miss one match, returning in Fremantle's comeback win against to be among the best players with two goals; however, Fyfe strained the same hamstring at training a few days later, and was expected to miss several matches, before returning in Fremantle's upset win over in Round 9. Fyfe played almost half of the 2021 AFL season before being side lined for three games after injuring his shoulder in Fremantle's Round 12 clash against the Western Bulldogs. Round 17 saw Fyfe play his 200th game, he was arguably best on ground collecting 31 disposals and kicking a goal in Fremantle's 62-point victory over Hawthorn. Fyfe had his season cut short when he reinjured his shoulder in Fremantle's Round 19 clash against Sydney. Fyfe missed the first half of the 2022 AFL season after an off-season shoulder operation impacted his pre-season. Fyfe made his return to football through the WAFL playing for Peel Thunder, Fyfe's first WAFL appearance since the 2010 AFL season. He made his AFL return during Fremantle's round thirteen clash against Hawthorn. Fyfe suffered a hamstring injury during Fremantle's round nineteen clash against which saw him side lined for the next three games, he made his return during Fremantle's round 23 clash against . Fyfe was expected to partake in Fremantle's finals campaign but another hamstring injury sustained during training on the opposite leg of his previous hamstring injury saw him ruled out for the remainder of the season. On 7 February 2023, Fyfe relinquished captaincy of the Club after six seasons as captain. Statistics Updated to the end of the 2022 season. |- | 2010 || || 13 | 18 || 14 || 14 || 173 || 117 || 290 || 82 || 54 || 0.8 || 0.8 || 9.6 || 6.5 || 16.1 || 4.6 || 3.0 || 5 |- | 2011 || || 7 | 21 || 18 || 14 || 253 || 274 || 527 || 111 || 85 || 0.9 || 0.7 || 12.0 || 13.0 || 25.1 || 5.3 || 4.0 || 13 |- | 2012 || || 7 | 11 || 4 || 3 || 157 || 100 || 257 || 44 || 41 || 0.4 || 0.3 || 14.3 || 9.1 || 23.4 || 4.0 || 3.7 || 14 |- | 2013 || || 7 | 22 || 18 || 13 || 339 || 230 ||