Pompano Beach, Florida, United States | |- | Loss | align=center| 18–23 (2) | Mark George | TKO (injury) | PP: The Real Deal | | align=center| 2 | align=center| 1:33 | Columbus, Georgia, United States | |- | Win | align=center| 18–22 (2) | Logan Clark | KO (punches) | Fight Nation: Guida vs. Clark | | align=center| 1 | align=center| 0:07 | Rochester, Minnesota, United States | |- | Loss | align=center| 17–22 (2) | Jeremy Horn | Submission (arm-triangle choke) | Arena Rumble: Guida vs. Horn | | align=center| 1 | align=center| 4:03 | Spokane, Washington, United States | |- | Loss | align=center| 17–21 (2) | Bobby Lashley | Decision (unanimous) | SRP: March Badness | | align=center| 3 | align=center| 5:00 | Pensacola, Florida, United States | |- | Loss | align=center| 17–20 (2) | Matt Sassolino | Decision (split) | C-3: Domination | | align=center| 3 | align=center| 5:00 | Hammond, Indiana, United States | |- | Loss | align=center| 17–19 (2) | Mamed Khalidov | TKO (strikes) | ShoXC: Elite Challenger Series | | align=center| 2 | align=center| 4:53 | Hammond, Indiana, United States | |- | Loss | align=center| 17–18 (2) | Mike Russow | Submission (guillotine choke) | Adrenaline MMA: Guida vs Russow | | align=center| 1 | align=center| 2:13 | Hoffman Estates, Illinois, United States | |- | Win | align=center| 17–17 (2) | Cristiano Machado | Submission (guillotine choke) | Costa Rica Fights 9 | | align=center| 2 | align=center| 0:18 | Limón, Costa Rica | |- | Win | align=center| 16–17 (2) | Mike Van Meer | TKO (punches) | CFC 2: Explosion | | align=center| 1 | align=center| 0:40 | Tinley Park, Illinois, United States | |- | Loss | align=center| 15–17 (2) | Travis Wiuff | Decision (unanimous) | XFO 14: Xtreme Fighting | | align=center| 3 | align=center| 5:00 | Peoria, Illinois, United States | |- | Loss | align=center| 15–16 (2) | Terry Martin | KO | XFO 13: Operation Beatdown | | align=center| 3 | align=center| 0:08 | Peoria, Illinois, United States | |- | Win | align=center| 15–15 (2) | Antony Rea | Decision (unanimous) | Absolute Fighting Championships 18 | | align=center| 3 | align=center| 5:00 | Boca Raton, Florida, United States | |- | Loss | align=center| 14–15 (2) | Alex Stiebling | Decision (split) | WEC 22: The Hitmen