– Pam, Lizzie, Arlene At Night She Comes Home To Me – Nick, Danny What Could Be Better? (Reprise) – Danny, Lizzie Fatherhood Blues – Danny, Alan, Nick, Mr. Weiss and Dean Romance – Nick, Pam I Chose Right – Danny We Start Today (Reprise) – Company The Story Goes On – Lizzie Act II The Ladies Singin' Their Song – Lizzie, Women in the Town Patterns – Arlene Baby, Baby, Baby (Reprise) – Arlene* Romance (Reprise) – Nick, Pam Easier to Love – Alan The End of Summer - Lizzie, Arlene, Pam** Two People In Love – Danny, Lizzie With You – Nick, Pam*** And What If We Had Loved Like That – Alan, Arlene*** We Start Today (Reprise) – Danny, Lizzie, Nick, Pam, Alan, Arlene The Story Goes On (Reprise) – Company "Baby, Baby, Baby (Reprise)" was replaced in the initial run and the original cast recording with the song "Patterns," wherein Arlene contemplates her circular life as mother and wife. "The End of Summer" was written for the Paper Mill Playhouse production, and is now part of the newly revised score available for licensing. "With You" and "And What If We Had Loved Like That" are in reverse order in the new libretto. Productions The Broadway production, directed by Richard Maltby, Jr. and choreographed by Wayne Cilento, began previews at the Ethel Barrymore Theatre on November 8, 1983, and opened officially on December 4 that same year. It ran for 241 performances and 35 previews before closing on July 1, 1984. The original cast included Liz Callaway as Lizzie Fields, Beth Fowler as Arlene McNally, Todd Graff as Danny Hooper, Catherine Cox as Pam Sakarian, James Congdon as Alan McNally, and Martin Vidnovic as Nick Sakarian. Set design was by John Lee Beatty, costume design by Jennifer von Mayrhauser, and lighting design by Pat Collins. Paper Mill Playhouse in Millburn, New Jersey, presented an updated version of the musical from March 31, 2004 to May 9, 2004. The cast featured Carolee Carmello (Arlene), Chad Kimball (Danny), LaChanze (Pam), Norm Lewis (Nick), Moeisha McGill (Liz), and Michael Rupert (Alan). The updated Paper Mill Playhouse script and score were then finalized for a March 2010 production at TrueNorth Cultural Arts in Sheffield Village, Ohio. This is now the only version licensed by Music Theatre International. The cast was headed by Natalie Green (Lizzie), Shane Joseph Siniscalchi (Danny), Michael Dempsey