favor of the city of Pleasant Grove No. 07–665 on February 25, 2009. The court found that monuments that were privately funded were considered government speech and therefore not in violation of any one group's First Amendment rights. In his opinion, Justice Samuel Alito analogized that, if the law accorded with Summum and its "civil liberties" supporters, New York City would have been required to accept a Statue of Autocracy from the German Empire or Imperial Russia when it accepted the Statue of Liberty from France. Caldera vs. Microsoft: Case No. 2:96-cv-645 B. This case mirrored the much larger anti-trust case against Microsoft in Washington D.C. Utah based Caldera, Inc. brought the anti-trust suit against Microsoft for the anti-competitive practice of encoding Microsoft Windows 95 to only run properly if MS-DOS, a Microsoft product, was being used. Caldera's claim was that this practice unfairly inhibited the competition by eliminating DR-DOS as an alternative. Judge Benson denied 4 Motions for Summary Judgment by Microsoft to have the case dismissed. The case was eventually settled by the parties. References External links BYU Law Review Crandall Canyon Mine - Deseret News Mineral Leasing Act Secretary of the Interior 1948 births 2020 deaths American soccer players American Soccer League (1933–1983) players J. Reuben Clark Law School alumni Latter Day Saints from Utah American twins United States Attorneys for the District of Utah Judges of the United States District Court for the District of Utah United States district court judges appointed by George H. W. Bush 20th-century American judges Utah Golden Spikers players American Mormon missionaries in Sweden 20th-century Mormon missionaries Benson family American people of Swedish descent Judges of the United States Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court Association footballers not categorized by position Soccer players from Utah People from Sandy, Utah American soccer coaches Deaths from brain cancer in the United States 21st-century American judges