| Ebenezer Sage | | Democratic-Republican | 1810 | | Incumbent retired.New member elected.Democratic-Republican hold. | rowspan=2 nowrap | |- | John Lefferts | | Democratic-Republican | 1812 | | Incumbent retired.New member elected.Democratic-Republican hold. |- ! rowspan=2 | | William Irving | | Democratic-Republican | 1813 | Incumbent re-elected. | rowspan=2 nowrap | |- | Jotham Post Jr. | | Federalist | 1812 | | Incumbent retired.New member elected.Democratic-Republican gain. |- ! | Peter Denoyelles | | Democratic-Republican | 1812 | | Incumbent retired.New member elected.Democratic-Republican hold. | nowrap | |- ! | Thomas J. Oakley | | Federalist | 1812 | | Incumbent retired.New member elected.Democratic-Republican gain. | nowrap | |- ! | Thomas P. Grosvenor | | Federalist | 1812 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap | |- ! | Jonathan Fisk | | Democratic-Republican | 1812 | Incumbent re-elected.Incumbent resigned at the beginning of the term, triggering a special election. | nowrap | |- ! | Abraham J. Hasbrouck | | Democratic-Republican | 1812 | | Incumbent retired.New member elected.Democratic-Republican hold. | nowrap | |- ! | Samuel Sherwood | | Federalist | 1812 | | Incumbent retired.New member elected.Federalist hold.Loser successfully challenged the election. | nowrap | |- ! | John Lovett | | Federalist | 1812 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap | |- ! | Hosea Moffitt | | Federalist | 1812 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap | |- ! | John W. Taylor | | Democratic-Republican | 1812 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap | |- ! rowspan=2 | | Zebulon R. Shipherd | | Federalist | 1812 | | Incumbent lost re-election.New member elected.Democratic-Republican gain. | rowspan=2 nowrap | |- | Elisha I. Winter | | Federalist | 1812 | | Incumbent lost re-election.New member elected.Democratic-Republican gain.Successor died before the next term began, triggering a special election. |- ! | Alexander Boyd | | Federalist | 1812 | | Incumbent retired.New member elected.Democratic-Republican gain. | nowrap | |- ! | Jacob Markell | | Federalist | 1812 | | Incumbent retired.New member elected.Federalist hold. | nowrap | |- ! rowspan=2 | | Isaac Williams Jr. | | Democratic-Republican | 1813 | | Incumbent retired.New member elected.Democratic-Republican hold. | rowspan=2 nowrap | |- | Joel Thompson | | Federalist | 1812 | | Incumbent retired.New member elected.Democratic-Republican gain. |- ! | Morris S. Miller | | Federalist | 1812 | | Incumbent retired.New member elected.Federalist