Pleasure Island and Lars' eventual lover Kevin Heffernan as Lars Bronkhorst, a buddhist, pacifist and the recently hired Masseur on Pleasure Island Erik Stolhanske as Sam "Machete Sam" Colletti, the aptly named "Fun Police", in charge of games and activities on Pleasure Island Steve Lemme as Juan Castillo, a Nicaraguan staff member on Pleasure Island, and an athletic divemaster Jay Chandrasekhar as Puttman Livingston, a British staff member and tennis instructor on Pleasure Island Paul Soter as Dave "DJ Dave" Conable, a staff member and the disk jockey for the club on Pleasure island, and Coconut Pete's nephew Bill Paxton as Pete "Coconut Pete" Wabash, a washed-up folk singer, owner of Pleasure Island and Dave's uncle M. C. Gainey as Hank, a southern-accented former director of the FBI Homicide Department, acting as Coconut Pete's bodyguard and best friend Lindsay Price as Yu, a Japanese-American staff member and waitress on Pleasure Island Julio Bekhor as Carlos, the groundskeeper on Pleasure Island Dan Montgomery Jr. as Rollo, a polygamist and staff member on Pleasure Island Elena Lyons as Stacy, an assistant to Putman on Pleasure Island and one of Rolo's girlfriends Tanja Reichert as Kellie, an understudy to Yu, waitress on Pleasure Island and one of Rolo's girlfriends Richard Perello as Cliff, a menial worker on Pleasure Island Ryan Falkner as Marcel, one of the officials on Pleasure Island Other characters Greg Cipes as Trevor, Pleasure Island guest Michael Weaver as Roy, Pleasure Island guest and Manny's best friend Nat Faxon as Manny, Pleasure Island guest and Roy's best friend Samm Levine as Dirk, Pleasure Island guest Jordan Ladd as Penelope, an Alaskan gymnast, Pleasure Island guest and Juan's eventual girlfriend Paco Mauri as Mainland detective Tony Amendola as Mainland detective's partner Soundtrack On one of the disc's commentary tracks the filmmakers state that they screened the film for Jimmy Buffett, who was so amused that he requested permission to sing some of the film's songs on one of his live tours. Critical reception Club Dread received mostly negative reviews. It has a score of 45 out of 100 on review aggregator website Metacritic based on 28 reviews. On Rotten Tomatoes, it has an approval rating of 29% based on 101 reviews. The site's critical consensus reads: "Comedy is too hit-or-miss in this slasher spoof". Dave Kehr of The New York Times wrote that "From Broken Lizard, the comedy troupe that delivered