occur in only the loveliest, bluest light." The scenes showing Madonna walking alone on the beach was an homage to actress Joan Crawford in the 1946 film Humoresque. Christopher Rosa from VH1 listed it as one of Madonna's 10 Most Underrated Videos. He compared the blue-tinged visuals to the video for "Frozen", but found the plot to be more complex. Rosa also noted that the ending showing Madonna walking towards the sea was purposefully ambiguous. "Does Madonna drown herself in the ocean? Does she move on from her lover? Whatever the case, there is no denying this moody video is one of Madge's most effective ever," he concluded. The video can be found on the Madonna compilations, The Video Collection 93:99 (1999) and Celebration: The Video Collection (2009). Live performances Madonna first performed "The Power of Good-Bye" on October 23, 1998, during the VH1 and Vogue Fashion Awards, dressed in black latex and leather, accompanied by the children of Opus 118 from The Harlem School of the Arts. On November 12, the singer performed the song on the 1998 MTV Europe Music Awards in Assago, Italy, dressed in black. John Dingwall from Daily Record noted that Madonna "struggled" on delivering the performance, as she seemed nervous. "The Power of Good-Bye" was also one of the few singles that Madonna has performed on the BBC program Top of the Pops, which aired seven days later. On November 23, 1998, she appeared on the Spanish RTVE show Séptimo de caballería and performed "The Power of Good-Bye", along with her European single, "Drowned World/Substitute for Love". Track listings and formats US 7-inch vinyl, cassette, and CD single "The Power of Good-Bye" (Album Version) – 4:10 "Mer Girl" – 5:32 Australian and Japanese maxi-CD "The Power of Good-Bye" – 4:13 "The Power of Good-Bye" (Dallas' Low End Mix) – 4:34 "The Power of Good-Bye" (Luke Slater's Super Luper) – 8:45 "The Power of Good-Bye" (Luke Slater's Filtered Mix) – 6:07 "The Power of Good-Bye" (Fabien's Good God Mix) – 8:22 European 12-inch vinyl "The Power of Good-Bye" (Dallas' Low End Mix) – 4:34 "The Power of Good-Bye" (Luke Slater's Super Luper) – 8:45 "The Power of Good-Bye" (Fabien's Good God Mix) – 8:22 "The Power of Good-Bye" (Album Version) – 4:10 European and UK CD single "The Power Of Good-Bye" (Album Version) – 4:10 "Little Star" – 5:18 Maxi CD single "The Power of