and Karen Ziemba as Martha. The tour closed in Boston at the Wang Center on December 29, 2019. Critical response and awards Critics of the Broadway production were unimpressed, including Charles Isherwood of The New York Times, who wrote that the show was as "fresh and appealing as a roll of Necco wafers found in a mothballed Christmas stocking." Nevertheless, the show received two 2009 Tony Award nominations for Best Choreography (Randy Skinner) and Best Orchestrations (Larry Blank). It also received 2009 Drama Desk Award nominations for Walter Bobbie, Outstanding Director of a Musical, Outstanding Choreography, Outstanding Orchestrations, Outstanding Set Design of a Musical (Anna Louizos), Outstanding Costume Design (Carrie Robbins), and Outstanding Sound Design (Acme Sound Partners). Musical numbers Act I "Overture" - Orchestra "Happy Holiday (1944)" - Bob Wallace and Phil Davis "White Christmas (Music Box)" - Bob, Phil, Ralph Sheldrake and Ensemble "Happy Holiday / Let Yourself Go" - Bob, Phil and Ensemble "Love and the Weather" - Bob and Betty Haynes "Sisters" - Betty and Judy Haynes "The Best Things Happen While You're Dancing" - Phil and Quintet "Snow" - Phil, Judy, Bob, Betty, Mr. and Mrs. Snoring Man and Ensemble "What Can You Do With a General?" - Martha Watson, Bob and Phil "Let Me Sing and I'm Happy" - Martha "Count Your Blessings (Instead of Sheep)" - Bob and Betty "Blue Skies" - Bob and Ensemble Act II "Entr'acte" - Orchestra "I Love a Piano" - Phil, Judy and Ensemble "Falling Out of Love Can Be Fun" - Martha, Betty and Judy "Sisters (Reprise)" - Bob and Phil "Love, You Didn't Do Right By Me / How Deep Is the Ocean?" - Betty and Bob "The Old Man (Prelude)" - Bob and Male Ensemble "Let Me Sing and I'm Happy (Reprise)" - Susan Waverly "How Deep Is the Ocean? (Reprise)" - Betty and Bob "The Old Man" - Bob, Phil, Ralph and Male Ensemble "White Christmas" - Bob and Company "I've Got My Love to Keep Me Warm" - Full Company (Post - Curtain Call) Principal roles and Broadway original cast Bob Wallace – Stephen Bogardus (role originated in world premiere by Lara Teeter) Phil Davis – Jeffry Denman (role originated in world premiere by Lee Roy Reams) Betty Haynes – Kerry O'Malley (role originated in world premiere by Karen Mason) Judy Haynes – Meredith Patterson (role originated in world premiere by Lauren Kennedy)