but had to wait until 12 April 2003 for his first and only goal of the season. Scoring the opener in a 4–0 win away at Doncaster Rovers, on the day Yeovil celebrated promotion. The end of the season saw Way called up to the England National Game XI for the Four Nations Tournament, Way appeared in the first two matches, scoring the winner against holders Wales, as England won the title. Way was one of four Yeovil players chosen in the Conference team of the year at the end of season Conference AGM. On 9 August 2003, with club captain Terry Skiverton out injured Way captained Yeovil in their first ever match in the Football League, a 3–1 victory away at Rochdale. In November 2003, Way suffered a stress fracture in his shin bone, the first occurrence of an injury which would plague him later in his career. Yeovil ended their first season in the Football League finishing in eighth place, missing out on a play-off place on goal difference, with Way scoring five times in 44 appearances in all competitions. Way missed only one league match the following season as Yeovil won the League Two title and promotion, at the end of the season Way was one of five Yeovil players in PFA League Two Team of the Year. Way was also part of the Yeovil's historic run to the FA Cup fourth round that season, for only the second time in the club's history, scoring in the 3–0 third round victory away at Championship side Rotherham United. With the run coming to an end losing 3–2 away at Premier League side Charlton Athletic. His first season in League One saw Way make sixteen appearances for Yeovil, before he suffered a fractured cheekbone and eye socket in a match against Gillingham in October 2005. The injury kept him out for a month but Way would only make two more appearances for Yeovil, scoring on his return in the FA Cup victory over Macclesfield Town on 15 November 2005, "with a spectacular shot from distance". In what turned out to be his final match for Yeovil ironically against Swansea City, Way suffered a recurrence of his shin injury which ruled him out until January. In January 2006, Way left Yeovil just a week after his midfield partner Lee Johnson to Hearts, as the Conference winning side began to be