Cotton the horse – owned/trained by Ralph McCutcheon 1958 (Starting in 1958 PATSY awards were also awarded to television animals) Motion Pictures Spike the dog (Old Yeller) Beauty the horse (Wild Is the Wind) Kelly the dog (Kelly and Me) Television Lassie the dog (Lassie) Cleo the dog (The People's Choice) Rin Tin Tin the dog (The Adventures of Rin Tin Tin) Award of Excellence Tony the horse (Hoofs and Goofs / Movies) Flicka the horse (My Friend Flicka / TV) Craven Award Trigger the horse – owned by Roy Rogers / trained by Glenn Randall 1959 Motion Pictures Pyewacket the cat (Bell, Book and Candle) Tonka the horse (Tonka) Henry the rabbit (The Geisha Boy) Television Lassie the dog (Lassie) Asta the dog (The Thin Man) Rin Tin Tin the dog (The Adventures of Rin Tin Tin) Award of Excellence King the dog (The Proud Rebel / Movies) Jasper the dog (Bachelor Father / TV) Craven Award Baldy the horse – owned by Fat Jones Stables / trained by William "Buster" Trow 1960 Motion Pictures Shaggy the dog (The Shaggy Dog) Herman the pigeon (The Gazebo) North Wind the horse (The Sad Horse) Television Asta the dog (The Thin Man) Lassie the dog (Lassie) Fury the horse (Fury); Jasper the dog (Bachelor Father) - tied Craven Award Sharkey, Dempsey, Choctaw, and Joker the horses 1961 Motion Pictures King Cotton the horse (Pepe) Spike the dog (A Dog of Flanders) Stubbs the monkey (Toby Tyler); Skip the dog (Visit to a Small Planet) - tied Television Tramp the dog (My Three Sons) Lassie the dog (Lassie) Fury the horse (Fury) 1962 Motion Pictures Orangey the cat (Breakfast at Tiffany's) Pete the dog (The Silent Call) Flame the horse (The Clown and the Kid) Television Mister Ed the horse (Mister Ed) Lassie the dog (Lassie) Tramp the dog (My Three Sons) 1963 Motion Pictures Big Red the dog (Big Red) Sydney the elephant (Billy Rose's Jumbo) Zamba the lion (The Lion) Television Mister Ed the horse (Mister Ed) Lassie the dog (Lassie) Tramp the dog (My Three Sons) Craven Award Mickey O'Boyle the horse 1964 Motion Pictures Tom Dooley the dog (Savage Sam) Pluto the dog (My Six Loves) Raunchy the jaguar (Rampage) Television Lassie the dog (Lassie) Mister Ed the horse (Mister Ed) Tramp the dog (My Three Sons) 1965 Motion Pictures Patrina the tiger (A Tiger Walks) Storm the