of the Fab Four's quieter numbers, "Michelle" and "Yesterday", were understandable choices to present to the Mathis audience, but he recalled that it was still not an easy fit. "'I wasn't quite sure how to go about it because their recordings were so minimalist as far as orchestrations and sounded perfect when they did it, but I found it difficult to repeat. But I did get the chance to sing on "Michelle" with John Pisano, who is a great, great guitarist and a wonderfully nice man.'" It was the Mancini-Mercer tune "Moment to Moment", however, that stayed in the Mathis repertoire through the decades and even was performed for a phone-in fan on the A&E Network's 1998 Mathis concert Live by Request. In 2012 Mathis said, "'I used to perform it constantly, but now by the time I get to the end and some of those high notes, I can hardly pull it off anymore.'" ReceptionBillboard proclaimed, "Another superb Mathis performance to delight his multitude of followers," and upon the album's CD release Stephen Thomas Erlewine of Allmusic wrote, "Not only is The Shadow of Your Smile one of Mathis's most popular records, it's one of his strongest." Track listing Side one "Moment to Moment" from Moment to Moment (Henry Mancini, Johnny Mercer) – 2:23 "The Shadow of Your Smile" from The Sandpiper (Johnny Mandel, Paul Francis Webster) – 3:03 "Michelle" (John Lennon, Paul McCartney) – 2:33 "Yesterday" (Lennon, McCartney) – 3:04 "Something's Coming" from West Side Story (Leonard Bernstein, Stephen Sondheim) – 2:50 "A Taste of Honey" (Rick Marlow, Bobby Scott) – 3:09 Side two "I'm in Love for the Very First Time" from An Alligator Named Daisy (Paddy Roberts, Jack Woodman) – 3:15 "Quiet Nights of Quiet Stars (Corcovado)" (Antonio Carlos Jobim, Gene Lees) – 2:26 "I Left My Heart in San Francisco" (George Cory, Douglass Cross) – 2:59 "On a Clear Day (You Can See Forever)" from On a Clear Day You Can See Forever (Alan Jay Lerner, Burton Lane) – 2:43 "Melinda" from On a Clear Day You Can See Forever (Lerner, Lane) – 3:18 "Come Back to Me" from On a Clear Day You Can See Forever (Lerner, Lane) – 2:16 Recording dates From the liner notes for The Complete Global Albums Collection: August 27, 1965: "Come Back to Me", "On a Clear Day You Can See Forever" September 14, 1965: "Melinda" January 12, 1966: