Miami Herald was negative towards the release saying that "Madonna's latest misstep is this pointless Remixed & Revisited seven-track EP in which she tries to resell five songs from her recent American Life CD to an audience who deserve far better efforts from the queen, than this." Ricardo Baca from The Denver Post compared Madonna to actress Drew Barrymore on the cover of the EP, feeling that the singer looked foolish and that the tracks were weak attempts at "spicing up" the already non-commercial songs from American Life. Kevin C. Johnson from St. Louis Post-Dispatch said that with the remixes, Madonna "put some life" back into the songs of American Life, complementing "Your Honesty" and wondering why it was left from the Bedtime Stories sessions. Keith Caulfield of Billboard was impressed with "Your Honesty" and the remixes of "Love Profusion" and "Nobody Knows Me". He said, "Die-hard fans, even those unenamored of American Life will dig this EP." In his book The Essential Rock Discography, Martin Charles Strong called the release as "equally dispensable as its parent album". Commercial performance In the United States, Remixed & Revisited debuted at number 115 on the Billboard 200, selling 22,000 copies in its first week. It also debuted and peaked at number 128 on the Top Comprehensive Albums chart. According to Nielsen SoundScan, the EP has sold 114,000 copies as of August 2005 in the United States. The Nevins' mix of "Nothing Fails" charted on the Canadian Singles Chart at seven and topped the Hot Dance Club Play chart. It also debuted on the album charts of Belgium, in Flanders and Wallonia, and Switzerland. The album charted in Italy as a single, reaching a peak of number two. It also charted in Finland and Denmark as an EP on the singles charts. Track listing Personnel Adapted from the Remixed & Revisited AllMusic credits Production Madonna – producer Mirwais Ahmadzaï – producer (except "Your Honesty") Dallas Austin – producer ("Your Honesty") Ray Carroll – additional production; remixer ("American Life", "Love Profusion") Mount Sims – additional production; remixer ("Nobody Knows Me") Jason Nevins – additional production; remixer ("Nothing Fails") Vin Nigro – additional production ("Nothing Fails") Joe "Magic" – additional production ("Nothing Fails") Soul Diggaz – remixer ("Into the Hollywood Groove") The Passengerz – editor ("Into the Hollywood Groove") Chris Griffin – mixing ("Into the Hollywood Groove") Pat Kraus – mastering Additional musicians Missy Elliott