or a jaded version of the Jonas Brothers now willing to drop the F-bomb." Alex Sheremet of RapReviews wrote that: "In the City offers good production, excellent melodies, and – of course – the same song, idea(s), and kinds of guest appearances many times over. Still, I'd recommend it as a blueprint for potential. It's also good to enjoy on a visceral level, if you're interested in that sort of thing." Rolling Stones Christian Hoard said that despite the Lil Wayne-assisted single, he found the rest of Rudolf's debut to be "a middling rock record dressed up in sleek digital clothes." Evan Sawdey from PopMatters was critical of Rudolf's clumsy lyrical output on being above the dark side of achieving fame and celebrity culture, showing "very little musical variation" beyond the "Let It Rock" formula and felt the "token acoustic tracks ("I Song" and "Scarred")" were interchangeable from each other, concluding that: "If anything, Rudolf does show promise beyond that of just a simple studio session man. He has some solid ideas and keen sense of production; the problem is that his solo songs, by and large, suffer from a frightening lack of creativity and a remarkably shallow lyrical outlook." Pitchfork contributor Ian Cohen panned In the City for taking the dumb parts of "80s corporate rock" without any sense of fun and having "little indication it was constructed by real people in real time." He concluded by sarcastically writing: "But just in case you're taking a half-full approach to Rebirth, you might want to hear this first." Track listing All tracks produced by Kevin Rudolf; track 10 co-produced by The Neptunes Chart performance References 2008 debut albums Kevin Rudolf albums Cash Money Records albums Universal Records albums Albums produced by the Neptunes Electronic rock albums by American artists