its live debut on 13 September 2009 at Soldier Field in Chicago, during the U2 360° Tour. It was subsequently played on some of the North American second leg shows of the tour, and featured pre-recorded vocals from Sinéad O'Connor and a pre-recorded video of astronaut Frank De Winne reciting the song's final verse from the International Space Station. In writing about the live performance in Toronto on 16 September 2009 Mike Doherty of the National Post said, "When you can play music with someone who’s in space, the idea goes, you’re shrinking our corner of the universe down to size." The Richmond Times-Dispatch was less receptive of the song's performance in Charlottesville, Virginia, stating how the song ruined the show's mood and was "a plodding rumination that consumed precious set list space". Track listing Personnel Passengers Bono – vocals Adam Clayton – bass guitar, narration The Edge – guitar, organ Brian Eno – synthesisers Larry Mullen Jr. – drums, percussion Technical Brian Eno – mixing, sequencing Danton Supple – audio engineering References Footnotes Bibliography 1995 songs Songs written by Brian Eno Song recordings produced by Brian Eno Songs written by Bono Songs written by the Edge Songs written by Adam Clayton Songs written by Larry Mullen Jr. Passengers songs